Flagellation of Christ

Explore Botticelli art prints
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

A closer look

Christ stands bound to a column, his head inclined and his bare torso exposed between two men who torment him. The man at the left presses close; the one at the right lifts an arm for another blow. An open stretch of painted pavement leaves no crowd to absorb the violence. This Flagellation of Christ belongs to the Uffizi as inventory 1890 no. 5876. Both the Italian national catalogue and a later Uffizi exhibition catalogue identify its makers as the workshop of Sandro Botticelli. The design may owe something to the master, but the painting should not be introduced as an undisputed autograph Botticelli.^[1][2]

Its paired history makes the picture more than an isolated Passion scene. In an 1880 inventory, it was recorded with a second painting, now no. 5877, then attached to the reverse of the same support. That other work depicts the Way to Calvary. The later catalogue sets them side by side and relates them to further damaged scenes in Canada. Their original arrangement, commissioner and precise date remain matters of research. Looking closely at no. 5876 begins with the three figures, then widens into questions of workshop production and a broken-up series.^[1][2]

Contents

1. At a Glance
2. Christ Between Two Tormentors
3. A Workshop Painting with a Botticelli Design
4. Date and Material: Why the Catalogues Disagree
5. The Lost Arrangement of the Passion Scenes

Christ Between Two Tormentors

The composition places Christ at the centre of a tight courtyard. A dark upright support rises behind him, making his still body a vertical counterweight to the attackers' bent arms and active legs. His wrists are drawn behind him. The white cloth around his waist is the lightest large form in the lower half; above it, the pale chest and arms catch the viewer's attention against the darker architecture. He does not meet our gaze. The head tilts down and sideways, so that the scene reads through the contrast between his restrained posture and the movement on either side.^[1][2]

At left, a bearded man leans toward Christ with a scourge or bundle of cords. His body is wrapped in layered clothing, with one leg planted wide. At right, another figure turns inward, lifting an arm and instrument above Christ's shoulder. His shorter pink garment, dark boots and sweeping black cloth make a sharply angled shape against the pale body at the centre. The two attackers are not portraits of named biblical characters. Their opposed positions create pressure from both sides; the painting gives the spectator no comfortable exit from the action.^[1][2]

The courtyard is pared down to hard surfaces: column, walls, a low architectural edge and bands of warm paving. The background is neither a detailed reconstruction of Jerusalem nor a documented view of a Florentine building. It gives the bodies a stage. The national catalogue calls the setting an interior, while the 2022 exhibition text describes a courtyard. That difference is easy to understand from the image: the figures stand inside architecture with an open-feeling space around them. Neither term proves the exact building the workshop meant to imagine.^[1][2]

The Gospel accounts place scourging in the events following Jesus' appearance before Pilate and before the journey to crucifixion. Matthew says Pilate had Jesus scourged before handing him over for crucifixion; John also begins the next stage with Pilate ordering the scourging. Neither passage specifies the clothes or postures of the two men painted here. The bodily arrangement, colour contrasts and pavement are the workshop's visual choices for making that brief scriptural event present to a viewer.^[4][5]

A Workshop Painting with a Botticelli Design

“Workshop of Botticelli” is a meaningful attribution, not a modest synonym for “by Botticelli.” The Italian national catalogue keeps the work under the workshop heading and records a scholarly proposal that it was based on the master's drawings. Annamaria Bernacchioni's 2022 Uffizi/Minneapolis entry likewise assigns the composition's design to Botticelli but its execution to the workshop. It even allows that the painting may have been completed after Botticelli's death in 1510. That is a stronger caution than simply saying he had help.^[1][2]

The distinction matters because the picture's order can be compelling while the hand that painted its surfaces remains uncertain. Christ's pale, almost sculptural body, set between two brightly dressed tormentors, supplies a clear structure. The 2022 catalogue also compares the figure's bodily form with ancient sculpture in the exhibition. Such a comparison concerns design and visual language; it is not a signed preparatory drawing for this exact panel. Nor does the resemblance overturn the catalogues' workshop attribution.^[2]

The workshop continued producing images in Botticelli's manner as his career ended. The catalogue does not identify a particular painter for no. 5876. It mentions a documented follower, Jacopo di Francesco di Domenico, only as a possible avenue for future research; no surviving painting is securely assigned to him there. A public account should therefore resist a more precise name. The evidence supports a Botticelli-associated design and workshop execution, with the identity of the executing painter open.^[1][2]

Date and Material: Why the Catalogues Disagree

The Italian national entry gives a broad about 1490–1510 range and describes tempera on panel. It was compiled in 1986 and last updated in 2006. The 2022 Uffizi exhibition catalogue proposes about 1505–10 and describes the work as probably tempera and oil, or tempera grassa, on canvas transferred from panel. An Uffizi loan worklist for a 2014 Tokyo exhibition calls it tempera on canvas and dates it after 1510. The differences should remain visible rather than being collapsed into a single unqualified date and medium.^[1][2][3]

There is a plausible relationship among the support descriptions: a painting originally on wood could later be transferred to canvas. But that does not let a reader silently replace the older catalogue's field with an uncaveated technical claim. The recent exhibition entry says probably for the paint mixture and gives the transfer history as its current understanding. The Japanese loan list agrees on present canvas support while choosing a later date. The proper shorthand for the page is a late workshop Flagellation, around 1505–10 or possibly later, with the older record's broader dating noted.^[1][2][3]

Size is more stable. Both the national and 2022 catalogues give 132 × 107 cm for this Flagellation. Its Uffizi companion, no. 5877, is slightly different at 133 × 107 cm in the later catalogue. Sharing a height and subject cycle does not make the two canvases one surviving panel. The 1880 record of their reverse-to-reverse attachment is a later documented condition, while the first planned format remains unsettled.^[1][2]

The Lost Arrangement of the Passion Scenes

The Flagellation and Way to Calvary have a material history together. The national catalogue says the 1880 inventory gave them the same catalogue number when the second scene was attached to the back of this one. Later authors proposed several reconstructions. One treated them as doors of a tabernacle. Federico Zeri proposed a larger triptych linking them with a Christ Carrying the Cross and a Resurrection in New Brunswick, Canada. A different proposal imagined a longer series of processional pictures. The national entry presents these as scholarly hypotheses, not a recovered original contract.^[1]

The 2022 catalogue adds a concrete visual link. It describes Uffizi no. 5877 as the left part of a Way to Calvary, cut down so that Christ himself is absent except for a bit of robe. The right part is identified with a painting at the Beaverbrook Art Gallery in Fredericton; a piece of the Virgin's drapery appears to continue between the separated sections. A Resurrection in the same Canadian collection belongs to the proposed Passion group. Those paintings help reconstruct possible relationships, but their subjects must not be folded into the Flagellation image shown on this page.^[2]

The original patron is unknown. Bernacchioni suggests that a Florentine lay confraternity concerned with the Passion may have commissioned the series, offering the Croce al Tempio or Scalzo as possible examples. Their processional and charitable activities would give the violent story a setting, but neither group is documented as owner of these particular paintings in the entry. Likewise, an imagined tabernacle or procession is an interpretive framework, not the proven first use of no. 5876.^[1][2]

The surviving ownership trail is firmer from the nineteenth century. The 2022 catalogue places the works in the Uffizi before 1881, at the Museo d'Arte Medievale e Moderna in Arezzo from 1937, and back with the Uffizi from 1993. Their movement through collections is real evidence, even while the original chapel, confraternity or route of a procession remains unlocated. The current Uffizi inventory number identifies the Flagellation regardless of where it is displayed at a particular moment.^[2]

What survives in the image is a stark three-person encounter. The still, bound Christ is squeezed between two forceful bodies, and the paving gives their movement a harsh stage. The painting's association with Botticelli lies in a proposed design and a workshop language continued near or beyond the end of his life. Calling it the workshop's Flagellation, Uffizi 5876, preserves both the power of its composition and the limits of what is known about who painted it, when it was finished and where its larger Passion story was first seen.^[1][2]

References

1. Italian Ministry of Culture, Flagellazione di Cristo, national catalogue 0900189476, Uffizi 1890 no. 5876; workshop attribution, broad date, older support entry, measurements and reconstruction history; accessed 1 October 2026 View source.
2. Annamaria Bernacchioni, “The Flagellation” and “The Way to Calvary,” nos. 15–16, pp. 104–5 in Cecilia Frosinini and Rachel McGarry, eds., Botticelli and Renaissance Florence: Masterworks from the Uffizi, Minneapolis Institute of Art and Gallerie degli Uffizi, 2022; accessed 1 October 2026 View source.
3. Tokyo Metropolitan Art Museum, Galleria degli Uffizi loan worklist, 2014, row 30; workshop attribution, after-1510 date and canvas entry; accessed 1 October 2026 View source.
4. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Matthew 27:26–31; accessed 1 October 2026 View source.
5. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, John 19:1–3; accessed 1 October 2026 View source.

More BOTTICELLI Artworks

The Birth of Venus

Primavera

Venus and Mars

Adoration of the Magi

Madonna of the Magnificat

Pallas and the Centaur

The Mystical Nativity

Fortitude