Self-Portrait Holding a Thistle 1493: Introduction
Albrecht Dürer looks out over a small, prickly plant held between his fingers. His shoulders turn towards the right, but his eyes return towards us. A red cap, covered with loose red threads, crowns long golden-brown hair; below the exposed neck, a pale shirt is gathered into fine folds and crossed with narrow reddish bands. Against the dark background, the face and hands become two separate centres of attention. One meets our gaze. The other quietly handles a stem. [1]
At the Louvre, the 1493 portrait, RF 2382, measures 56.5 × 44.5 centimetres; its parchment is glued to canvas. [2]
The picture rewards looking between those two centres. The near cheek broadens into a brightly lit neck, while the far side of the face narrows beside the nose. His mouth remains closed. Small traces of facial hair soften the chin and upper lip without concealing their contours. The eyes are carefully differentiated: one lies nearer the outer edge of the face, and the other is enclosed by the turn towards the viewer. The resulting expression can look watchful, reserved or slightly challenging, depending on where we begin.
At a Glance
- Date 1493 [2]
- Support today Parchment attached to canvas [2]
- Size 56.5 × 44.5 cm [2]
- Collection Louvre, Paris, RF 2382 [2]
This work across Albrecht Dürer’s career
Young Hare
1502Praying Hands
1508Melencolia I
1514Four Apostles
1526Contents
- A carefully prepared appearance
- What does the plant mean?
- The words and the date
- Face and hand in the drawings
- Parchment, restoration and collecting
- The particular character of 1493
- Frequently Asked Questions
A carefully prepared appearance
The clothes are unusually busy beside that still face. On the sleeve at the left, pale fabric swells through openings in the darker outer garment. Red edging follows the shoulder and descends beside the shirt. The shirt's closely spaced folds are gathered at intervals by horizontal bands, which make the rounded chest legible beneath the cloth. There is little empty space inside the figure: each area offers another kind of edge, fold or surface.
Hair and cap carry this play of lines upwards. Individual strands break away from the heavier locks beside the neck. The tassels of the cap spread across the crown and fall loosely at the left, echoing the hair without sharing its golden colour. At the bottom, the plant introduces much sharper angles. Curves and points are repeated across the portrait, but their textures remain distinct: soft hair, gathered cloth, rounded knuckles and the stiff, finely divided edges of leaves.
Dürer's own retrospective family account places this image within a period of travel and change. In William Martin Conway's 1889 English translation, he records leaving home after Easter 1490, following the completion of his training, and remaining away for four years until his father called him back. He returned in 1494 after Whitsuntide. He then records the arrangement of his marriage to Agnes Frey, daughter of Hans Frey, and their wedding on 7 July 1494. [1]
The brevity of that testimony is useful. Dürer supplies the departure, recall and marriage, while leaving the details of the portrait's making unrecorded in these passages. The date 1493 falls within his absence, before the wedding he describes. His statement about the arrangement between the two fathers explains why the approaching marriage belongs in discussions of this picture. It supplies no instruction to paint it, no named recipient and no account of its delivery. [1]
Annotated Details from Self-Portrait, 1493
Compare the turned face, the bands across the shirt and the hands holding the plant.
Details from SELF-PORTRAIT, 1493
Open each detail to follow the different marks used for skin, gathered cloth and pointed leaves.
A turned face and returning eyes
The nose projects towards the right, while the eyes turn back towards us. Curls frame the cheek and ear, with thin bright strands crossing darker locks.
What does the plant mean?
The sprig gives the hands something definite to do. The hand nearer the centre pinches it between thumb and fingers, while a longer stem curves across the other hand at the lower right. Small flower heads and radiating points stand out against the dark ground. The fingers gather closely around a narrow stalk, yet leave the branching upper part clear. The contrast between those enclosing fingers and the plant's sharp silhouette makes a modest action conspicuous.
The marriage interpretation has a long history. Writing in 1909, Louis Réau identified the sprig as eryngium or panicaut and connected its German name, Männertreu , with marital fidelity. He proposed that Dürer sent the picture to Agnes in Nuremberg as a prospective husband's self-presentation. Réau's account is evidence of an established interpretation; its proposed destination remains a hypothesis. [18]
Joan Stack's 2008 study sets the betrothal reading beside Fedja Anzelewsky's alternative: devotion to God, with eryngium understood in relation to Christ's Passion. Stack reports his comparison with other Christian images containing the plant. She also notes divergent translations of the inscription: Jane Campbell Hutchison invokes what is written in the stars, whereas Anzelewsky gives it a religious emphasis. These readings connect the same two details differently. Neither an attractive marriage chronology nor a devotional association recovers a documented commission. The inscription and sprig make the portrait meaningful, but their combination leaves its original occasion open. [19]
Dürer has brought both hands into the narrow lower corner and turned their fingers in different directions. Their overlap creates depth where the dark costume would otherwise flatten into the background. The stem continues the movement outwards, into the open darkness beside the chest. [1]
The words and the date
The Louvre transcribes the words as “My sach die gat / Als es oben schtat.” A close English rendering is “My affairs go as it stands above.” [2]
The date has much greater visual weight than the lettering beside it. Its large, widely separated numerals occupy the darkness over the cap; the two lines of writing are smaller and more tightly grouped. Below them, the bright face seems almost to project from the background. The little verbal statement asks for a different pace of attention from the immediate encounter with the eyes.
Face and hand in the drawings
The ALBERTINA's self-portrait of 1484 shows how early Dürer began examining himself. Made at thirteen, it is drawn in silverpoint on prepared paper. His later inscription identifies the year and says that he used a mirror. The museum notes adjustments at the cap, right arm and forefinger: lightly drawn contours were later reinforced. The pointing hand's destination remains unspecified. [8] [3]
Seen together, the drawing and painting offer a particularly useful comparison of gesture. In the earlier sheet, the raised hand stretches across the lower part of the body towards the right. The long, extended finger continues beyond the other fingertips. In the painting, the hands are lower and more closely grouped, their action contained around the plant. Both images give the face an answering gesture, but the painted fingers have a visible object around which to arrange themselves.
A second comparison comes much closer in date. The Metropolitan Museum's Sheet with a Self-Portrait and Studies of the Artist's Left Hand and a Pillow bears Dürer's date 1493 on the reverse. It is drawn in pen and iron gall ink, with six further pillow studies on the other side. Stijn Alsteens proposes that the isolated hand might relate to the eryngium-holding gesture in the Louvre painting, and brings the ALBERTINA's three-hand sheet into the comparison. His suggestion connects closely observed exercises with a finished portrait, while leaving the preparatory relationship unproved. [20]
On the sheet, the hand is almost as prominent as the head. Hatching curves around the finger joints and darkens the palm. Below, the pillow's abrupt folds enclose rounded, lighter surfaces. Blank paper separates head and hand; their different scales make the three studies conspicuously independent.
The ALBERTINA dates Three Studies of Dürer's Left Hand (26327r) to 1493/94. Its catalogue links the flower-bearing suitor's gesture with the Paris portrait. The other hands point and make the obscene fig sign. The museum sees observation and artistic exercise together. [21]
The upper left hand spreads its fingers around a delicate stem. At the upper right, the fingers close into a compact mass; below, the extended finger makes a long, emphatic direction. The painting adopts its own quieter grouping, bringing two hands together at the end of the arms and keeping the plant upright beside the figure.
The childhood self-portrait sets a long pointing finger beside the face.
Parchment, restoration and collecting
The portrait's physical history enters the record well before its arrival in Paris. In 1899, Theodor von Frimmel described it in his history of Viennese collections. He placed it with Dr Habel at Baden bei Wien during the 1840s and stated that Erasmus Engert transferred the painting, originally on parchment, to fine canvas, backed it with stronger fabric and restored it. This is a historical account of intervention, rather than a modern examination of the surviving paint. [22]
Frimmel also supplies a useful dealer's episode. According to his account, the Viennese dealer Miethke bought the picture outright, and Eugen Felix acquired it from him for a substantial sum. Felix had already owned a copy of the same portrait. Finding the original therefore brought him a second version with a different status. Frimmel distinguishes the two carefully, noting that the copy went to the Leipzig museum. His narrative makes the portrait's survival a matter of changing supports, changing owners and the recognition of originals among copies. [22]
That copy has its own place in the portrait's reputation. Conway reprints Goethe's admiring description of the version he saw, while explicitly identifying it as a copy which Goethe had mistaken for the original. Goethe attended to the red cap, bare neck, embroidered shirt border, sleeve bands, two hands and eryngium. He found the youthful face serious and praised the coherence and finish of the whole. The response is strikingly attentive to the features that still draw the eye, but its object must be kept clear: it records an encounter with a version of Dürer's composition, not an inspection of this painting's surface. [1]
Frimmel's note adds the circumstances: Goethe saw the copy in Beireis's collection at Helmstedt in 1805. Frimmel also says that Thausing's first edition had confused original and copy, a distinction corrected in the second. Such episodes explain why a familiar description cannot automatically establish where the original was located. A portrait can become known through another painter's repetition, then carry that repetition's history into later discussion of the original. [22]
Réau's 1909 article records the original's passage from Felix's collection to Léopold Goldschmidt in Paris and then to Goldschmidt's grandson Nicolas de Villeroy. His praise of the picture's grave, youthful charm belongs to that moment of its reception. He also repeats the Goethe encounter without Conway's clear distinction between copy and original. [18]
The Louvre tentatively lists Imhoff ownership, records Berlin's rejection over restoration and price in 1873 and renewed refusal in 1897, and traces the Felix heirs–Agnew–Goldschmidt–Villeroy succession. Villeroy's property was sequestered under the law of 7 October 1919 concerning enemy nationals. After an unrealised proposed bequest, the museum bought the portrait in March 1922 for 300,000 francs from liquidator Paul Armand, before the collection's auction, paying in instalments. [2]
The particular character of 1493
Stack contrasts the loose waves of 1493 with the organised ringlets in the 1498 Madrid portrait, and discusses the Christ-like appearance of the frontal Munich painting of 1500. [19]
Here, the red threads spread irregularly above the head, the neck remains conspicuously bare, and the two hands handle their little piece of vegetation. The upper part of the figure is still; the fingers and branching plant make a much busier pattern below.
Frequently Asked Questions
Artworks directory
These 187 records include individual works, reverse sides, detail views, paired panels and reconstructed arrangements. Three additional catalogue images repeat works already listed. Related views are not counted as separate originals; qualified attributions and published dating are retained.
Discussion
Look again at the images and ideas explored in Self-Portrait Holding a Thistle 1493. These editorial prompts invite your observations.
Reader Insights
Which detail or idea in Self-Portrait Holding a Thistle 1493 most changed your reading, and why?
How does the discussion of “A carefully prepared appearance” affect your understanding?
What comparison would you bring to the discussion of “The particular character of 1493”?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about Self-Portrait Holding a Thistle 1493 below.
References
- William Martin Conway , Literary Remains of Albrecht Dürer , 1889, pp. 36–38. English, including historical translations from German. View source .
- Musée du Louvre , Portrait de l'artiste tenant un chardon , RF 2382. French. Current collection record. View source .
- Charles Ephrussi, Albert Dürer et ses dessins (Paris: A. Quantin, 1882). Original French edition. View source.
- Moriz Thausing, Albert Dürer: His Life and Works, edited by F. A. Eaton, vol. II (London: John Murray, 1882), pp. 16–18. English edition. View source.
- S. R. Koehler, A Chronological Catalogue of the Engravings, Dry-Points and Etchings of Albert Dürer (New York: Grolier Club, 1897). Original English edition. View source.
- Campbell Dodgson, Catalogue of Early German and Flemish Woodcuts Preserved in the Department of Prints and Drawings in the British Museum, vol. 1 (London: British Museum, 1903). Original English edition. View source.
- Heinrich Wölfflin, Die Kunst Albrecht Dürers, second enlarged edition (Munich: F. Bruckmann, 1908), pp. 110, 298. Original German edition. View source.
- ALBERTINA , Selbstbildnis als Dreizehnjähriger , 4839, including Heinz Widauer's 2003 catalogue text. German and English. View source .
- Metropolitan Museum, Four Horsemen from The Apocalypse, 19.73.209 (English). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Selbstbildnis im Pelzrock, inv. 537 (German). View source.
- ALBERTINA, Feldhase, inv. 3073 (German). View source.
- ALBERTINA, Das große Rasenstück, inv. 3075 (German). View source.
- Metropolitan Museum, Adam and Eve, 19.73.1 (English). View source.
- ALBERTINA, Betende Hände, inv. 3113 (German). View source.
- Metropolitan Museum, Knight, Death, and the Devil, 43.106.2 (English). View source.
- Metropolitan Museum, Melencolia I, 43.106.1 (English). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen – Alte Pinakothek München, Vier Apostel: Hll. Johannes Ev. und Petrus, 1526, inv. 545 (German). View source.
- Louis Réau , “Les portraits de Dürer par lui-même”, Gazette des beaux-arts , 1909, pp. 110–111. French. View source .
- Joan Stack , “Albrecht Dürer's Curls: Melchior Lorck's 1550 Engraved Portrait and Its Relationship to Dürer's Self-Fashioned Public Image”, Muse 42, 2008, pp. 48–51, notes 20–21, p. 68. English. View source .
- Stijn Alsteens , catalogue 6, Dürer and Beyond: Central European Drawings in The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 1400–1700 , 2012, pp. 12–16. English. View source .
- ALBERTINA , Drei Studien von Dürers linker Hand , 26327r, including Maria Luise Sternath's 2003 catalogue text. German and English. View source .
- Theodor von Frimmel , Geschichte der Wiener Gemäldesammlungen , I.1, 1899, pp. 54–55 and notes. German. View source .
- Burlington Fine Arts Club, Exhibition of Early German Art (London: Burlington Fine Arts Club, 1906). Original English catalogue. View source.
- Joseph Heller, Das Leben und die Werke Albrecht Dürer’s, vol.II, part1 (Bamberg: C.F.Kunz, 1827), p.118, no.138. Original German edition. View source.
- Johann Carl Sigmund Kiefhaber, ed., Nachrichten zur ältern und neuern Geschichte der freyen Reichsstadt Nürnberg: ein Beytrag zur Geschichte der Reichsstädte in Teutschland, vol.1 (Nuremberg: Lechner, 1803), first quarter, pp.6–9,14–16. Original German historical edition of correspondence and inventory. View source.
- Maud Cruttwell, Andrea Mantegna, London: George Bell and Sons, 1901, pp. 110–112. View source.
- Moriz Thausing, Dürer: Geschichte seines Lebens und seiner Kunst (Leipzig: E. A. Seemann, 1876). Original German edition. View source.
- T. Sturge Moore, Albert Dürer (1905), part III, Munich self-portrait discussion. Original English edition; Project Gutenberg eBook9837. View source.
- Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Barbara Dürer (German and English). View source.
- Web Gallery of Art, Tucher–Rieter reverse (English). View source.
- National Gallery of Art, Portrait of a Clergyman (English). View source.
- Dürer Art, Portrait of a Man (English). View source.
- Hessen Kassel Heritage, Elsbeth Tucher (German). View source.
- Web Gallery of Art, Hans Tucher (English). View source.
- Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Emperor Maximilian I (German and English). View source.
- National Gallery of Art, Lot and His Daughters, reverse (English). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Glim Lamentation (German). View source.
- Museo Nacional del Prado, Portrait of a Man (Spanish). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Madonna of the Carnation (German). View source.
- Städel Museum, Job on the Dungheap (German). View source.
- Wallraf-Richartz-Museum, Piper and Drummer (German). View source.
- Italian Ministry of Culture / Uffizi, Head of Saint James (Italian). View source.
- Klassik Stiftung Weimar, Dresden Altarpiece (German). View source.
- Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, Girl with a Red Beret (German and English). View source.
- Dresden State Art Museums / Roland Enke, Bernhard von Reesen (German). View source.
- Royal Collection Trust, Burkhard von Speyer (English). View source.
- Dresden State Art Museums, Seven Sorrows of the Virgin (English). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Mater Dolorosa (German). View source.
- Bayerische Staatsgemäldesammlungen, Lucretia (German). View source.
- Städel Museum, Young Woman with Her Hair Down (English). View source.
- ALBERTINA, Portrait of a Young Man (German). View source.