The Balcony Rene Magritte Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on October 14, 2023
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

The Balcony

Three brightly lit coffins occupy the balcony in René Magritte’s The Balcony. One bends forward over the seat of a chair. Two stand upright behind and beside it, while a fourth dark shape stands deeper inside the opening. The green railing runs across all of them. We stand in front of a group that has the arrangement of a portrait and the stillness of furniture.

The Museum of Fine Arts Ghent holds this oil on canvas as Perspective II. Manet’s Balcony, inventory 1961-A. Its collection record gives circa 1950, and the inscription on the reverse includes the year 1950 and the number II. The Flemish Art Collection identifies it as the second version, following one made in 1949. The balcony and its arrangement come from Édouard Manet’s Le Balcon, painted in 1868–69 and now in the Musée d’Orsay. [1] [2] [3]

At a Glance

  • Catalogue titlePerspective II. Manet’s Balcony
  • DateCirca 1950, with 1950 inscribed on the reverse
  • MediumOil on canvas
  • CollectionMuseum of Fine Arts Ghent, 1961-A

Selected works

Year
192519451970

The Gradation of Fire

1938 or 1939 in the catalogue index

The Balcony

Circa 1950, with 1950 inscribed on the reverse

Contents

  1. The railing and the figures behind it
  2. What Magritte kept from Manet
  3. From a sketchbook to the second version

The railing and the figures behind it

The railing is the first continuous line across the scene. Two green bars cross the coffins at about the same level, and diagonal rods form a repeating pattern beneath them. The rods pass in front of the objects and the chair and cut across the open space below. This gives the balcony a definite front edge. Everything else gains a place in relation to that edge, even when the dark interior supplies few clues to the depth of the room.

The shutters do a similar job at either side. Their repeated horizontal slats mark the edges of the opening. The left shutter is broader in view, while the right occupies a narrow strip. In the lower left corner, a potted plant gives a smaller point of reference. Its leaves and flowers break the hard lines of the ironwork. The pot sits low enough to make the coffins behind it look tall. Those ordinary details hold the setting together while the group becomes more difficult to read as part of a domestic scene.

The nearest coffin has the most unusual shape. A broad upright section comes down to a bend close to the railing. The lower part angles outward over the seat and down towards the floor. This is close to the position of a body sitting on a chair. The dark chair is visible at the side and between the rods. We can see enough of it to recognise how a seated figure would be supported. The straight boards and visible fastenings turn the bends of that pose into something we can follow as a construction.

The two brighter upright coffins give the seated one a scale. The back one rises above the others, with its top set against the darkness. At the right, the pale edge of another catches the light near the shutter. The fourth is much less distinct. It sits to the left in the dark opening and is easier to see once we have recognised the outlines of the three in front. The distribution of light gives a sense of people standing at different depths, even though we are looking at objects that show no expressions or gestures.

Watch: Understanding Magritte

Three complementary films introduce the artist, explore words and images, and examine a painting’s materials. These are broader Magritte comparisons, alongside the work discussed here.

What Magritte kept from Manet

In Manet’s painting, Berthe Morisot sits at the front left, with Fanny Claus and Antoine Guillemet behind the railing. Another figure is barely visible in the interior. The Musée d’Orsay notes that the painting puzzled viewers at the Salon of 1869. The people appear together without an obvious exchange between them. Their positions, the green ironwork and the dark opening are enough to give the scene its structure. [3]

Comparing the two pictures shows how much of that structure Magritte keeps. The potted plant still has its place at the bottom left, and the shutters still carry the green of the railing upwards. The main alteration comes where we would expect heads, clothes and hands. Magritte gives each coffin a position that can still be compared with a pose. The seated one retains the bending outline of the figure at the front. The more distant shape can be found in roughly the same part of the shadows as Manet’s fourth figure. Recognising the source makes it possible to read a group of objects as a set of replacements, one position at a time. [1] [3]

The wood surface also changes what we can learn by looking at each place. The coffins have differences of height, angle and light, and the fastenings pick out their construction. Manet’s figures give us faces and clothing that can be followed one by one. Magritte’s group depends on the surrounding picture and on the turns of the wood for much of its individuality. Look at the repeated metal studs and the same details that make the coffins resemble one another also help us see which surface faces the light.

The light also changes how the group separates from the interior. In Manet, pale clothes occupy large areas along the railing and dark clothing partly merges with the doorway. Magritte gives much of that contrast to the boards. The two sides of an upright coffin can look quite different where they meet at a ridge. The nearest coffin has a bright front and a darker side that nearly disappears into the chair. The coffins begin to look less alike when we follow those small differences in illumination. A single lighted plane might seem to point straight out at us, while another angles into the room. Those shifts in direction take the place of some of the differences among the figures in Manet. [1] [3]

From a sketchbook to the second version

Ghent also holds a sketchbook sheet with studies for the composition. Its account says that one of the studies contains two coffins, with one placed on the other’s lap. The idea was therefore tried with a different arrangement before the four positions became part of the version shown here. The museum groups the oil with Magritte’s Perspective paintings, in which coffins take the places of figures in existing works. On this balcony the rail and the chair do much of the work of making the change visible. They tell us where the group would sit and stand. The form of each coffin gives us something we can compare with that remembered position. [1] [4]

Magritte artworks directory

100 records

NameDateMedium
Memory of a Voyage1963Oil on canvas
The Blood of the World1927; also catalogued as 1926–27Oil on canvas
The Hunters at the Edge of NightParis, 1928Oil on canvas
The Empty Picture Frame (La saignée)1938–39Gouache on paper
The Glass House1939Gouache on paper
Oasis1926 in the illustrated Christie’s catalogueOil on canvas
Natural Encounters1945Oil on canvas
Attempting the Impossible1928Oil on canvas
On the Threshold of Liberty1930Oil on canvas
The Titanic Days1928Oil on canvas
The Voice of Space1931Oil on canvas
Unexpected Answer1932 in the museum catalogue, 1933 on the reverseOil on canvas
Elective Affinities1932 in MoMA’s checklist, also published as 1933Oil on canvas
The Human Condition II1935Oil on canvas
The Six Elements1929Oil on canvas
The Happy Donor1966Oil on canvas
Clairvoyance (Self Portrait)Brussels, 1936Oil on canvas
Philosopher’s Lamp1936Oil on canvas
The AnnunciationParis, 1930Oil on canvas
The Lost JockeyCirca 1942 in the illustrated lot catalogueGouache on paper laid down on canvas
Homage to Mack Sennett1936 in the Thyssen catalogueOil on canvas
Discovery1927Oil on canvas
Collective Invention1935 in the later catalogue indexOil on canvas
The Wonders of Nature1953Oil on canvas
The BalconyCirca 1950, with 1950 inscribed on the reverseOil on canvas
The Pilgrim1966Oil on canvas
The Invention of Life1928Oil on canvas
The Therapist1941Gouache on paper
The Gradation of Fire1938 or 1939 in the catalogue indexGouache on paper
A Friend of Order1964Oil on canvas
The Poetic World1939 in Hammacher’s illustrated monographGouache
The Muscles of the SkyParis, 1927Oil on canvas
The Battle of the Argonne1959Oil on canvas
Meditation1936Oil on canvas
The Domain of Arnheim1962Oil on canvas
This Is Not an Apple1964Oil on Unilite
The Meaning of NightBrussels, 1927Oil on canvas
The Pleasure Principle (Portrait of Edward James)1937Oil on canvas
Ready Made Bouquet1957Oil on canvas
Popular Panorama1926Oil on canvas
Memory of a Journey1955 in the Thyssen catalogue. Tentatively 1958 in the catalogue index.Gouache on paper, as exhibited at the Thyssen
Sheherazade1947Gouache on paper
The Difficult Crossing1926Oil on canvas
The Fair Captive1948 in the catalogue raisonnéOil on canvas
The Birth of the Idol1926Oil on canvas
Hegel’s Holiday1958Oil on canvas
Homesickness1941Oil on canvas
The Rape (Le Viol)1934Oil on canvas
The Art of Living1967Oil on canvas
Secret Life IV1928Oil on canvas
The Tomb of the Wrestlers1960Oil on canvas
Young Girl Eating a Bird (The Pleasure)1927Oil on canvas
The Central Story1928Oil on canvas
The Seducer1953Oil on canvas
The Telescope1963Oil on canvas
The Banquet1958Oil on canvas
The Empty Mask1928Oil on canvas
The Cultivation of Ideas1927Oil on canvas
The Enchanted Pose1927Oil on canvas
The Future of Statues1937Oil on plaster
The Return of the Flame1943Oil on canvas
The White Page1967Oil on canvas
The Large Family1963Oil on canvas
Black Magic1945Oil on canvas
Les Amants I1928Oil on canvas
Man in a Bowler Hat1964Oil on canvas
The Portrait1935Oil on canvas
The Sixteenth of September1956Oil on canvas
Heartstrings1960Oil on canvas
The Present1939; also dated 1938 or 1939Gouache on paper
Act of Violence1932Oil on canvas
Fashionable People1950, in the 2016 thesis captionMedium unconfirmed · Attribution follows the published caption
The Representation1962Oil on canvas
Memory1948Gouache on paper
The Mysteries of the Horizon1955Oil on canvas
Portrait of Stephy Langui1961Oil on canvas
The Double Secret1927Oil on canvas
Every Day1966Oil on canvas
The Invisible World1954Oil on canvas
Dawn of Cayenne1926Oil painting
Clear Ideas1955 (inscribed); possible 1958 executionOil on canvas
The Face of Genius1926 / 1927Oil on canvas
Good Faith1965; earlier record 1964–65Oil on canvas
The Flash1959Gouache and pencil on paper
Perpetual Motion1935; earlier catalogue 1934Oil on canvas
Personal Values1952Oil on canvas
Not to Be Reproduced1937Oil on canvas
The Red Model1935Oil on canvas
The Menaced Assassin1927Oil on canvas
The Castle of the Pyrenees1959Oil on canvas
The Blank Signature1965Oil on canvas
The Listening Room1958Oil on canvas
Golconde1953Oil on canvas
Time Transfixed1938Oil on canvas
The Treachery of Images1929Oil on canvas
The False Mirror1929Oil on canvas
The Empire of Light1953–54Oil on canvas
The Human Condition1933Oil on canvas
Les Amants1928Oil on canvas
The Son of Man1964Oil on canvas

Frequently Asked Questions

Which version appears here?

This is Ghent’s second version, inventory 1961-A. The reverse inscription includes the year 1950 and the number II.

Which painting was Magritte responding to?

The composition revisits Édouard Manet’s Le Balcon, painted in 1868–69 and now in the Musée d’Orsay.

Discussion

Look closely and compare your reading with others.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

Which part of the setting first makes the coffins read as a group?

Editorial prompt · Comparison

How does the seated coffin change when you follow the shape of the chair behind it?

Editorial prompt · Context

Which detail makes the connection with Manet most apparent?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about The Balcony below.

References

  1. Museum of Fine Arts Ghent. Perspective II. Manet’s Balcony. Collection record and reverse inscription, 1961-A. View source.
  2. Flemish Art Collection. “René Magritte, Perspective II-Manet’s Balcony, 1950, MSK Gent.” Illustrated collection essay. View source.
  3. Musée d’Orsay. Édouard Manet, Le Balcon. Collection record, RF 2772. View source.
  4. Museum of Fine Arts Ghent. Page from a Sketchbook with Three Studies among Others for “Perspective: Manet’s Balcony”. Collection record, 2010-B-recto. View source.