Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar — Minneapolis Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on November 2, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Frédéric Bazille’s Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar: Introduction

A bright white collar holds the centre of Frédéric Bazille’s Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar. Above it, a bearded face turns out of a dark coat and a brown background, its uneven lighting giving the head an almost sculptural presence. The picture belongs to the Minneapolis Institute of Art, which dates it to 1865–67. Its close framing leaves face and clothing to establish the sitter’s presence. [1]

Its apparent directness conceals two questions. When exactly was it painted, and is the man unquestionably Bazille? Michel Schulman dates the canvas later than the museum, to 1867–68, and defends its identification as a self-portrait against an earlier scholarly doubt. Those differences matter because they prevent the image from becoming a simple illustration of a supposedly known moment in the artist’s life. Its power comes first from the painted encounter: the head’s turn, the dark eyes, and the sudden clarity of the collar beneath the beard. [2]

At a Glance

  • Date1865–67 (Minneapolis); 1867–68 (catalogue) [1] [2]
  • MediumOil on canvas [1]
  • CollectionMinneapolis Institute of Art, 62.39 [1]

This work across Frédéric Bazille’s career

Contents

  1. Which self-portrait is this?
  2. The face emerges through light
  3. A painter without his tools
  4. Faces among friends
  5. How certain is the sitter’s identity?
  6. From the Bazille family to Minneapolis

Which self-portrait is this?

The Minneapolis painting is an oil on canvas measuring approximately 54 × 46 centimetres, accession number 62.39. The museum’s title refers to the detachable collar: the separate white band around the neck that makes such a strong visual division between face and clothing. The composition stops at the upper body. No hand, palette, easel or canvas appears within it. Its limited field brings the viewer close to the sitter, while the plain background leaves his surroundings undescribed. [1]

The dates should remain a range. Minneapolis gives 1865–67; Schulman’s catalogue gives 1867–68 and proposes the winter spanning those years. These datings overlap in 1867, but the catalogue’s more specific seasonal suggestion is a scholarly proposal rather than a date written on the canvas. The museum records no visible signature. Neither the sitter’s beard nor the picture’s vigorous appearance can establish a particular month by themselves. [1] [2]

The distinction from Chicago is equally important. The Art Institute of Chicago’s Self-Portrait, dated 1865–66, measures 108.9 × 71.1 centimetres and includes the tools of painting. Its greater height makes room for a fuller presentation of the artist’s body and activity. Minneapolis offers a different problem: how much can a portrait communicate when the visible evidence is reduced to head, clothing, light and gaze? Treating the two works as interchangeable would erase that difference. [3]

The face emerges through light

Begin with the shoulder at the lower right and follow its diagonal towards the neck. The coat occupies much of the lower picture, but its subdued colour gives it less immediate emphasis than its size might suggest. The collar interrupts that dark mass. Its pale upper edge turns beneath the beard, then rises towards the illuminated side of the neck. This small band helps us understand both the head’s position and the body’s direction.

The face does not receive an even wash of light. The forehead, bridge of the nose, cheek and visible ear form separate illuminated areas, with deeper passages around the eyes and beneath the brow. The beard enlarges the lower silhouette of the head while partly concealing the jaw. Hair and facial hair therefore do more than furnish a likeness: they organise the dark shapes against which the brighter features become legible.

There is a useful tension between the head and eyes. The nose gives the face a definite turn, while the eyes carry the encounter back towards the viewer. We are neither looking at a strict profile nor receiving the symmetrical address of a fully frontal head. The face seems engaged with someone just outside its bodily alignment. That makes the gaze feel alert, although alertness in a portrait should not be mistaken for proof of a particular thought or mood.

The background provides little narrative information, yet it is essential to the composition. Its warm brown field separates the dark hair from the upper edge and gives the head space to turn. At the lower left, clothing and background approach one another in tone; around the brighter ear and collar, separation becomes much more definite. The sitter is consequently established by an alternation of firm and softer boundaries, rather than by an equally emphatic outline all the way around.

Schulman draws attention to the contrast between more heavily worked light passages and thinner shadows, especially the collar and ear against coat and background. That account helps explain why such a restrained arrangement can feel forceful: the accents of brightness seem concentrated rather than dispersed. The contrast belongs to the construction of the portrait; it cannot establish the sitter’s private feelings. [2]

Schulman places the picture within the realist portrait tradition of the 1850s and 1860s, naming painters including Courbet and Fantin-Latour. The connection is useful because the format itself is conventional: a single dressed sitter, a plain ground and a turned head. The force of the result lies in what happens within that familiar arrangement. Strong divisions of light and dark make the face hold together at a glance, while the collar gives the otherwise subdued painting a clear accent. Its modern presence does not require a wholly new subject or an elaborate setting. [2]

A painter without his tools

Chicago’s museum interprets its palette self-portrait as both an exercise in observing a reversed mirror image and a declaration of professional purpose, following Bazille’s decision to leave medicine for painting. The visible palette and brushes make that interpretation concrete. We see a man presenting himself through his work, even though his easel and canvas remain outside the picture. That museum reading belongs specifically to the Chicago composition. [3]

In Minneapolis, costume carries more of the burden. The dark coat and light collar offer the recognisable appearance of a dressed contemporary man without identifying a particular occupation. The omission of tools does not make the picture less ambitious. It moves the emphasis from the public signs of being a painter to the painter’s ability to construct a convincing presence. The face itself becomes the main subject of the demonstration.

This need not be read as a rejection of the earlier self-image. The competing dates do not support a confidently narrated progression from one psychological state to another. What the two pictures establish is a range of pictorial choices: a larger image that names the profession through objects, and a smaller image that concentrates on the head. Neither needs to be made into an unguarded confession to explain its interest.

Bazille’s letters supply a more secure account of his working ambitions than an imagined inner monologue. Writing to his father on 6 January 1865, he explained that he was painting from the living model in Monet’s studio. “I must paint a great many figures this winter,” he wrote, in a translation from his French, before explaining that the work would prepare him to make good use of spring and summer in the countryside. The remark places figure painting within a sustained programme of learning, rather than treating portraiture as an occasional diversion from landscape. [4]

That letter does not identify the Minneapolis canvas. It does clarify the kinds of problems a head study could address: modelling a face, making a turn convincing and relating a figure to surrounding space. Nor does the availability of the painter’s own face prove that money forced this particular choice of subject. Self-portraiture offered an opportunity to practise and to present oneself, but the circumstances of this sitting remain less certain than the painted result.

Watch: Bazille and early Impressionism

Explore a Paris studio with Smarthistory, then discover the beginnings of Impressionism with the National Gallery of Art.

Faces among friends

The Minneapolis portrait becomes more distinctive beside Bazille’s Portrait of Renoir, dated 1867 in the Musée d’Orsay record. Renoir sits with his knees drawn up, his forearms resting across them. His pose fills the canvas through the interlocking shapes of legs, arms and hands. The head remains important, but it is one part of a conspicuous bodily arrangement against a pale wall. [5]

In the self-portrait, by contrast, the hands are absent and the shoulders provide a broad, relatively quiet support for the face. The comparison shows how much an impression of intimacy depends on framing. Renoir’s unusual seat and folded limbs give us an encounter with a person occupying a room. The Minneapolis sitter is detached from almost every indication of place. One portrait makes bodily arrangement memorable; the other makes the turn of a head sufficient.

The Portrait of Edmond Maître, painted in 1869 and now in the National Gallery of Art, offers another variation. Maître’s lowered head, book and cigar direct attention into the sitter’s immediate activity. His dark clothing and white collar provide a useful formal comparison, but his profile leads the gaze away from the viewer rather than returning it. The objects give that withdrawal a visible setting. [6]

Minneapolis has no comparable action to explain the eyes. There is no page being read and no hand interrupting a task. The encounter therefore remains open. We can describe the direction of the gaze and the arrangement of light without inventing the subject of the sitter’s attention. These portraits demonstrate Bazille’s interest in different ways of making a person present, through a compact head, a conspicuous pose or a carefully furnished moment.

His later Studio, Rue La Condamine places the artist within a larger social and working environment. The 1870 painting includes Bazille standing among visitors, pictures and studio furniture. Here professional identity is distributed across a whole room: displayed work, conversation, an easel and the relationships between people. [7]

The figure of Bazille in that studio picture also complicates the idea that every painted likeness of him must be a self-portrait. The contribution traditionally assigned to Manet is treated cautiously in Bruno Mottin’s technical discussion, which also explains that the room was painted before the figures were introduced. The studio is a constructed account of artistic company, not a single instantaneous record. Set beside it, the Minneapolis canvas feels unusually concentrated: its encounter excludes the surrounding community that the studio painting makes visible. [8]

Portrait of Renoir
Portrait of Renoir

Portrait of Edmond Maitre
Portrait of Edmond Maitre

How certain is the sitter’s identity?

Minneapolis currently calls the painting a self-portrait, and Schulman accepts that identification. There has nevertheless been dissent. Schulman reports that the 1992 Montpellier exhibition catalogue used the title Portrait d’homme, or Portrait of a Man, and records Dianne W. Pitman’s uncertainty about recognising Bazille in it. His own discussion argues for retaining the self-portrait identification. This is a disagreement about the sitter, not a reason to treat the painting’s attribution to Bazille as equally disputed. [2]

A likeness can change substantially with pose, lighting, beard and the way the painter builds the face. Those variables explain why comparing portraits requires care; they do not, on their own, settle the identity. The current museum title retains the self-portrait identification. The earlier question remains part of the picture’s interpretation, rather than the museum’s present conclusion.

The same care applies to the wider group of possible self-images. A work on paper associated with this discussion is now titled Portrait of a Bearded Man by the Musée d’Orsay. That title describes what is securely identifiable without deciding that the man is Bazille. It is a useful reminder that a bearded face is not sufficient evidence for adding another self-portrait to the group. [9]

The Minneapolis painting remains rewarding even as its title is considered critically. If it represents Bazille, it gives us one of his concentrated acts of self-presentation. The portrait’s visual achievement is the particular presence it creates through a few relationships: dark coat against brown field, pale collar beneath beard, and an oblique head whose eyes keep the viewer engaged.

From the Bazille family to Minneapolis

Schulman traces the canvas through the artist’s family, including his nephew Marc Bazille and subsequent descendants, before it passed through Knoedler & Co. in New York. Minneapolis acquired it in 1962 using the John R. Van Derlip Fund, the fund named in the museum’s current credit line. This history distinguishes the picture from the Chicago self-portrait, despite both entering their present American collections in the same year. [2] [1] [3]

Its exhibition history also predates its American acquisition. Schulman lists appearances in Paris in 1950 and Montpellier in 1959, followed by later exhibitions in the United States and Europe. The portrait was included in the 1992–93 retrospective context in which the sitter’s identity was questioned. The exhibition record therefore includes a period when the customary identification was being reconsidered. [2]

The National Gallery of Art’s 2017 retrospective checklist listed the Minneapolis and Chicago paintings separately as Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar and Self Portrait with Palette. It dated the Minneapolis picture to about 1865–67, close to the holding museum’s present range. Bringing both together made possible precisely the comparison their different formats invite: professional equipment in the larger painting, a tightly framed face in the smaller one. [10]

Schulman also records that the Minneapolis canvas was lined in 1947. That is a fact about its physical history, not evidence of a compositional revision by Bazille. The surviving portrait asks to be understood through the visible arrangement of head and clothing, while its dating, sitter identification and later treatment remain distinct questions. Within its modest dimensions, a few illuminated forms sustain a compelling encounter. [2]

Bazille catalogue directory

The 284 records comprise 85 painting records,40 separate works-on-paper records and 159 album or study records. They describe the catalogue’s organisation rather than 284 independent objects or unanimously accepted attributions. Recto, verso, albums and multiple studies remain distinct. Dates are qualified where needed; the Drawing filter includes the etching, gouache and mixed works on paper. Manuscript mentions and unproved projects are listed separately below.

Works known through documents

These mentions remain separate from the 284 catalogue records. Some may concern surviving studies or underlying compositions; they cannot simply be added together as missing physical paintings.

  • A copy after Rubens mentioned in March 1863 is unlocated.
  • A portrait of an unidentified woman was reported completed before July 1866.
  • A portrait of Monet and a composition of two life-size women arranging flowers were reported in progress in April 1867. Their mention does not establish two otherwise unknown surviving canvases.
  • Gertrude et le père Lapin was at least begun in the summer of 1870.

Further reported works and uncertain attributions

  • A Bouquet of Lilacs was reportedly stolen and returned in 1864; a portrait of the friend Theulier and Yellow Narcissi reported by Maître in 1868 are also documentary mentions.
  • Unidentified pictures associated with Guillemet and Mme Rolina are reported through later correspondence cited by the catalogue.
  • Children Dressed as Bride and Groom was associated with Vallotton’s collection and also attributed to Renoir. Its identification and authorship should remain open.

Projects whose completion is unproved

  • A portrait of Pauline was planned in July 1865.
  • A portrait of Marc was proposed in April 1866; a related drawing survives.
  • A Jardinière project appears in album inscriptions and related figure material. Written plans are not evidence of a completed painting.

284 records

NameDateMedium
Mystic Marriage of St. Catherine1863Oil on canvas
Trees, Study1863Oil on canvas
Farm of Saint-Sauveur1863Oil on canvas
In the Garden of the Parc Monceau, Paris1864Oil on canvas
Naked Woman from Behind1864Oil on canvas
Reclining Nude1864Oil on canvas
Courtyard of the Auberge du Cheval blanc at Chailly near Barbizon1864Oil on canvas
Covered Soup Bowls1864Oil on canvas
Two Herrings1864Oil on canvas
The Pink Dress1864Oil on canvas
The Dog Rita Asleep1864 (catalogue); c. 1864 (2017 checklist)Oil on canvas
The Scoter1864Oil on canvas
Naked Reclining Woman1864Oil on canvas
Landscape at Chailly1865Oil on canvas
Rocks at Chailly, Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Undergrowth at Chailly, Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Still Life with Grapes and Nuts1865Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait with a Palette — Chicago1865Oil on canvas
Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1865Oil on canvas
Beach at Sainte-Adresse1865Oil on canvas
The Improvised Field Hospital1865Oil on canvas
Village Street, Chailly1865Oil on canvas
Small Valley in the Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Forest of Fontainebleau1865Oil on canvas
Woman Ironing1866Oil on canvas
The Artist's Studio on the rue de Furstenberg1865–66 (museum)Oil on canvas
Still Life with Fish1866Oil on canvas
Little Italian Street Singer1866Oil on canvas
Potted Flowers1866Oil on canvas
The Little Gardener1866–1867Oil on canvas
Young Woman Playing the Piano1866–1867Oil on canvas
End of a Summer Day1866–1867Oil on canvas
A Studio on the rue Visconti1867Oil on canvas
Thérèse Reading in the Park at Méric1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Verlaine1867Oil on canvas
The Terrace at Méric1867Oil on canvas
Still Life with Heron1867Oil on canvas
The Family Gathering1867–68 (museum)Oil on canvas
Oleanders1867Oil on canvas
Woman on the Terrace at Méric1867Oil on canvas
The Ramparts at Aigues-Mortes from South1867Oil on canvas
The Western Ramparts at Aigues-Mortes1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Edmond Maître — head study1867Oil on canvas
Porte de la Reine at Aigues-Mortes1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Sisley1867Oil on wood
Portrait of Renoir — Cleveland1867Oil on canvas
Portrait of Renoir — Musée d’Orsay1867Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait with a Detachable Collar — Minneapolis1865–67 (museum); 1867–68 (catalogue)Oil on canvas
Vase of Flowers on a Console1868 (museum); 1867–68 (catalogue)Oil on canvas
Portrait of a Woman1868Oil on canvas
Young Woman in the Vineyards1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Basket1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Yellow Hat1868Oil on card
Harvester with a Headdress1868Oil on panel
On the Banks of the Lez1868Oil on canvas
After the Bath (attribution questioned)1868?Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Lowered Eyes1868Oil on canvas
Fisherman with a Net1868Oil on canvas
View of the Village1868Oil on canvas
Portrait of Bazille (attributed to Monet by Musée Fabre; disputed catalogue attribution)1864 (museum); 1868 (catalogue)Oil on panel
Studies for a Grape Harvest (two panels)1868Oil on canvas (two panels)
The Fortune Teller1868–69 (catalogue); c. 1869–70 (2017 checklist)Oil on canvas
Harvester with a Cap1869Oil on card
Portrait of Edmond Maître — 18691869Oil on canvas
Woman in a Moorish Costume1869Oil on canvas
Young Woman in the Garden1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of Alphonse Tissié in a Cavalryman's Uniform1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of a dragoon1869Oil on canvas
Portrait of Zacharie Astruc1869Oil on canvas
Bunch of Grapes in a Bucket1869Oil on card
Portrait of Edouard BlauProbably 1869; inscribed 1866Oil on canvas
Young Male Nude Lying on the Grass1870Oil on canvas
Summer Scene1869–1870Oil on canvas
The Studio on the rue La Condamine1869–1870Oil on canvas
La Toilette1870Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Peonies — Montpellier1870Oil on canvas
Young Woman with Peonies — Washington1870Oil on canvas
Monotonous Chant1870Oil on canvas
Flowers — private collection1870Oil on canvas
Flowers — Musée Fabre1870Oil on canvas
Young Fisherman1870Oil on canvas
Study for Ruth and Boaz1870Oil on wood
Ruth and Boaz1870Oil on canvas
Self-Portrait in Shirt Sleeves1870Oil on canvas
Landscape on the Banks of the Lez1870Oil on canvas
Study after an Alpine Landscape1860Graphite on watercolour-tinted paper
Profile Head1862Charcoal on laid paper
Studies after Delacroix1863Ink and graphite, with gouache and watercolour, on paper
Academic Head1863Charcoal on paper
Study of a Woman's Head in Profile on a Chair1863Charcoal on paper
Academic Head of a Woman1863Charcoal on paper
Academy of Woman1863Black pencil and charcoal, stumped, on watermarked laid paper
Academy of Man1863Black pencil and charcoal, stumped, on watermarked laid paper
Naked Man1863Charcoal on paper
The Pont au Change in Paris1864Watercolour on paper
Study for the Pink Dress or Portrait of Thérèse des Hours1864Black pencil on paper
Naked Woman Standing1864Pencil on paper
Study of a Reclining Nude1864Charcoal on paper
Bathers1864Charcoal on paper
Portrait of a Man1864Charcoal on paper
Study for The Pink Dress1864Black pencil, squared, on paper
Study for Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1864Graphite on paper
Study for Landscape of Saint-Sauveur1865Pencil on paper
Man Taming a Bull1866Pen and black pencil on paper
Man Half Lying on a Sofa1866Charcoal on paper
Study for The Family Gathering1867Pencil on paper
Study for The Family Gathering1867Graphite, charcoal and black pencil on paper
The Embroiderer1867Pencil on pink paper
Study of Children1867Pencil on paper
Women in a Garden1867Pencil drawing
View of the Village1868Etching on paper
Portrait of a Bearded Man (catalogued as Self-Portrait)Undated (museum); 1869 (catalogue)Charcoal and brown ink
Man Smoking Pipe1869Watercolour on paper
Manet Drawing1868–70(?) (museum)Charcoal and white chalk on paper
Study for the Summer Scene1869Charcoal, pen and ink on paper
Family Portrait1869Pastel and charcoal on paper
Study for Ruth1870Pencil and charcoal on paper
Woman Arranging a Hat1870Pencil drawing
Study for Boaz Asleep1870Pastel and red chalk
Boaz Asleep1870Charcoal and pencil on paper
Study for Boaz Asleep1870Black and beige pastel with red chalk on laid paper
Ruth Lying down1870Charcoal and pastel on paper
Head, Arm and Chest of Ruth1870Charcoal on paper
Chest of Ruth1870Black chalk and charcoal on paper
Black Woman with Peonies — gouachec. 1870Gouache, watercolour, pencil and black chalk on card
Various Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Rocky Sea SideUndatedCharcoal on paper
Studies of a Dancing WomanUndatedDrawing with white chalk
Study of a LegUndatedPencil drawing
Dancers in CamargueUndatedPencil drawing
Academy of WomanUndatedCharcoal
Caricature of Venus of Milo and Various Other CaricaturesUndatedCharcoal
CaricatureUndatedPencil drawing
Study of LandscapeUndatedCharcoal
Caricatures and Seated MonkUndatedCharcoal
Caricatures and Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Women Carrying a PitcherUndatedPencil drawing
The Hanged ManUndatedCharcoal
Castle in the PlainUndatedCharcoal
Naked Woman from BehindUndatedCharcoal
CaricaturesUndatedCharcoal and pencil
Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Landscape with a CastleUndatedCharcoal
Study of LandscapeUndatedCharcoal
Horse Rider seen from BehindUndatedCharcoal
MazeppaUndatedPencil and charcoal
Study of Rider and Others SubjectsUndatedPencil, pen and brown ink
Study of an Unidentified ManUndatedPencil drawing
Study for an Unknown Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study a Man ReadingUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Men ReadingUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Landscape ?UndatedCharcoal
Study of a Head of a ManUndatedPencil drawing
Erotic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study of DogUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Unidentified Subjects and Erotic SceneUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Study for a Theater SceneUndatedCharcoal
Study of a Reclining Naked WomanUndatedCharcoal
Two Studies of LandscapeUndatedPencil drawing
CaricatureUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Portrait of an Unidentified Young ManUndatedCharcoal
Study of an Unidentified SubjectUndatedBrown ink drawing
Unidentified Man with a HatUndatedPencil and charcoal
Study of an Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Theater Character ?UndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Theater Character ?UndatedPen drawing
The Pavillon de la Reine in ParisUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Horse RiderUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Entwined Couple. Caricature ?UndatedPencil drawing
Woman Sitting on a SofaUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil and charcoal drawing
Studies of AnimalsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Horse Rider in CamargueUndatedCharcoal
Study of Hunting DogsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of Soldiers. CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Hunting Dogs ?UndatedPencil drawing
Hunting Scene. Hunter Playing the HornUndatedPencil drawing
CaricatureUndatedPencil drawing
Study of an IbexUndatedPencil drawing
Theater Scene. CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Animals. Horses ?UndatedPencil drawing
CaricaturesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various Subjects and AnimalsUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified SubjectUndatedPencil drawing
Rider Taming a Horse [in Camargue ?]UndatedPencil drawing
Caricature of a SoldierUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Woman and MouseUndatedPencil drawing
Historic SceneUndatedCharcoal
Architecture StudiesUndatedPencil drawing
Mythologic SceneUndatedCharcoal
OpheliaUndatedPencil drawing
Mythologic SceneUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil and pen drawing
Studies of PeasantsUndatedPencil drawing
Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Historic or Literary SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified Historic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Unidentified StudyUndatedPencil drawing
Man in an ArmchairUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Portraits of Unidentified MenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Horse Rider and ArtistUndatedCharcoal and pencil
Study of Unidentified CharactersUndatedCharcoal
Dead Horse in a PlainUndatedCharcoal
Study of Various Subjects and FurnitureUndatedPencil drawing
Caricatures and Various Notes about OpéraUndatedPencil drawing
Galloping HorseUndatedCharcoal
Study for La ToiletteUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Naked WomanUndatedPencil drawing
Domestic SceneUndatedPencil drawing
PhysiognomiesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Female ProfilesUndatedPencil drawing
Various SubjectsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Terrace at MéricUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedCharcoal
Children PortraitsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Children's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Study of MinervaUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Family GatheringUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Young FishermanUndatedCharcoal
Self-PortraitsUndatedBlack pencil drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study of Horses for the Porte de la Reine at Aigues-MortesUndatedInk drawing
Study for an Outdoor ConcertUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of LegsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of HatsUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of MenUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Little GardenerUndatedPencil drawing
Study for The Ramparts at Aigues MortesUndatedCharcoal
Studies of Sail BoatsUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of Marc BazilleUndatedCharcoal, black pencil and graphite
Studies of Children's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Aigues-MortesUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Women's HeadsUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of Camille des Hours and an Unidentified ManUndatedCharcoal
Study of Flying BirdsUndatedCharcoal or graphite
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study of HandsUndatedPen drawing
Self-PortraitUndatedBlack pencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Summer SceneUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil drawing
Study of BranchesUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Seated ChildUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Couple and Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Unidentified WomenUndatedPencil drawing
Study of BuildingsUndatedPencil drawing
Study for a Grape HarvestUndatedPencil and charcoal
Studies of BoatersUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Man Writing at his TableUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Woman Cutting FlowersUndatedPencil drawing
Study of HandUndatedPencil drawing
Women in a GardenUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of Women in ProfileUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Ruth and BoazUndatedCharcoal
Study for The Family GatheringUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the View of the VillageUndatedPencil drawing
Study of the View of the VillageUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the Fisherman with a NetUndatedPencil drawing
Study for the View of the VillageUndatedCharcoal
Study for The Little GardenerUndatedCharcoal
Portrait of a Man with a Top HatUndatedPencil drawing
Portrait of a Man with a Top HatUndatedPencil drawing
InscriptionsUndatedPencil inscriptions
Study of TreeUndatedPencil drawing
Caricature of Nina la BelleUndatedPencil drawing
Study for Saint SebastianUndatedPencil drawing
Young Woman SewingUndatedPencil drawing
Studies of HandsUndatedPencil drawing
Woman in a GardenUndatedPencil drawing
Elegant WomanUndatedPencil drawing
Various InscriptionsUndatedInscriptions (medium unspecified in index)
Study of a Man with a HatUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a ChildUndatedPencil drawing
Study of a Man with a HatUndatedPencil drawing

Frequently Asked Questions

Which self-portrait is shown here?

This is the Minneapolis Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar, accession 62.39, rather than the palette portrait in Chicago. [1] [3]

When was it painted?

Minneapolis dates it 1865–67; Schulman’s catalogue proposes 1867–68. These are competing datings of the same canvas. [1] [2]

Has the sitter’s identity ever been questioned?

Yes. Schulman reports historical doubt about the sitter, while Minneapolis presents the work as a self-portrait. Sitter identification is distinct from attribution of the painting. [1] [2]

Discussion

The pale collar gives this compact portrait a sharp boundary. How does it change your encounter with the face?

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · The detachable collar

How does the pale collar separate the face from the dark clothing?

Editorial prompt · Two self-presentations

Compare this cropped encounter with the Chicago portrait’s more explicit presentation of the painter at work.

Editorial prompt · Uneven illumination

Which area of the face seems most clearly illuminated, and how does that affect the gaze?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Frédéric Bazille’s Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar below.

References

  1. Minneapolis Institute of Art, Self-Portrait with Detachable Collar, accession 62.39, current collection record and expanded object data. Museum record. View source.
  2. Michel Schulman, Self-Portrait with a Detachable Collar, MSb-39, digital catalogue raisonné, metadata, history, exhibitions and critical essay. Pitman’s 1992 position is reported through this source. Catalogue entry (English translation of a French scholarly catalogue). View source.
  3. Art Institute of Chicago, Self-Portrait, accession 1962.336, collection record, museum commentary and provenance. Museum record. View source.
  4. Frédéric Bazille, letter to his father, 6 January 1865, Musée Fabre, inventory 92.2.1, transcription p. 4 and facsimile p. 2. English quotation translated from the French. Museum facsimile and transcription (in French). View source.
  5. Musée d’Orsay, Pierre Auguste Renoir, collection record, DL 1970 3. Museum record (English interface with French collection fields). View source.
  6. National Gallery of Art, Edmond Maître, accession 1985.64.2, collection record. Museum record. View source.
  7. Musée d’Orsay, L’Atelier de Bazille, accession RF 2449, collection record and commentary. Museum record (English interface with French collection fields). View source.
  8. Bruno Mottin, “L’œuvre de Frédéric Bazille (1841–1870) examiné au laboratoire,” Technè 46 (2018), pp. 30–38, especially paragraphs 21–23. Article (in French). View source.
  9. Musée d’Orsay, Portrait d’homme barbu, Louvre inventory RF 29731 verso, current title and collection metadata. Museum record (in French). View source.
  10. National Gallery of Art, Frédéric Bazille and the Birth of Impressionism, 2017 exhibition checklist, p. 2, catalogue nos. 17–18. Exhibition checklist. View source.
  11. Joconde/POP, La Robe rose, RF2450. View source. (in French).
  12. Musée d’Orsay, L’Ambulance improvisée, RF 1967 5. View source. (in French).
  13. Musée d’Orsay, Réunion de famille,RF2749. View source. (in French).
  14. Musée Fabre, Vue de village, 898.5.1. View source. (in French).
  15. National Gallery of Art, Young Woman with Peonies,1983.1.6. View source.
  16. Michel Schulman, painting index and documentary introduction (English titles; French metadata). View source.
  17. Michel Schulman, works-on-paper index (English titles; French metadata). View source.
  18. Michel Schulman, albums and studies index (English titles; French metadata). View source.