Buy Art Prints Nowfrom Amazon
* As an Amazon Associate, and partner with Google Adsense and Ezoic, I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Just Judges: the missing Ghent Altarpiece panel
The riders at the far left of the opened Ghent Altarpiece approach the Soldiers of Christ and the central Mystic Lamb. Their panel is the Just Judges. Its place remains occupied, but its original painting does not: the Van Eyck panel was stolen in 1934 and remains missing. Saint Bavo’s Cathedral identifies the image now displayed as Jef Van der Veken’s twentieth-century copy. The distinction is fundamental to looking at this corner of the altarpiece.[1]
The replacement preserves a procession of mounted men beneath a rocky landscape and distant buildings. It allows the lower register’s movement towards the Lamb to remain legible. Yet its colours, brushwork and physical support belong to a later object. Earlier copies, historical photographs and even X-rays taken before the theft provide other evidence for the lost painting. The historical photograph and the published colour image of the replacement offer distinct starting points for comparison.[19][20]
At a Glance

Compare different witnesses to the lost panel
Details from The Just Judges: the missing Ghent Altarpiece panel
Historical photograph: original Judges at left
Left: the lost original Judges. Right: the Knights of Christ. Historical black-and-white witness, not a current installation. KIK-IRPA, cliché C001029, CC BY 4.0. Unmodified published 640 × 800 image; no capture year asserted.
Original panel: Burroughs’s pre-theft X-ray
Original: 1926–1927 X-ray, Alan Burroughs. Published 2008, p. 284, © Harvard Museum of Art. Unmodified page.
Replacement: the 1986 X-ray
Replacement: 1986 X-ray, Guido Van de Voorde. Published 2008, p. 285. Unmodified page.
Justice within the procession
The Vlaamse Kunstcollectie’s Dutch record explains the subject as righteous administrators. These are people exercising government justly, rather than judges shown hearing a particular court case. The record also makes the loss explicit: its 1432 ensemble attribution must be distinguished from the copy visible today. The title describes a moral quality of public authority. It does not establish that the group consists of a documented set of Ghent magistrates gathered on one historical occasion.[2]
Position reinforces that meaning. The riders enter from the altarpiece’s outer edge, while their neighbours carry the standards and armour of military service. On the opposite side, other groups approach the same sacred centre. The Judges do not constitute a separate courtroom or a secular portrait gallery attached to an otherwise religious painting. They participate in a shared act of approach, bringing the responsibilities of worldly government into the vision of the redeemed community.
The subject’s name is also part of the frame programme. KIK-IRPA’s 2020 study discusses the identifying inscriptions for Judges and Knights alongside those on the exterior. It draws attention to recurring letter forms and to the interior’s black archaising capitals on gold. The inscriptions were designed to work with the pictures, rather than merely functioning as modern museum labels. Their relationship to the exterior texts helps establish the coherence of the ensemble’s written programme.[3]
That evidence supports reading the company collectively as the Just Judges. It does not name every face or authenticate the paint of the replacement. A frame can retain an historical subject while the image occupying its opening changes. Here the label and the surviving physical picture have different histories. Understanding their relationship is part of understanding the panel itself.
Horses, dress and the direction of attention
In the replacement, the nearest rider wears a deep blue robe with pale fur at the sleeves and hem. He sits on a white horse whose elaborate harness repeats bright circular ornaments. His hand closes around the reins, while the animal’s lifted leg gives the group a measured forward rhythm. The large pale body provides an anchor beneath a crowded succession of faces and headgear.
Behind him, a man in a red cap and light fur collar rides beside darker clothing and another horse’s warm brown head. Hats alternate between soft folds, rounded shapes and firmer projecting brims. Faces turn in different directions, so that the procession is not simply a sequence of identical profiles. The density of clothing and overlapping bodies makes status visible through surfaces and gestures rather than through a single emblem held by every member.
Weale’s account, published in 1912 while the original still existed, describes an elderly rider on a white horse with jewelled trappings. He singles out another man wearing a dark head covering, fur-trimmed clothing and a red rosary, whose head turns away from the main direction of travel. His description supplies a pre-theft witness for conspicuous details. It should be read alongside the photograph of the lost panel, rather than silently substituted for a technical examination of the replacement.[4]
The landscape above creates a different pace of looking. Woodland opens behind the men, while a jagged cliff rises to the right. Buildings appear beyond the trees and rocky ledge, with spires interrupting the sky. In the copy, the group’s compressed foreground therefore gives way to a more extended, inhabited distance. That change of scale joins the riders to a world beyond their immediate path without identifying a particular journey undertaken by named officials.
Were Hubert and Jan among the riders?
The most persistent portrait tradition concerns the painters themselves. Weale traces the identification of two Judges as Hubert and Jan to Lucas de Heere’s sixteenth-century poem, displayed beside the altarpiece. He explains how the claim circulated through later writers and reproduced likenesses. The history is significant even though it does not establish the identities: a proposed face inside the masterpiece became a way for later generations to imagine its makers.[4]
Sarah Helen Meiers’s 2002 study of Hieronymus Cock’s engraved artist portraits follows this process into print. She explains that the supposed Van Eyck likenesses were drawn from the Judges and that the legend was established by the 1560s. Her discussion distinguishes that established tradition from acceptance of the riders as actual portraits of the brothers. A widely reproduced image can acquire historical authority through repetition without gaining contemporary documentation.[5]
Pierre Colman makes the caution particularly explicit in his French study available through Persée. Discussing the figure with a rosary over his shoulders, he rejects the old identification as Jan and questions assumptions drawn from Italian painters’ appearances in religious scenes. His objection concerns an argument about artistic self-representation, not a discovery of a different securely named sitter. The responsible caption therefore describes a rider traditionally identified as the painter, rather than presenting that identity as fact.[6]
Individuality remains visible even when a name cannot be supplied. A turned head, distinctive hat or unusual expression can be essential to the picture’s effect without becoming proof of a portrait. The missing original makes caution especially necessary: comparing a face in the modern replacement with a later print may simply compare two descendants of the same uncertain tradition.
A sixteenth-century witness by Michiel Coxcie
The Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium preserve an earlier copy of the Judges by Michiel Coxcie, inventory 6696. Their Dutch catalogue dates it to 1557–1559 and connects it with Philip II’s commission to copy the altarpiece. Its recorded visible dimensions, 147 by 51 centimetres, belong to Coxcie’s wooden panel. They should not be printed as measurements of the missing original or Van der Veken’s replacement.[7]
Watch: Jan van Eyck in context
Choose a Smarthistory close reading of the Arnolfini Portrait or the closed and opened Ghent Altarpiece.
Jan van Eyck, The Ghent Altarpiece (2 of 2)
Follow the heavenly figures and the gathering around the Lamb when the wings open.
Watch on YouTubeThe same record identifies Saint John the Evangelist on Coxcie’s reverse. This is particularly useful evidence of the copy’s independence: the lost original Judges had formed a pair with the exterior John the Baptist, not this Evangelist. Coxcie’s version can preserve the broad arrangement of riders while altering another part of the double-sided structure. Its importance as an early witness does not make it an exact substitute for every feature of the original ensemble.[7]
KIK-IRPA’s exterior study similarly treats Coxcie’s altarpiece as comparative evidence and records differences in panel measurements. The surviving copy belongs to a different moment of making. Agreement between it and a historical photograph can strengthen an account of the composition; disagreement requires investigation into the copyist’s choices, subsequent treatment and photographic conditions. Neither outcome restores access to the vanished original paint layers.[3]
Why two painted faces could be stolen
The theft becomes clearer when the shutter’s physical history is kept in view. KIK-IRPA traces the side wings, excluding Adam and Eve, from their sale in 1816 to Berlin in 1821. In 1894, their painted fronts and backs were sawn apart. This allowed both painted faces to be displayed simultaneously. The wings returned to Ghent in 1920. The Judges and its former Baptist reverse could consequently be removed as separate paintings by the time of the theft.[8]
This is a history of a transformed wooden object, rather than merely of an image moving between owners. Before separation, opening and closing the wing changed which subject the viewer encountered. After separation, each painted face had its own support history and could suffer a different fate. The return of the Baptist therefore did not entail the return of the Judges. Nor is the recovered exterior saint a modern invention accompanying Van der Veken’s replacement.
The documented theft and ransom
The City of Ghent dates discovery of the loss to 11 April 1934. Its account describes the disappearance of both paintings from the Vijd Chapel and a note invoking the Treaty of Versailles. On 30 April, a ransom letter signed D.U.A. demanded one million Belgian francs. The correspondent later supplied a luggage-depot receipt through which the John the Baptist panel was recovered at Brussels-North station. The apparent German grievance was part of the presentation of the crime, not proof of official German responsibility.[9]
The same account describes a failed payment arrangement using an intermediary and the eventual discovery of copies of the ransom letters among Arsène Goedertier’s papers. Shortly before his death, Goedertier claimed to know where the Judges was hidden. That claim did not recover the painting or establish its subsequent fate. The missing object remains the decisive limit: correspondence, recollection and a proposed location are not equivalent to finding and identifying the original panel.[9]
The theft can dominate interpretation, but the objects constrain the story: one painted face returned and one did not. The replacement filled a visible gap; older photographs and copies supplied other witnesses. An unverified theory does not change those distinctions.
Van der Veken’s reconstruction and its dates
KIK-IRPA’s French 2010 dossier records work begun in Brussels in 1939 using Coxcie’s copy, resumed in 1945, and adjusted in 1950–1951. Colour-test strips and wax helped Van der Veken match the ensemble.[10]
Other institutional labels capture different dates. The cathedral and Vlaamse Kunstcollectie call it a 1939 copy; BALaT catalogues 1939–1940; KIK-IRPA’s 2019 press dossier captions it as 1945. The documented interruptions and later modifications explain why one short date is inadequate, although they do not establish precisely what every catalogue label intends. It is safest to identify the maker and describe the work as a twentieth-century reconstruction begun in 1939, with subsequent development.[1][2][13][14]
BALaT also records Van der Veken’s painted signature and a Dutch inscription invoking love, duty and retaliation for ill treatment. The words make the replacement’s maker present in an unusually personal way. They belong to this modern object, not to the Van Eycks’ commission. Their existence is another reason to treat the copy as an historical artefact with its own evidence rather than merely as a transparent window onto a lost painting.[13]
What the X-rays establish
The original is unavailable for new sampling, but its technical record did not disappear entirely. Catherine Fondaire and Dominique Vanwijnsberghe published a comparison between Alan Burroughs’s 1926–1927 X-ray of the original and Guido Van de Voorde’s 1986 examination of the copy. The earlier image records a cradle behind the original; the replacement lacks it. The copy also shows a dowel and a different pattern of wood grain and paint handling. The authors conclude that the original is not concealed beneath Van der Veken’s painting.[11]
The old X-ray preserves structural evidence, although it cannot supply colour or permit new sampling.
The KIK’s 2005 catalogue adds another distinction. It describes Van der Veken’s egg-based reconstruction in the context of his belief that he had recovered the early painters’ technique. It contrasts that belief with the 1951 findings of an oil-based binder in the original altarpiece. This is a history of an attempted technical reconstruction and its reassessment. A successful visual resemblance should not be treated as proof that the same materials and working sequence were used.[12]
Conserving a modern replacement
Serious paint lifting required urgent refixing in 2010. Imaging and microsamples informed treatment of the replacement’s complex materials. Conserving this modern painting did not uncover a hidden Van Eyck.[10]
KIK-IRPA’s later lower-register documentation keeps this treatment separate from the 2016–2019 campaign on the surviving originals. Its caption identifies the replacement as conserved in 2010. Figures for old overpaint or newly uncovered fifteenth-century colour on the Soldiers, Hermits, Pilgrims and Lamb should consequently not be transferred to the Judges. Their neighbouring positions do not give the paintings the same material history.[14]
The colour relationship has nevertheless changed around the copy. In her first-hand account of the exhibition space, Maaike Blancke explains that Van der Veken matched an ensemble darkened by yellowed varnish. Cleaning the originals restored a different blue to their skies. She describes a blue spotlight used to help the Judges fit visually with its neighbours. That is a presentation decision, not a repainting of the copy or evidence for the original sky’s exact colour.[15]
The replacement’s archive and the panel’s continuing life
The RKD in the Netherlands preserves Van der Veken’s working archive. Its 2024 account describes drawings, paintings, exercises, documentation and tools as evidence of how he worked. The material opens questions about copying and restoration through surviving practice, rather than judging the replacement only by whether it looks convincing from the cathedral floor. An archive of the later maker can explain the modern object without answering every question about the lost medieval one.[16]
CODART’s 2014 notice connects acquisition of that archive directly with the Judges replacement and its continued place in the altarpiece. It also acknowledges the tension in Van der Veken’s reputation as both a skilled conservator and a maker of deceptive works. That background warrants careful attribution. It does not turn this openly identified reconstruction into proof of a concealed original or a solved theft.[17]
The loss continues to generate new art. Ghent’s 2026 exhibition devoted to Koen Broucke’s artistic investigation brought paintings, drawings, objects and archival material into a search around the Judges. The city’s announcement described an artist and historian exploring the case, not an announcement that the original had been found. Such projects document the panel’s continuing cultural presence while leaving the historical disappearance unresolved.[18]
Looking again at the visible riders, begin with their shared destination and then distinguish the witnesses that make them available. The replacement restores a passage through the altarpiece. Coxcie preserves an earlier interpretation; historical photography records the lost design; pre-theft X-rays preserve limited material evidence. Each contributes something different. Their value increases when the visible painting is clearly named as Van der Veken’s work and the absent original remains recognised as an irreplaceable loss.
Discussion
What do you notice in The Just Judges: the missing Ghent Altarpiece panel? Share a close observation or a source that adds useful context.
Join the Conversation
Keep observations specific and evidence clear.
References
- Saint Bavo’s Cathedral, Dutch panel guide, XVI, loss in 1934 and Van der Veken copy. View Source
- Vlaamse Kunstcollectie, “De Rechtvaardige Rechters,” administrators, panel position and replacement. View Source
- Bart Fransen and Cyriel Stroo, editors, The Ghent Altarpiece: Research and Conservation of the Exterior, 2020, p. 297 and Coxcie comparison. View Source
- W. H. James Weale, The Van Eycks and Their Art, 1912, pp. 47–48 and 230–231, pre-theft description and portrait tradition. View Source
- Sarah Helen Meiers, Artists in Print: Hieronymus Cock and His 1572 Series of Engraved Portraits, Queen’s University MA thesis, 2002, p. 40, RKD digital copy. View Source
- Pierre Colman, “À la recherche d’un autoportrait de Jan van Eyck,” 2012, pp. 81–82, French original through Persée. View Source
- Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, Michiel Coxcie, Judges with Saint John the Evangelist on the reverse, 1557–1559, inventory 6696. View Source
- KIK-IRPA, upper-register project account, side-wing sale, splitting and return. View Source
- City of Ghent, “The disappearance of the Just Judges panel,” theft, ransom correspondence and Goedertier. View Source
- KIK-IRPA, Rendez-vous avec les Juges intègres, 4 June 2010, pp. 3, 7–9, reconstruction chronology and urgent conservation. View Source
- Catherine Fondaire and Dominique Vanwijnsberghe, “Van der Veken et Van Eyck aux rayons X,” 2008, pp. 283–286, original excerpt reproduced in KIK-IRPA’s 2010 dossier, PDF pp. 10–13. View Source
- KIK-IRPA, De zaak Van der Veken, 2005, pp. 5–6, egg-based reconstruction and reassessment of early Netherlandish technique. View Source
- KIK-IRPA BALaT, object 23, Van der Veken replacement, dates and inscriptions. View Source
- KIK-IRPA, lower-register press dossier, 17 December 2019, p. 16, photograph 22, copy and 2010 treatment. View Source
- Maaike Blancke, “A new exhibition space for the Ghent Altarpiece,” colour matching and display lighting. View Source
- RKD, “Echt nep of net echt? Vervalsingen in de schilderkunst,” 2024, archive contents and research into working practice. View Source
- CODART, “Crowdfunding for Van der Veken,” 10 September 2014, archive acquisition and acknowledged replacement. View Source
- City of Ghent, Koen Broucke exhibition announcement, 30 March 2026, artistic and archival investigation. View Source
- KIK-IRPA BALaT, photograph C001029, historical photograph of the original Judges and neighbouring Knights. View Source
- Lukas–Art in Flanders, Van der Veken replacement, published whole-panel photograph and rights. View Source







 Jan van Eyck.jpg)
 Jan van Eyck.jpg)



