Henrietta Maria as St Catherine before 2012 conservation, showing the enlarged canvas and later blue costume. Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience

Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

Portrait of Queen Henrietta Maria as St Catherine: Introduction

Henrietta Maria turns towards us above a lustrous red-brown sleeve, her raised hand close to her shoulder. This smaller portrait emerged beneath a larger blue-costumed image during conservation in 2012. Van Dyck scholar Christopher Brown’s reported assessment that year qualified its attribution to Anthony van Dyck. [1]

Attribution note: The image shows the enlarged painting before its 2012 conservation. The later assessment of Van Dyck’s involvement was provisional. [1]

At a Glance

  • Subject Queen Henrietta Maria represented as St Catherine of Alexandria.
  • Attribution Attributed to Anthony van Dyck in Brown’s reported 2012 assessment. [1]
  • Date About 1639 in the illustration list of Leanda de Lisle’s Henrietta Maria , published by Vintage in 2023. [2]
  • Medium Oil on canvas. [3] [2]
  • Collection Private collection, as recorded in the 2023 book. [2]

This work across Anthony van Dyck’s career

Year
16101620163016401645

Frans Snyders

about 1620

Rinaldo and Armida

1629–1632; Louvre commentary proposes late1631–spring1632

Charles I in Three Positions

1635–before June 1636

Portrait of Queen Henrietta Maria as St Catherine (current article)

c. 1639 in Leanda de Lisle’s published illustration caption; execution not independently resolved

Contents

  1. Looking at the two appearances
  2. What conservation established
  3. How much is by Van Dyck?
  4. A queen represented as a saint
  5. Copies and the survival of a composition

Looking at the two appearances

The blue version gives the queen a spacious setting. Her figure extends down into a broad skirt; an upright architectural division behind her separates the dark left side from a landscape on the right. One hand rises across her chest while the other hangs lower, its fingers resting near the edge of the blue fabric. The light catches long creases in the gown and the pale lace at the wrist. Those conspicuous passages make it easy to remember this as a picture of blue silk.

The smaller restored image changes the balance. The landscape, lower hand and spread of skirt disappear from the composition. A large red-brown sleeve fills the foreground, crossed by bright ridges and deep folds. Grey cloth curves over the shoulder and across the back. The body turns away while the head looks back, giving the pose a more pronounced twist than the expanded version suggests.

The face offers a useful point of comparison. In both images there are tightly curled locks beside the cheeks, a curl falling onto the forehead and a jewelled ornament behind the head. Yet the face appears much larger in relation to the restored picture’s edges. The eye moves between three concentrated areas: the illuminated head, the rounded sleeve and the raised forearm. Dark space surrounds them instead of opening into distant scenery.

The jewellery also behaves differently within each composition. Against the pale open neckline of the blue image, the necklace reads as one small element among many. In the restored portrait, its large pearls make a bright curve beneath the chin, close to the edge of the grey drapery. The crown’s irregular glints answer the highlights on the sleeve. These relationships can be studied without assuming that every visible passage was painted by the same person.

Calling these images simply a blue version and a red version would obscure their physical relationship. Here they record a painting before and after the removal of later material. A separate copy, by contrast, is another object. That distinction matters whenever a familiar reproduction is used to discuss the work.

What conservation established

The auction record preserves the enlarged picture’s former identity. Christie’s catalogued it as After Sir Anthony van Dyck , described its satin dress as white, and recorded a canvas measuring 127 × 101.6 cm. The photograph’s blue drapery is a more useful visual identifier than that brief costume description. Those dimensions belong to the expanded picture offered at auction; they cannot be transferred to the smaller restored portrait. [3]

Bendor Grosvenor, a participant in the purchase and investigation, described how the head and joins around a smaller rectangle drew his attention. The later painter and the date of the alterations remained unidentified. [1]

There is technical support for the sequence of paint layers. A University College London research case study states that Libby Sheldon’s examination of paint cross-sections established that this portrait had been painted over by a later artist. It identifies the work as an unfinished portrait of Henrietta Maria as St Catherine. [4]

The distinction between sequence and authorship is essential. Evidence that one layer lies over another helps explain how the image changed. Assigning an individual painter’s hand involves a further judgement about the surviving earlier work. The UCL account establishes a material history of alteration; its short account of the analysis does not demonstrate that every part underneath is by Van Dyck himself. [4]

The restored image retains visible differences of finish. The sleeve has a richly developed pattern of shadow and reflected light, while the raised hand is more broadly stated. Around the head, small strokes and uneven transitions sit beside carefully modelled features. These variations give the picture particular interest: the viewer encounters passages at different stages of development. They do not, by themselves, identify which painter worked on each area.

Watch: Van Dyck’s art and working methods

Choose a museum introduction, a specialist lecture or a conservation film to continue exploring Van Dyck’s work.

How much is by Van Dyck?

In 2012 Grosvenor reported Christopher Brown’s initial judgement: certainly unfinished, certainly from Van Dyck’s studio, with a good chance that the head was autograph, pending comparison and research. Brown accepted “Attributed to Van Dyck”. Here, autograph means painted by Van Dyck himself. [1]

That wording preserves several possibilities. A picture originating in a master’s studio can contain different degrees of his participation. An unfinished work can also make familiar comparisons harder: a face brought to a high degree of finish and a hand still being developed offer different kinds of evidence. The broader questions are explored in Van Dyck’s workshop and influence .

Later naming should be read with the same attention to its purpose. The illustration list in Leanda de Lisle’s Henrietta Maria gives the portrait to Van Dyck and dates it about 1639. That is useful evidence of how the work was presented in the 2023 edition. The caption supplies no new argument resolving Brown’s qualified assessment, and the approximate date should not be mistaken for a result of laboratory analysis. [2]

The head rewards close attention whatever degree of certainty one attaches to the attribution. A narrow light runs along the nose; the lower lip is softly picked out; shadow beneath the chin makes the neck turn palpable. The curls vary from distinct loops against the skin to looser marks along the outer edge. Such features explain why a viewer might want to investigate the head closely. They remain observations to bring to an attribution argument, rather than a substitute for one.

A queen represented as a saint

The title brings together an identifiable sitter and a sacred role. St Catherine of Alexandria was traditionally represented as a princess, with a crown and the attributes of her martyrdom. The National Gallery’s account of Crivelli’s Saint Catherine of Alexandria explains the familiar palm and spiked wheel. That older painting provides a clear guide to the symbolism, without establishing a direct connection between the two works. [5]

Here the jewelled crown sits behind the queen’s curls, while a dark, narrow frond appears beside the raised hand. Against the subdued background, that palm is much less immediately conspicuous than the sleeve or the pearls. No complete wheel is clearly legible in the reproduced restored image. The saintly identity is conveyed within a concentrated portrait, with little space for a surrounding narrative.

The combination allows the crown to carry two associations: the sitter’s royal position and Catherine’s princely identity. This is a visual reading of the image. It does not establish who proposed the subject, where the portrait was intended to hang or what Henrietta Maria privately felt about the saint. The surviving appearance can sustain an interpretation of sacred and royal identity without supplying a lost commission history.

For another treatment of the queen, Queen Henrietta Maria with Sir Jeffrey Hudson offers a separate composition and a different relationship between the sitter and her surroundings. Its object history should be kept distinct from this portrait’s conservation and attribution.

Copies and the survival of a composition

Grosvenor reported that the St Catherine composition had previously been known through copies. [1] A copy can preserve a pose or arrangement even when the status of its model is uncertain. Its usefulness depends on asking what it records: a face, an attribute, a costume, or perhaps a more complete composition.

The before-and-after images raise a different question. Their changes encompass the silhouette, the background and the figure’s relationship to the edges. Looking only at the blue image, one might discuss a queen displayed in a landscape. Looking at the restored portrait, one encounters a turning figure pressed close to the foreground, with the hand and sleeve occupying much of the available space. Keeping these states separate allows both the painting’s earlier design and its subsequent transformation to be seen clearly.

Artworks directory

A selected directory of paintings, drawings and prints, including works discussed in the articles and the Frick’s 2016 portraiture exhibition. It is not a complete catalogue of Van Dyck’s work. Print titles identify collaborators or later printmakers; disputed and workshop attributions are retained. The exhibition checklist supplies additional object records; current collection information governs the updated article entries. [6]

134 records

NameDateMedium
Portrait of a Seventy-Year-Old Man1613Painting
Self-Portrait (Vienna)c. 1613–15Painting
Self-Portrait (Rubenshuis)c. 1615–17Painting
Head Study of a Youthc. 1615–17Painting
Head Study of a Red-Haired Young Woman Looking Downc. 1618–20Painting
Portrait Study of a Standing Man (Alexander Vincque?)1616 or beforeDrawing
The Jesuit Nicolas Trigault in Chinese Costume1617Drawing
Portrait of a Carmelite Friarc. 1618Painting
Frans Snydersabout 1620Painting
Margareta de Vosabout 1620Painting
Self-Portrait (Metropolitan Museum)c. 1620–21Painting
Horseman with His Groomabout 1628–32 (current Met record)Drawing
Guido Bentivoglio, Seated (?)about 1623Drawing
Cardinal Guido Bentivoglio1623Painting
George Gage with Two Menc. 1622–23Painting
Genoese Noblewomanc. 1625–27Painting
Standing Woman in a Nun’s Habit (identity unknown)about 1627Drawing
Commander on Horseback1621–about 1627, Italian periodDrawing
Portrait Study of Nicholas Lanier1628Drawing
Nicholas Lanierc. 1628 in Frick 2016; c. 1632 current KHMPainting
Anna van Thielen and Her Daughterc. 1631–32Drawing
Portrait Study of Henrietta of Lorraine1634.Drawing
Lady with Studies of Her HandsEarly 17th century (current Met record)Drawing
Cesare Alessandro Scaglia, Seatedabout 1634Drawing
Cesare Scaglia Adoring the Virgin and Childc. 1634–35Painting
Marie-Claire de Croÿ with Her Son Philippe-Eugène1634Painting
Johann of Nassau-Siegen in ArmourAbout 1634Drawing
Two Studies of Cesare Alessandro ScagliaAbout 1634Drawing
Johann of Nassau-Siegen, SeatedAbout 1634Drawing
Ernestine Yolande with Her Sonabout 1634Drawing
Portrait Study of Quintijn Simonsabout 1634Drawing
Justice Flanked by Seven Magistrates of the City of Brusselsc. 1634Painting
Portrait Study of a Man, Facing Rightc. 1634Painting
Portrait Study of a Man, Looking Leftc. 1634Painting
Self-Portrait (first state, Fitzwilliam) — Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Etching
Anthony van Dyck (third state) — Anthony van Dyck and Jacob Neefsc. 1644Etching and engraving
Anthony van Dyck (fourth state) — Lucas Vorsterman the Elder after Anthony van Dyckc. 1635Engraving
Hendrik van Balenc. 1627–32Drawing
Pieter Brueghel the Youngerc. 1627–35Drawing
Pieter Brueghel the Younger (first state) — Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Etching
Adriaen Brouwerc. 1634Painting
Gaspar de Crayerc. 1627–35Drawing
Gaspar de Crayerc. 1627–35Painting
Manuel Frockas1631–32?Drawing
Manuel Frockas1631–32?Painting
Orazio Gentileschic. 1635Drawing
Gaspar Gevaertsc. 1627–35Drawing
Gaspar Gevaertsc. 1627–35Painting
Inigo Jones1632–36Drawing
Joos de Momper the Younger (first state) — Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Etching
Joos de Momper the Younger (third state) — Lucas Vorsterman the Elder after Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Etching and engraving
Paulus Pontius (second state) — Anthony van Dyck and an unidentified engraverc. 1627–30Etching
Paulus Pontius (fifth state) — Paulus Pontius after Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Engraving
Jan van Ravesteyn1628–29 or 1632Drawing
Nicolaas Rockoxc. 1627–35Drawing
Nicolaas Rockox1636Painting
Nicolaas Rockox (first state) — Paulus Pontius after Anthony van Dyck1639Engraving
Frans Snyders (first state) — Anthony van Dyckc. 1627–35Etching
Hendrick van Steenwijck the Youngerc. 1632–38Drawing
Lucas Vorstermanc. 1631?Drawing
Lucas Vorsterman (first state) — Anthony van Dyckc. 1631?Etching
Lucas Vorsterman the Elder (fourth state) — Lucas Vorsterman the Younger after Anthony van Dyckc. 1650?Engraving
Sebastiaan Vrancxc. 1628–31Drawing
Jan Wildensc. 1627–32Drawing
Jan van den Wouwer (second state) — Anthony van Dyck; additional work attributed to Lucas Vorsterman the Elder1632?Etching and engraving
Frederick Henry, Prince of Orange (third state) — Paulus Pontius after Anthony van Dyckc. 1638?Engraving
Michiel le Blon (sixth state) — Theodor Matham after Anthony van Dyck1632–54Engraving
Charles I and Henrietta Maria Holding a Laurel Wreath (second state) — Robert van Voerst after Anthony van Dyck1634Engraving
Charles I and Henrietta Maria Holding a Laurel Wreath1632Painting
Portrait Study of Charles Ic. 1632–36Drawing
Queen Henrietta Maria with Jeffrey Hudson (study)1633Drawing
Queen Henrietta Maria with Sir Jeffrey Hudson1633Painting
The Princesses Elizabeth and Anne, Daughters of Charles I1637Painting
Prince William of Orange and Mary, Princess Royal1641Painting
Portrait Study of Endymion Porter and His Son Philipc. 1632–33Drawing
Two Portrait Studies of Philip Porterc. 1632–33Drawing
Study of the Upper Body and Hands of George Porterc. 1632–33Drawing
Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, Turned to the Rightc. 1635–36Drawing
Thomas Howard, Earl of Arundel, Seatedc. 1635–36Drawing
Portrait Study of James, William and John Herbert, Standing on Stairs1633–35Drawing
Portrait Study of James Stuart, Standingc. 1633Drawing
Two Studies of a Greyhoundc. 1633Drawing
Portrait Study of a Young Man (Bernard Stuart?)c. 1638Drawing
Portrait Study of a Young Man in Classical Garbc. 1632–41Drawing
Study of the Head of a Lady Facing Leftc. 1635–40Drawing
Lady Anne Carey, Later Countess of Clanbrassilc. 1636Painting
James Stanley, Lord Strange, with His Wife Charlotte and Their Daughterc. 1636Painting
John Sucklingc. 1638Painting
Pomponne II de Bellièvrec. 1637–40Painting
Edmund Verneyc. 1640Painting
Portrait of a Womanc. 1640Painting
Head Study of a Reclining Woman, Possibly Margaret Lemonc. 1638–39?Drawing
Margaret Lemonc. 1638Painting
Margaret Lemon (second state) — Jean Morin after Anthony van Dyck1646Etching
Mary, Lady van Dyck, née Ruthvenc. 1640Painting
François Langlois, Playing a Musette1641?Drawing
François Langlois, Playing a Musette1641?Painting
Charles I at the Huntabout 1636 (Ducos2023); broader discussion often about 1635Painting
Charles I in Three Positions1635–before June 1636Painting
Crucifixionabout 1630Painting
Cupid and Psyche1639–40Painting
Entry of Christ into Jerusalemabout 1617Painting
Equestrian Portrait with M de St Antoine1633Painting
James Stuart Duke of Lennox and Richmondca1633–35Painting
The Lomellini Familyc. 1625–27Painting
Lord John Stuart and his Brotherabout 1638Painting
Lord Philip Wharton1632Painting
Madonna and Child — workshop of Van Dyck (2026 notice)1620–30Painting
Marchesa Elena Grimaldi Cattaneo1623Painting
Portrait of Cornelis van der Geestabout 1620Painting
Portrait of Isabella Brant1621 (current NGA)Painting
Portrait of Olivia Boteler Porterc. 1637 (current museum wording)Painting
Henrietta Maria as St Catherine — attributed to Van Dyck (provisional 2012 assessment)c. 1639 in Leanda de Lisle’s published illustration caption; execution not independently resolvedPainting
Rest on the Flight into Egyptc. 1630Painting
Saint Ambrose and Theodosiusabout 1619–20Painting
Saint Martin and the Beggarc. 1618–20Painting
Saint Rosalie Interceding for the Plague1624Painting
Self Portraitc. 1640Painting
Self-Portrait with a Sunflowerabout 1633 (dates vary)Painting
The Shepherd Parisabout 1628Painting
Silenus Drunkc. 1619–20Painting
Sir Endymion Porter and Anthony van Dyckc. 1633 in current own-museum tour; Brown essay proposes spring1635Painting
Thetis Receiving Achilles’s Weapons — workshop of Van Dyckabout 1630/1632Painting
Virgin and Child with Two Donorsc. 1630–32Painting
The Vision of the Blessed Hermann Josephc. 1629/1630Painting
Samson and Delilahabout 1618–20Painting
Rinaldo and Armida1629–1632; Louvre commentary proposes late1631–spring1632Painting
Anton Giulio Brignole-Sale1627Painting
Paolina Adorno Brignole-Sale1627Painting
Lamentation of Christ — Circle of Rubens, Munich 404about 1620Painting
Lamentation of Christ — Vienna GG486about 1618–20Painting
Deposition — Oxford WA1869.1about 1619Painting
Lamentation of Christ — Antwerp 404about 1640Painting
Equestrian Portrait of Charles I — National Gallery, NG1172about 1638–9Painting

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the blue dress part of the original portrait?

It belongs to the enlarged state before conservation. The restored portrait’s sleeve is red-brown, with grey drapery. [1] [4]

Has the whole painting been confirmed as Van Dyck’s own work?

Brown’s reported assessment remains qualified. Paint-layer evidence establishes later alteration, without identifying the hand responsible for each earlier passage. [1] [4]

How large is the restored painting?

The auction measurement, 127 × 101.6 cm, describes the expanded state. That record does not supply a measurement for the smaller restored picture. [3]

Where is the portrait now?

De Lisle’s 2023 edition lists a private collection. The Banqueting House display notice dates from 2012; present access remains unverified. [1] [2]

Discussion

Look again at the images and ideas explored in Portrait of Queen Henrietta Maria as St Catherine. These editorial prompts invite your observations.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

How does the removal of the landscape and lower figure change your attention to the queen’s head and raised hand?

Editorial prompt · Comparison

Which details in the restored portrait make the relationship between royal sitter and saint most apparent to you?

Editorial prompt · Context

How should a picture’s uneven degree of finish affect the way we compare the quality of its different passages?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Portrait of Queen Henrietta Maria as St Catherine below.

References

  1. Bendor Grosvenor , Before ’n After, Art History News , 1 October 2012. Participant’s account of the purchase, conservation and initial attribution assessment. English. View source .
  2. Leanda de Lisle , Henrietta Maria: Conspirator, Warrior, Phoenix Queen , Vintage, 2023, first published 2022, list of illustrations, p. xiv, official publisher’s sample. English. View source .
  3. Christie’s , After Sir Anthony van Dyck: Portrait of Queen Henrietta Maria (1609–1669), Christie’s Interiors , sale 4102, lot 261. Record of the expanded picture before conservation. English. View source .
  4. University College London , The benefits of Painting Analysis for conservation and our cultural heritage, REF 2014 impact case study, p. 3. English. View source .
  5. The National Gallery , London, Carlo Crivelli: Saint Catherine of Alexandria, NG788.4, online collection entry, used for Catherine’s traditional attributes. English. View source .
  6. The Frick Collection, Van Dyck: The Anatomy of Portraiture, online exhibition checklist (2016). View source.