Introduction
A small dog's head appears just above a sloping brown bank. Its muzzle tilts towards the right, where the bank rises and the ochre field darkens. Above the head there is a disproportionate amount of space. The whole animal might fit many times over in the area given to that field, yet even its neck is hard to follow. The most recognisable thing in the painting occupies very little of it. The longer you follow the dog's gaze, the more you notice the difficulty of saying what, if anything, has caught its attention.
Francisco de Goya painted The Dog around 1820–23 in his house near Madrid. The surviving work, now in the Museo Nacional del Prado, measures about 131 by 79 centimetres. Its vertical format was originally a painted section of wall. The museum object preserves paint that was removed from that wall and transferred to canvas. Those facts matter as soon as we try to tell a story about the small head and the seemingly empty space above it. [1]
At a Glance
- Artist and dateFrancisco de Goya, about 1820–23. [1]
- Medium and sizeOil on plaster transferred to canvas, approximately 131 × 79 cm. [1]
- Original locationBeside the entrance to the upstairs room of the Quinta del Sordo, near Madrid. [1] [4]
- CollectionMuseo Nacional del Prado, Madrid, catalogue no. 767. [1]
Works across Goya’s career
The Parasol
1777The Nude Maja
1795–1800Saturn Devouring His Son
c. 1820–23The Dog
c. 1820–23Milkmaid of Bordeaux
c. 1827The head, the bank and the space above
Start at the left edge of the bank and follow its soft contour towards the right. For much of the way it is the only firm division in the picture, though it climbs much more sharply after passing the dog. The head interrupts that rising line just as the silhouette of the muzzle turns up. A few lighter strokes around the eye and cheek make it possible to read the position of the face within the dark shape. Once you have found the eye, a small passage of paint has the authority to send your gaze across nearly the entire canvas. The eye gives you a direction. The rest of the surviving picture makes it difficult to fix a destination. [1]
The large field is uneven. There are warmer ochres and lighter passages towards the left, and more muted browns on the right, especially as the upper field meets the rising bank. Some of these intervals seem to open up space, while others bring attention back to the marks on the surface. Calling the field a sky is an understandable response to its position over the bank. It has few of the cues that would let you judge a distance, make out a horizon, or say where an object in that space ought to be. The bank is similarly hard to name. As land it could be hiding a dog standing on the other side of a rise. Read as water or mud, the same edge could become a surface through which the dog is struggling. The head remains in the same place through either reading.
The titles make those changes of scene particularly easy to track. In an inventory compiled in the mid-nineteenth century, Antonio de Brugada called it Un perro (A Dog). Charles Yriarte described and illustrated it in his 1867 monograph on Goya with a title that made the dog fight against a current. The Prado catalogue of 1900 used Perro semihundido, or Half-Submerged Dog. Brugada identified the animal, Yriarte supplied an action, and the later catalogue described a physical situation. Each name puts a different question in the viewer's mind before the painting comes into view. [2]
Try looking once with Brugada's title in mind. The angle of the muzzle can read as simple alertness. The dog's attention might be fixed on something beyond the bank. With Yriarte's title in mind, the same angle can seem like an effort to keep the muzzle clear. Both impressions depend on the viewer supplying circumstances that the shape alone leaves open. Yriarte's title is valuable evidence of how a visitor in the nineteenth century understood the picture. Even an early title gives us a reading of the image at a particular moment in its history.
Annotated Details from The Dog
Start with the head, then follow the diagonal beneath it and the tonal changes above. The details show the surviving canvas at the Museo Nacional del Prado (P000767).
Details from THE DOG
Compare the small scale of the dog’s head with the rise of the dark bank and the broad field above.
Head at the edge
The muzzle tilts up and catches a little light. The outline gives the head its direction even though almost all of the dog’s body is out of view.
The rising boundary
The brown bank rises more steeply to the right of the head. The transition softens where the two areas of paint meet, leaving the substance of the bank ambiguous.
A painting beside a doorway
The Quinta del Sordo was a country house near the Manzanares outside Madrid. It had its name before Goya bought it in 1819. He lived there with Leocadia Weiss and her children and gave the property to his grandson Mariano in 1823. These events establish the period in which Goya was able to paint the rooms and identify the building as a lived-in house. The property later passed out of the family's hands. By the time Laurent photographed the paintings, decades had elapsed since Goya had lived with them. [2] [3]
The fourteen works now known collectively as the Black Paintings occupied rooms on the ground and upper floors. The Fundación Goya en Aragón places The Dog to the right of the entrance to the upstairs room. Across from the entrance, on the other short wall, it places The Reading and Two Women and a Man. In their reconstruction of the room, Carlos Foradada Baldellou and his colleagues place the dog on the interior wall of the entrance. On that layout, someone entering the room would see the paintings on the opposite wall before turning back towards the door to see the dog. The position would give the tall ochre field a particular effect, glimpsed alongside the doorway during a turn rather than approached from straight ahead. [4] [1] [5]
The Reading makes for a comparison within that upstairs space. It, too, is a narrow upright painting and gives the eye relatively few clues about the setting. Its men gather around a seated figure with a light shirt and a paper. Some faces are easier to make out than the bodies to which they belong. You can move from the light on the reader to the paper and the faces of those attending to him. Even with much of the setting in darkness, the painting gives the group a focus within the scene. If you turn from that group to The Dog, you still have a figure only partly visible and a clear direction of attention. The apparent focus lies somewhere in the broad uncertainty of the field, or beyond its edge. [6]
The place of the dog beside a door also puts a different kind of boundary around the painted space. The bottom diagonal belongs to the image, while the upright edge once belonged to the room as well. Laurent's photograph shows decorative paper around the painted section. In his photograph it is possible to compare the scale of the opening in the wall treatment with the little head inside it. The decorated border records the house at the time of the photograph. Foradada’s team points to places where brushstrokes seem to extend across the paper moulding in Laurent’s photograph. They argue from that overlap that the decorative treatment was in place while Goya was painting. The dating associated with the digitised plate allows for a later, mid-century origin for the paper. The paper’s presence when Laurent stood in the room is easier to establish than the sequence in which decoration and paint were applied. [7] [5]

What Laurent's photograph shows
Jean Laurent photographed the mural before its transfer to canvas. The glass negative, numbered VN-06583 P in the Ruiz Vernacci archive at Spain's Institute of Cultural Heritage, measures 27 by 36 centimetres and was made with wet collodion. One way to see the image today is in a modern print made by laying paper against the negative, as reproduced by conservation researcher Celia Isabel Díez Esteban. Another is in the digitisation of the original glass plate. The photograph has been dated to around 1873 in Prado exhibition material, while the digitised reproduction is labelled 1874. What matters for comparison with the canvas is the order of events. The painting is still on the wall in the photograph. [2] [3] [7]
A full view of the plate includes evidence that can go missing when the photograph is cropped to the shape of the painting. Beyond the head and dark bank there is a decorated surround. Cracks run across the painted area and its surrounds. They connect the image to the wall even though the photograph also bears a label referring to the Museo del Prado. The label belongs to the later history of the negative, while the cracks and border belong to what stood in front of the camera. A reader who took the label as proof of where the exposure was made would date the photograph to a different stage in the painting's life. [7]
Lighting matters too. Laurent could photograph portable works in sunlight, but the paintings at the Quinta could only be photographed indoors. Díez Esteban discusses the use of electrical lighting supplied by a portable battery system, and Corinne Cristini studies the Laurent photographs as records produced through a particular photographic process. The light needed to expose a plate in the room could alter the apparent strength of a mark or cast shadows from an uneven surface. The monochrome plate renders the colours of the painting as shades of grey. A dark patch in one reproduction and a faint change of colour in another are therefore difficult to compare directly, especially if the reproductions differ in contrast or cropping. [3] [8]
Look above the darker form on the right, in the direction of the muzzle. The Fundación Goya en Aragón credits José Manuel Arnáiz with identifying two marks there as birds. Díez Esteban also reads them as birds and proposes that they disappeared during the transfer or subsequent restoration. On that reading the photograph supplies a small but consequential piece of action. The dog may have turned to watch something move in the air. Its gaze, so difficult to place in the canvas, would have a destination within the image. [1] [3]
There are several steps between recognising two marks and saying precisely what Goya painted. The image shows a mural already affected by age, rendered in the tones that the plate could register. It records marks visible at the time of exposure. Identifying those marks as birds is an interpretation of their shapes and position. Assigning them to Goya's original design requires a further judgement about the history of the painted surface before Laurent arrived. If they were painted birds, aligning the photograph and canvas would still leave a question about when or how the corresponding detail ceased to be legible. The marks repay a close look because they make a specific proposal about the dog's gaze possible. The photograph leaves room for that proposal to be tested against other kinds of evidence. [3] [7]
What a nineteenth-century photograph can describe
The other photographs Laurent took inside the Quinta help establish how to use the photograph of the dog. Across the group, seams, borders and fragments of decoration can show where a painted field met the room. The reconstruction of the lower floor by Carlos Teixidor Cadenas and F. Javier Laguna works through those architectural clues. It also illustrates a distinction that matters upstairs. A border establishes an edge of the field that Laurent photographed. A faint shape inside it calls for a different argument, because a tonal difference in a monochrome reproduction can register paint, deterioration or an effect of the photograph. [15] [3]
Follow the dog’s head and the inclined bank first. They give the photograph and the present painting comparatively stable features to align. Then work outward into the field above. Changing the contrast of a digital reproduction can make certain marks easier to see, but it can also make irregularities appear more coherent than they do in another reproduction of the same plate. Repeated shapes near one another may suggest movement. Establishing what Goya meant them to depict would require an independent line of evidence. The built edges and the diagonal bank can therefore sustain firmer conclusions than an enlarged pale patch. [15] [3]
Celia Isabel Díez Esteban uses the photograph to recover the condition of the Quinta mural before its transfer to a new support. Those arguments have to account for the order of the surviving evidence. A drawing made after an early photograph records what someone saw in the photograph. Its agreement with the photographic mark cannot be counted as a second sighting of the mural. A drawn reconstruction can make a conjecture open to inspection. The photograph and the canvas remain the two records that directly describe different material stages of the painting. Their strongest point of agreement is the small scale of the head relative to the surrounding field. That relationship gives the uncertainty of the dog’s attention its force regardless of whether any feature above it can be identified. [15] [3]
The lower-floor reconstruction gives a usefully firm comparison with the upstairs picture known as Men Reading. The photograph of that mural preserves a visible boundary around a group that remains recognisable in the transferred canvas. The border carries one kind of information and the disposition of the heads another. Neither needs to match the brightness of the paint as displayed today. Applying that same order of attention to the dog helps establish which features can carry an inference about placement in the house, before any interpretation of the figures begins. [15] [3]


Goya on film
Five films explore Goya’s portraits, prints, Black Paintings and painting techniques.
The Duke of Wellington by Goya
The portrait, its military decorations and its later theft.
Watch on YouTubeFrom plaster to canvas
Goya applied oil paint to a prepared dry wall. The transfer depended on applying an adhesive facing to the painted surface, lifting the paint along with some of the wall material and attaching it to canvas, then removing the facing. How much underlying material came away with the paint could vary. This helps explain why even a sample from a successfully transferred mural may preserve only fragments of its earliest layers. [2] [8] [9]
Baron Émile d'Erlanger acquired the Quinta in 1873 and commissioned the transfer from Salvador Martínez Cubells, then a restorer at the Prado. The Dog was among the Black Paintings exhibited at the Palais du Trocadéro during the 1878 Paris Exposition Universelle. The baron subsequently donated the works to the Spanish state. A royal order of 20 December 1881 records their assignment. Díez Esteban dates the start of public display of the Black Paintings at the Prado to 1889. They had moved first from wall to canvas, and then from a house to temporary exhibition and museum display. [1] [3]
The actual layers of The Dog tell a less straightforward story than the phrase ‘oil on canvas’ would suggest. The Prado technical study by María del Carmen Garrido Pérez describes a white calcium sulphate preparation bound with gelatine glue, and identifies remnants of a grey-violet layer beneath that preparation in samples from this painting. On the X-ray, brushwork associated with an earlier landscape design is visible beneath the dog's head. The head itself has pronounced contrasts in the X-ray, with more substantial paint highlighting parts of the face. The study gives us a way of thinking about why the head emerges so clearly in the finished image and how much information survives underneath its surroundings. [9]
Garrido Pérez also considered whether there might be a painted body beneath the foreground. The X-ray shows slight brushwork in that area, which she related tentatively to the earlier landscape, and provides no sufficient evidence for a dog's body. She reports a granular surface and extensive retouching in the area on the right, where previous readings of photographs had proposed a hunter and horse. The X-ray and paint cross-sections did not substantiate that identification. These findings help explain the difficulty of reasoning back from the painting's appearance today. The present texture comes from several stages in the work's history. The study could examine the materials still present and distinguish some of their layers, but it could draw only limited conclusions about the identity of forms in nineteenth-century images. [9]
In 2014, Factum Arte used the non-contact Lucida scanner to record the relief of the surviving surfaces of the Black Paintings. The team also made colour recordings by combining a series of photographs. A scanner measures small differences in the height of the surface. In a rendering of that data, even subtle ridges and depressions can show up independently of their colour. The colour record lets the researcher locate those features within the visible composition. Factum aligned material from the Prado's Technical Department with its own records, including X-ray, infrared, ultraviolet and Laurent's photographs. Its project account reproduces both a surface view and a combined colour and X-ray view of details of The Dog. [10]
The point of comparing such records is easiest to see in the upper field. A dark passage in a colour photograph and a depression in the relief might coincide. If so, that relation is something to investigate by looking at the paint layers or the historical image. Each record has a different relationship to the painting. The colour photograph documents its appearance when photographed. The relief measures the shape of the exposed surface at the time of scanning. Laurent's negative shows some features of a wall that has since gone. In 2023 the Prado and Factum announced a facsimile of a detail of The Dog that reproduced both colour and relief. The facsimile brings out a quality a flat reproduction can easily suppress. Its fidelity is to the surviving surface that Factum was able to record. [10] [11]
Antonio Saura's encounter with the painting
The Spanish painter Antonio Saura began a series of works after The Dog in 1957. He kept returning to it into the early 1990s. One of the titles he used was Imaginary Portrait of Goya. That title gives us a documented case of an artist seeing Goya himself in the upturned face. In his own writing, Saura linked the head emerging into view with solitude and described the dog in terms of Goya looking on at events. He also wrote about ‘the tremendous importance of the void’ in allowing a figure to appear. Those are descriptions of what the image set in motion for Saura, whose own paintings make the encounter visible. [12]
In the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao's Imaginary Portrait of Goya of 1985, mixed media on paper, Saura gives darkness most of the space and leaves white in the upper right, above a head made from scrawled marks. Goya's narrow vertical composition becomes a horizontal work. The isolated head survives that change of orientation and the shift from a largely ochre field to darkness. The light area now occupies only a fraction of the space. The difference can lead the eye to the head by a different route. In Goya's painting you can travel up the foreground slope and come upon the muzzle. In Saura's work the surrounding darkness makes the isolated light and the figure beneath it announce one another. [1] [12]
Saura also worked with the image in print. The Museo Reina Sofía holds a 1972 screenprint titled The Dog of Goya, the first plate in his Four Imaginary Portraits of Goya. By grouping versions into a series of portraits, Saura could repeat a head while changing the marks that define it and the space in which it appears. The title turns Goya from the painter of the animal into the person a new artist tries to picture through it. It also gives the viewer a way to see how much an interpretation can change the identity of the figure without changing the modest physical fact that prompted it, a head appearing out of a field. [12] [13]
In a study of the painting's reception, Bárbara Cobos Muñumer describes Saura’s response as drawing the viewer into the dog’s position. Saura pictures Goya as the dog and the dog as us. This gives a particular force to the otherwise undirected space. A viewer may find themselves identifying with the creature looking up before they have decided what the creature sees. [14]
Saura's interest in emergence offers another way to spend time with the Prado canvas. From a distance you can see how quickly the upper field asserts itself and how little area the dog claims. Closer in, the mottled surface breaks up that broad impression and the details of the face take on more weight. From either distance the direction of the eye remains remarkably precise. Laurent's photograph allows a possible subject for that attention to be put back into consideration. What we experience in the gallery can be as specific as the way that upward look draws us across an area of paint whose earlier appearance remains partly recoverable. [1] [3] [10]
Artworks directory
| Name | Date | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| And There’s No Help for It, Plate 15 | Printed 1863 | |
| Asmodea | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Boys Inflating a Bladder | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Boys Picking Fruit | 1778 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Bullfight in a Divided Ring | 1825 | Lithograph |
| Card Players | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Card Players (sketch) | 1777–78 | Painted sketch |
| Dance on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Duel with Cudgels | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Heads in a Landscape | c. 1820–23 | Easel painting |
| Judith and Holofernes | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Leocadia | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Maja and Cloaked Men | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Maja and Cloaked Men (sketch) | 1777 | Painted sketch |
| Majo Clapping in Time to the Music | 1777 | Drawing |
| Men Reading | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Out Hunting for Teeth, Plate 12 | 1799 | Etching, burnished aquatint and burin |
| Picnic in the Countryside (sketch) | 1776–78 | Painted sketch |
| Picnic on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1776 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Pilgrimage to San Isidro | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Preparatory study for The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters | c. 1796–97 | Drawing |
| Procession of the Holy Office | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Quarrel at the Cockerel Inn (sketch) | 1777 | Painted sketch |
| Quarrel in the New Tavern | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Saturn Devouring His Son | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Seated Majo Smoking | c. 1776 | Drawing |
| The Dog | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Drinker | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| The Fates | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Great He-Goat | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Kite | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| The Parasol | 1777 | Oil on canvas, tapestry cartoon |
| The Second of May 1808 | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters, Plate 43 | 1799 | Etching and aquatint |
| The Third of May 1808 | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| Thou Who Canst Not, Plate 42 | 1799 | Etching and burnished aquatint |
| Three Figures | 1776 | Drawing (lost) |
| Two Old Men | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Two Old Men Eating Soup | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Two Women and a Man | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Universal Language: The Author Dreaming | 1797 | Drawing |
| The Family of Charles IV | 1800 | Oil on canvas |
| Witches’ Sabbath (Osuna painting) | 1797–98 | Oil on canvas |
| The Nude Maja | 1795–1800 | Oil on canvas |
| The Clothed Maja | 1800–07 | Oil on canvas |
| Self-Portrait (Drawing) | c. 1796 | Brush and carbon black ink on laid paper |
| The Swing, Madrid Album B.21 | 1795–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Majas Fighting, a Majo Observing, Madrid Album B.15 | 1796–97 | Brush, grey and black washes on laid paper |
| Majos and Majas Conversing, Madrid Album B.16 | c. 1794–97 | Ink wash on paper |
| Weeping Woman and Three Men, Madrid Album B.17 | 1795–97 | Brush, carbon black washes and black chalk |
| Maja Seated on a Chair and Two Companions Behind, Madrid Album B.18 | 1795–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Girl and Bull, Madrid Album B.23 | 1796–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Lovers Sitting on a Rock, Madrid Album B.24 | 1796–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Mariano Ceballos Riding a Bull | 1825 | Crayon lithograph and scraper |
| Landscape (lifetime impression) | c. 1807–10 | Etching and aquatint |
| Self-Portrait (1815), Prado canvas | 1815 | Oil on canvas |
| Self-Portrait (1815), Academy panel | 1815 | Oil on panel |
| Self-Portrait with Dr Arrieta | 1820 | Oil on canvas |
| Christ Crucified | 1780 | Oil on canvas |
| The Last Communion of Saint Joseph of Calasanz | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| Christ on the Mount of Olives | 1819 | Oil on panel |
| The Flower Girls, or Spring | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Grape Harvest, or Autumn | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Snowstorm, or Winter | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Threshing Ground, or Summer | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| Picnic on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1776 | Oil on canvas |
| The Kite | 1777–78 | Oil on canvas |
| Dance on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1777 | Oil on canvas |
| A Fight at the Venta Nueva | 1777 | Oil on canvas |
| Blind Man’s Bluff | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| Dogs on a Lead | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| Hunting with a Decoy | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| Hunter Loading His Rifle | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| The Angler | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| The Hermitage of San Isidro on His Feast Day | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| The Meadow of San Isidro | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| The Straw Manikin | 1791–92 | Oil on canvas |
| Witches’ Flight | c. 1797–98 | Oil on canvas |
| A Scene from ‘The Forcibly Bewitched’ | 1798 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duchess of Alba in Black | 1797 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duchess of Alba in White | 1795 | Oil on canvas |
| Charles III in Hunting Dress | c. 1786 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duke and Duchess of Osuna and Their Children | 1787–88 | Oil on canvas |
| Manuel Osorio Manrique de Zúñiga | 1787–88 | Oil on canvas |
| The Marquesa de Pontejos | c. 1786 | Oil on canvas |
| Equestrian Portrait of the 1st Duke of Wellington | 1812 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duke of Wellington | 1812–14 | Oil on wood |
| Portrait of Ferdinand VII of Spain | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| Gaspar Melchor de Jovellanos | 1798 | Oil on canvas |
| María Tomasa Palafox y Portocarrero | 1804 | Oil on canvas |
| Señora Sabasa García | c. 1806–11 | Oil on canvas |
| Don Juan Bautista de Muguiro | 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Doña Isabel de Porcel | Before 1805 | Oil on canvas |
| The Colossus | After 1808 | Oil on canvas |
| The Burial of the Sardine | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| The Madhouse | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| A Procession of Flagellants | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| Portrait of Jacques Galos | 1826 | Oil on canvas |
| Portrait of Mariano Goya, the Artist’s Grandson | 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Milkmaid of Bordeaux | c. 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Portrait of Don Juan Antonio Cuervo | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| María Luisa of Parma (Naples version) | c. 1800 | Oil on canvas |
| The Countess of Baena | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| The Family of the Infante Don Luis | 1783–84 | Oil on canvas |
| The Holy Family | c. 1787 | Oil on canvas |
| Saint Barbara | c. 1773 | Oil on canvas |
| Saints Justa and Rufina | 1817 | Oil on canvas |
| El Tío Paquete | c. 1819–20 | Oil on canvas |
| The Forge | c. 1815–20 | Oil on canvas |
| Majas on a Balcony (Metropolitan Museum version) | c. 1800–10 | Oil on canvas |
| Maja and Celestina on a Balcony | c. 1808–12 | Oil on canvas |
| The Water Bearer | 1808–12 | Oil on canvas |
| Time and the Old Women | c. 1810 | Oil on canvas |
Frequently Asked Questions
The head and the dark slope leave the dog's predicament open. Yriarte read the slope as a current in 1867, and the Prado's 1900 title describes the animal as half submerged. The visible contour can also be read as a bank hiding the body of a dog that is standing or watching. [2]
José Manuel Arnáiz and Celia Isabel Díez Esteban interpreted two marks above the dark form in Laurent's photograph as birds. They are hard to resolve on the canvas. Even if the marks depict birds, the photograph records one moment in the life of the wall, leaving open how and when the detail became difficult to see. [1] [3]
Discussion
Look again at the images and ideas explored in The Dog. These editorial prompts invite your observations.
Trace the dog's gaze first in the canvas and then in Laurent's photograph. Where does your attention settle in each image? Which detail does most to change how you understand the dog's posture?
Reader Insights
How far does the slope guide your eye towards what the dog might see?
What changes when you see the painting inside the decorated border in Laurent’s photograph?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about The Dog below.
References
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, Half-Submerged Dog (Perro semihundido), catalogue entry. View source.
- Museo Nacional del Prado and Centro León, El Prado en las calles, entry for Perro semihundido. View source.
- Celia Isabel Díez Esteban, ‘La fotografía histórica como fuente de información de la obra de arte: J. Laurent y el perro semihundido de Goya’, Actas XIII Congreso Internacional de Historia del Papel en la Península Ibérica, pp. 153–62. View source.
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, Leocadia (La Leocadia), catalogue entry and room reconstruction. View source.
- Carlos Foradada Baldellou, Carlos Narbaiza Dorado, José Javier Luis Tello and Alfonso Burgos Risco, ‘Las medidas de la casa de Goya y sus Pinturas negras en su entorno original’, ASRI 20 (2021), pp. 52–81, especially figs. 14 and 30–32. View source.
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, The Reading (La lectura), catalogue entry. View source.
- Jean Laurent, The Dog, photographed in the Quinta del Sordo before transfer to canvas, glass negative VN-06583 P, Archivo Ruiz Vernacci, Instituto del Patrimonio Cultural de España. Digitised negative and accompanying notes reproduced on Wikimedia Commons. View source.
- Corinne Cristini, ‘D’un support à un autre : l’apport des photographies de Jean Laurent dans la mise en lumière des Pinturas Negras de Francisco de Goya’, L’Âge d’Or, no. 4. View source.
- María del Carmen Garrido Pérez, ‘Algunas consideraciones sobre la técnica de las Pinturas Negras de Goya’, Boletín del Museo del Prado 5, no. 13 (1984), pp. 4–40, especially pp. 30–32 and figs. 63–66. View source.
- Factum Arte, 3D and colour recording of Francisco de Goya’s Black Paintings (c. 1819–1823), Museo Nacional del Prado collaboration, 2014–15. View source.
- Factum Foundation, Museo Nacional del Prado ✕ Factum Foundation: limited edition facsimile series, 15 December 2023. View source.
- Guggenheim Museum Bilbao, Antonio Saura, Imaginary Portrait of Goya, 1985, including excerpts from Saura’s essay ‘Iniciales’. View source.
- Museo Nacional Centro de Arte Reina Sofía, Antonio Saura, El perro de Goya (plancha 1), 1972, catalogue entry. View source.
- Bárbara Cobos Muñumer, La recepción de “Perro semihundido” de Francisco de Goya, las Pinturas Negras y su influencia en el arte posterior, doctoral thesis, Universidad Carlos III de Madrid, 2018, pp. 139–40. View source.
- Carlos Teixidor Cadenas and F. Javier Laguna, Institución Fernando el Católico, Las Pinturas negras en la Quinta de Goya. Reconstrucción de la planta baja. View source.










