Thistle by Paul Cézanne: Introduction
A round flower head holds the far end of a jagged stem; most of the sheet remains open around it. Cézanne’s Thistle makes a small plant study feel unusually spacious. The graphite is concentrated in a narrow tangle of leaves, stalk, and flower toward one side of the paper. Its different pressures of line invite the eye to separate growth from the pencil movements that describe it.
This leaf of Cézanne’s Washington sketchbook is catalogued as FWN 3015-31a, dated 1893–96, and titled Étude de chardon in the online catalogue raisonné. The circumstances of the sitting remain unknown. [1]
At a Glance
- Artist Paul Cézanne. [2]
- Title Thistle ; the catalogue raisonné also gives Étude de chardon and Study of a thistle . [1]
- Date 1893–96. [2] [1]
- Medium Graphite on wove paper. [2]
- Collection National Gallery of Art, Washington, DC; accession 1992.51.9.xx. [2]
- Sketchbook Page XXXI of the CP III or Washington sketchbook. [1]
This work across Paul Cézanne’s career
The Kiss of the Muse
c.1860The Artist’s Father, Reading L’Événement
autumn 1866The Hanged Man’s House
c.1873A Modern Olympia
1873–74Maincy Bridge
1879–80The Blue Vase
1889–90The Basket of Apples
c.1893Apples and Oranges
c.1899The Large Bathers (Philadelphia)
1900–1906 (Philadelphia Museum dating)Château Noir (MoMA)
1903–04Contents
- The plant and the pencil
- A leaf within a working sketchbook
- Beside another flower study
- The book’s later journey
The plant and the pencil
Start with the flower head. It is built from curves laid around a rounded core, rather than enclosed by a single firm contour. Some lines overshoot the circle and become the tips of surrounding bracts. Others double back, so that the head seems to have both a solid center and a frayed outer edge. A few faint strokes rise above it. They are light enough to leave the paper visible between them, and their looseness keeps the top of the plant from becoming a sealed shape.
The stalk runs diagonally into that head, with several lines competing to define its edge. Below it, long pointed leaves turn away in different directions. One slim form projects almost horizontally, while another drops in a curve. At the central knot, shorter hooked strokes accumulate. The drawing therefore changes character across a very small area: stretched parallel lines for the stem, sharp angular thrusts for leaves, short curls for the crowded junction, and broad arcs for the flower.
There is no tabletop, jar, horizon, or cast shadow to explain where the plant sits. The white area to its left is part of the composition’s working space. It lets the extended leaves reach outward without meeting another object, while making the dense contact of stem and head more noticeable. The plant is recognizable without a surrounding scene, but the image leaves unanswered whether Cézanne was drawing a cut specimen, one still growing, or a motif recalled from elsewhere. The marks establish a shape; they do not document the encounter.
The sheet rewards a second look at its softer lines. Near the flower, several arcs are so close that they could be successive attempts to locate an edge, indications of overlapping plant parts, or both. The drawing does not force a single answer. What matters visually is the slight shift from one line to its neighbour: the rounded head seems to thicken, while the pencil’s search remains visible. This is why the work feels more active than its modest scale might suggest.
Tone plays a smaller role than direction. There is no broad patch of graphite to make the flower head dark or to push the leaves into shadow. Instead, a contour becomes stronger when Cézanne passes near it again, or when several strokes converge at a joint. The darkest-looking passages are local collisions of lines. This allows the pointed foliage to keep its wiry character: a leaf can be indicated by two changing edges and a gap of bare paper between them. The round flower, by contrast, gathers curved lines on and around its surface. Both forms emerge from marks that remain plainly marks.
A leaf within a working sketchbook
The catalogue gives the sheet as 15.2 by 23.7 centimetres; the Gallery reverses that dimension order. [1] [2]
The number marks recall the sketchbook’s later history. The National Gallery records “XXXI” and “59” as graphite additions by a later hand, not as Cézanne’s signatures or dates. In the image above, they sit near the sheet’s opposite right corners. They can help identify the physical leaf, but they cannot tell us the day on which the thistle was drawn. [2]
Charles S. Moffett’s 1991 account describes a book used across roughly two decades, with forty-six surviving sheets and a striking variety of subjects: family portraits, landscapes, household objects, vegetation, figures, and studies after older art. He also notes that its numbered sequence does not match a sequence of work; Cézanne could open the book at different places, and drawings of different dates can appear together. Even the Roman numeral XXXI occurs twice. The thistle’s numbered position is therefore a location in the surviving book, not a step in a botanical diary. [3]
MoMA’s 2021 survey describes Cézanne’s wider drawing practice as repeated investigation on individual sheets and in sketchbooks. The thistle’s clustered contours offer one small instance of that search. [4]
Beside another flower study
A nearby recorded leaf is Peonies , FWN 3015-30a, another graphite plant drawing dated 1890–93. These date ranges do not establish consecutive sittings or a preparatory link. The pair offers a comparison within the surviving book. [5]
On the peony sheet, broad scalloped blossoms occupy the right, while oval leaves spread leftward. The thistle has a tighter head and narrower, more pointed foliage: two distinct patterns of expansion. [5]
The thistle also resists the symmetry its circular head might promise. Its lower leaves pull the arrangement down, while the finer strokes above it lift it back toward the upper edge. A long diagonal through the stem is checked by short, nearly horizontal marks to one side. This imbalance keeps the eye moving among parts instead of settling on the flower alone. The plant reads as one connected organism, yet the individual pencil decisions are easy to follow. A viewer can move between those two experiences—recognition of the thistle and attention to the drawing’s construction—without choosing one as the final meaning.
The book’s later journey
After Cézanne, the book passed to his son Paul, then to the dealer Paul Guillaume, and then to Adrien Chappuis. Chappuis held it until 1967; Mr. and Mrs. Paul Mellon subsequently promised it to the National Gallery. This history concerns the whole book, not an independently circulating thistle sheet. [3]
The drawing itself supplies no written explanation of why this subject was chosen. Its strong evidence is visual: a small, resistant form given generous room on the page. The close-up concentration of graphite can be approached as a study of how a plant joins and forks. If Cézanne revised a contour, the earlier trace stays present rather than being hidden by colour. In places the leaf tips are sharply resolved; elsewhere, near the head, a cluster of alternatives remains. The result holds observation and uncertainty together, without requiring a symbolic reading of the thistle.
Cézanne artworks directory
Browse 217 identified works in this researched selection, including paintings, drawings and watercolours. This is a bounded selection, not a complete catalogue of Cézanne’s surviving oeuvre. Unlinked titles have no confirmed article in this collection.
| Name | Date | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| A Head, a Cup, and a Bread Roll | 1891/1894 | Drawing |
| A Man seen from Behind | 1880/1883 | Drawing |
| A Modern Olympia | 1873–74 | Painting |
| A Nude and Foliage | 1879/1882 | Drawing |
| A Smoking Man | 1892–96 (catalogue); c.1890–92 (museum) | Drawing |
| Afternoon in Naples | 1876–77 | Painting |
| An Old Woman with a Rosary | about 1895–96 | Painting |
| Apples and Oranges | c.1899 | Painting |
| Auvers, Panoramic View | 1873–75 | Painting |
| Avenue at Chantilly | 1888 | Painting |
| Banks of the Marne | 1888–94 | Painting |
| Basket | 1877/1900 | Drawing |
| Bather with Outstretched Arms | 1877–78 | Painting |
| Bellows in Front of a Fireplace | 1887/1892 | Drawing |
| Bibémus Quarry | c.1895 | Painting |
| Boy in a Red Vest, Barnes Foundation | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Boy in a Red Vest, MoMA | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Boy in a Red Waistcoat, National Gallery of Art | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Branch in Flower | 1886/1889 | Drawing |
| Carnival Scene | 1885/1888 | Drawing |
| Chair and Dresser | 1880/1883 | Drawing |
| Chateau Noir | 1903–04 | Painting |
| Chestnut Trees and Farm at Jas de Bouffan | c.1885 | Painting |
| Chestnut Trees and Farm at Jas de Bouffan, Pushkin | c.1886 | Painting |
| Chestnut Trees at Jas de Bouffan in Winter | 1885–86 | Painting |
| Château Noir | 1900–04 | Painting |
| Cistern in the Park of Château Noir | c.1900 | Painting |
| Curtain, Jug and Fruit | 1893–94 | Painting |
| Cushion of an Armchair | 1886/1889 | Drawing |
| Draft Letter and Studies of Bathers | c.1878 | Drawing |
| Farmhouse and Chestnut Trees at Jas de Bouffan | 1884–85 | Painting |
| Figure Resting Head on Hand | c. 1889 | Drawing |
| Fireplace Tongs and Poker | 1887/1892 | Drawing |
| Forest Interior, San Francisco | c.1898–99 | Painting |
| Four Bathers | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Fruit and a Jug on a Table | 1893–94 | Painting |
| Gardanne | 1885–86 | Painting |
| Gardanne, Barnes Foundation | c.1885 | Painting |
| Hand and Shoulder of a Boy | c. 1885 | Drawing |
| Harlequin, National Gallery of Art | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Head of a Boy | 1887/1889 | Drawing |
| Head of a Boy Seen from Behind | c. 1885 | Drawing |
| Head of a Young Woman | c. 1880 | Drawing |
| Head of the Artist's Son | 1888/1889 | Drawing |
| Hillside in Provence | c.1890–92 | Painting |
| Horse Chestnut Trees at Jas de Bouffan | c.1885 | Painting |
| House and Farm at the Jas de Bouffan | c.1887 | Painting |
| House in a Park | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| House in Provence | c.1885 | Painting |
| House of Père Lacroix | 1873 | Painting |
| House Surrounded by Vegetation | 1889/1892 | Drawing |
| Houses in Provence The Riaux Valley near L’Estaque | c.1883 | Painting |
| Jas de Bouffan, the Pool | c.1876 | Painting |
| Kerosene Lamp | 1878/1881 | Drawing |
| L'Estaque, Melting Snow | c.1870 | Painting |
| Lake Annecy | 1896 | Painting |
| Landscape in Provence, Pola Museum | 1879–82 | Painting |
| Landscape Near Aix-en-Provence | 1877/1880 | Drawing |
| Landscape Seen from the Inside of a Cave | 1889/1892 | Drawing |
| Landscape with Poplars | c.1885–87 | Painting |
| Landscape with Trees | 1895/1898 | Drawing |
| Leda and the Swan | c.1880 (possibly later) | Painting |
| Little Girl with a Doll | 1902–04 | Painting |
| Louis Guillaume | 1879–1890 | Painting |
| Madame Cezanne | 1888/1891 | Drawing |
| Madame Cezanne | 1886/1889 | Drawing |
| Madame Cezanne | 1882/1887 | Drawing |
| Madame Cezanne | 1897/1900 | Drawing |
| Madame Cezanne with her Head Lowered | 1893/1896 | Drawing |
| Madame Cézanne in a Red Armchair | c.1877 | Painting |
| Madame Cézanne in a Red Dress, Metropolitan Museum of Art | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Madame Cézanne in a Yellow Chair | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Madame Cézanne in a Yellow Chair, Fondation Beyeler | 1888–90 | Painting |
| Madame Cézanne in the Conservatory | 1891 | Painting |
| Maincy Bridge | 1879–80 | Painting |
| Maison Maria with a View of Château Noir | c.1895 | Painting |
| Man Bending Forward | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Man Smoking a Pipe, Pushkin | c.1891, possibly later | Painting |
| Man with a Pipe | 1891–96 | Painting |
| Man with a Pipe, Nelson-Atkins | 1890–92 | Painting |
| Man with a Straw Hat (Gustave Boyer) | c.1871 | Painting |
| Man with Crossed Arms | c.1899 | Painting |
| Man with Pipe, National Gallery of Art | 1892–96 | Painting |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire | c.1902–06 | Painting |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire | 1900–02 | Painting |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire (recto) | c.1895 | Watercolour |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire and the Viaduct of the Arc River Valley | 1882–85 | Painting |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire Seen beyond the Wall of the Jas de Bouffan | c.1885/1888 | Watercolour |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire Seen from Bibémus Quarry | c.1897 | Painting |
| Mont Sainte-Victoire, Barnes Foundation | 1892–95 | Painting |
| Near the Pool at Jas de Bouffan | 1883/1887 | Drawing |
| Pelicans | 1877/1880 | Drawing |
| Peonies | 1890/1893 | Drawing |
| Pierrot and Harlequin | 1888 | Painting |
| Pine Tree | 1882/1885 | Drawing |
| Pont des Trois Sautets | 1906 | Watercolour |
| Poplars | 1879–80 | Painting |
| Portrait of Ambroise Vollard | 1899 | Painting |
| Portrait of Gustave Geffroy | 1895–96 | Painting |
| Portrait of Madame Cezanne with Loosened Hair | 1885–86 | Painting |
| Portrait of the Artist Looking Over His Shoulder | 1883–84 | Painting |
| Portrait of the Gardener Vallier | 1906 | Painting |
| Portrait of Victor Chocquet | 1876–77 | Painting |
| Portrait Of Victor Chocquet Seated | 1877 | Painting |
| Provençal Manor | c.1885 | Painting |
| Pyramid of Skulls | 1898–1900 | Painting |
| Reclining Nude (Leda?) | c.1887 | Painting |
| Scipio | 1866–68 | Painting |
| Seated Man, Oslo | 1898–1900 | Painting |
| Seated Peasant | c.1892–96 | Painting |
| Seated Peasant, Hiroshima | c.1897 | Painting |
| Seated Peasant, Orsay | c.1900 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait | c. 1895 | Drawing |
| Self-Portrait in a Bowler Hat, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek | 1885–86 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait in a Casquette | c.1875 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with a Beret | 1898–1900 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with a Hat, Artizon Museum | c.1890–94 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with a Pink Background | c.1875 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with Olive-Coloured Wallpaper | about 1880–81 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with Palette | 1886–87 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait with White Turban | c.1878–80 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait, c.1895 | c.1895 | Painting |
| Self-Portrait, Pushkin Museum | c.1882 | Painting |
| Spanish Dancers | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Still Life with a Curtain | 1892–94 | Painting |
| Still Life with Apples | c.1890 | Painting |
| Still Life with Apples | 1893–94 | Painting |
| Still Life with Apples and a Pot of Primroses | about 1890 | Painting |
| Still Life with Milk Jug and Fruit | c.1900 | Painting |
| Still Life with Open Drawer | 1877–79 | Painting |
| Still Life with Plaster Cupid | about 1894 | Painting |
| Still Life with Skull | 1890–93 | Painting |
| Still Life with Soup Tureen | 1877 | Painting |
| Still Life, Pitcher and Fruit | 1893–94 | Painting |
| Studies Including a Straw Hat | 1895/1898 | Drawing |
| Studies Including Madame Cezanne | 1884/1887 | Drawing |
| Study for "The Judgement of Paris" or "The Amorous Shepherd" | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Study for Woman with a Coffee Pot | c.1895 | Painting |
| Study of "The Roman Orator (Germanicus)" | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Study of "Venus de Milo" | 1881/1884 | Drawing |
| Study of a Decorative Ornament | 1879/1882 | Drawing |
| Study of a Standing Male Figure after the Antique | c. 1895 | Drawing |
| Study of an Angel in Rubens' "The Prophet Elijah" | 1892/1895 | Drawing |
| Study of Desiderio da Settignano's "Bust of a Child" | c. 1895 | Drawing |
| Study of Houses | 1879/1882 | Drawing |
| Study of Puget's "Hercules Resting" | c. 1879 | Drawing |
| Study of Puget's "Milo of Crotona" | 1895/1898 | Drawing |
| Study of Puget's "Milo of Crotona" | 1880/1883 | Drawing |
| Study of the Allegorical Figure Bellona in Rubens' "The Apotheosis of Henri IV" | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Study of the Allegorical Figure Bellona in Rubens' "The Apotheosis of Henri IV" | 1879/1882 | Drawing |
| Study of the Allegorical Figure France in Rubens' "The Exchange of the Two Princesses" | 1882/1885 | Drawing |
| Study of the Allegorical Figure of Health in Rubens' "The Birth of Louis XIII" | 1880/1883 | Drawing |
| Study of the Allegorical Figure of the Genius of Health from Rubens' "The Birth of Louis XIII at Fontainbleau" | 1895/1898 | Drawing |
| Sugar Bowl, Pears and Blue Cup | 1865–66 | Painting |
| The Aqueduct, Pushkin Museum | Dating differs between museum records | Painting |
| The Artist's Father, Reading L'Evenement | autumn 1866 | Painting |
| The Artist's Son | c. 1887 | Drawing |
| The Artist's Son Leaning on his Elbow | c. 1887 | Drawing |
| The Artist's Son Reading | c. 1887 | Drawing |
| The Artist's Son Writing | c. 1887 | Drawing |
| The Artist’s Son, Paul | 1886–87 | Painting |
| The Avenue at Jas de Bouffan | 1868–70 (possibly later) | Painting |
| The Avenue at Jas de Bouffan, Geneva | c.1890 | Painting |
| The Basket of Apples | c.1893 | Painting |
| The Bather, Museum of Modern Art | c.1885 | Painting |
| The Bay of Marseille seen from L'Estaque | c.1885 | Painting |
| The Blue Vase | 1889–90 | Painting |
| The Boy in the Red Vest, Bührle | 1888–90 | Painting |
| The Buffet | 1877–79 | Painting |
| The Card Players, Barnes Foundation | 1890–92 | Painting |
| The Card Players, Courtauld Gallery | 1892–96 | Painting |
| The Card Players, Metropolitan Museum of Art | 1890–92 | Painting |
| The Card Players, Musée d’Orsay | 1893–96 | Painting |
| The Card Players, Qatar | 1892–96 | Painting |
| The Eternal Feminine | c.1877 | Painting |
| The Gardener Vallier | 1906 | Painting |
| The Gardener Vallier, Tate | 1905–06 | Painting |
| The Grounds of the Château Noir | c.1900–04 | Painting |
| The Gulf of Marseille Seen from L’Estaque | c.1885 | Painting |
| The Hanged Man's House in Auvers | c.1873 | Painting |
| The House of Doctor Gachet at Auvers | 1872–73 | Painting |
| The House with the Cracked Walls | 1892–94 | Painting |
| The Kiss of the Muse | c.1860 | Painting |
| The Large Bathers, Barnes Foundation | 1895–1906 | Painting |
| The Large Bathers, National Gallery | 1895–1905 | Painting |
| The Large Bathers, Philadelphia Museum of Art | 1900–06 | Painting |
| The Mill | 1889/1892 | Drawing |
| The Painter’s Father, Louis-Auguste Cézanne | c.1865 | Painting |
| The Peasant | 1890–92 | Painting |
| The Plaster Mill (La Moulin à plâtre) | 1889/1892 | Drawing |
| The Smoker, Hermitage | c.1891 | Painting |
| The Smoker, Mannheim | c.1891 | Painting |
| The Stove in the Studio | c.1865 | Painting |
| The Vase of Tulips | c.1890 | Painting |
| Thistle | 1893/1896 | Drawing |
| Three Heads, One of Madame Cezanne | 1882/1885 | Drawing |
| Three Skulls | c.1898 | Painting |
| Three Skulls on a Patterned Carpet | 1904 | Painting |
| Trees and Shrubs | 1883/1887 | Drawing |
| Turning Road at Montgeroult | 1898 | Painting |
| Two Bathers | 1884/1887 | Drawing |
| Two Heads | 1888 | Drawing |
| Two Heads | 1890/1896 | Drawing |
| Two Heads of Women | 1890/1894 | Drawing |
| Two Studies for "The Judgement of Paris" or "The Amorous Shepherd" | 1883/1886 | Drawing |
| Uncle Dominique in a Tasseled Cap | 1866 | Painting |
| Uncle Dominique in a Turban | 1866–67 | Painting |
| Victor Chocquet and an Angel for "The Apotheosis of Delacroix" | 1878/1880 | Drawing |
| Woman in Blue | c.1904 | Painting |
| Woman Leaning Forward | 1888/1891 | Drawing |
| Woman Leaning Forward | 1890/1894 | Drawing |
| Woman Leaning Forward | 1890/1894 | Drawing |
| Woman with a Coffee Pot | c.1895 | Painting |
| Women Bathers and a Roll of Paper | 1882/1885 | Drawing |
| Young Girl with a Doll | c.1895 | Painting |
| Young Italian Woman at a Table | c.1895–1900 | Painting |
| Young Man and Skull | 1896–98 | Painting |
Frequently Asked Questions
No vase or setting is visible in the drawing. The image gives a flower head, stalk, leaves, and open paper; it does not establish whether Cézanne studied a cut plant or one outdoors.
Discussion
Look again at the images and ideas explored in Thistle by Paul Cézanne. These editorial prompts invite your observations.
Reader Insights
Follow the diagonal stem toward the flower. Where do its fairly straight lines stop being a simple route and become a tangle of leaves and curved marks?
Look at the large untouched area beside the plant. Does it make the specimen seem isolated, or does it give its projecting leaves more room to move?
Compare the tight head with the thin strokes above it. Which parts of the plant feel settled, and which still seem to be taking shape under the pencil?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about Thistle by Paul Cézanne below.
References
- Société Paul Cézanne. “Étude de chardon,” The Paintings, Watercolors and Drawings of Paul Cezanne: An Online Catalogue Raisonné , FWN 3015-31a. View source .
- National Gallery of Art. “Thistle,” object record, accession 1992.51.9.xx. View source .
- Charles S. Moffett, National Gallery of Art. “Sketchbook,” in Art for the Nation: Gifts in Honor of the 50th Anniversary of the National Gallery of Art (1991), p. 176. View source .
- Museum of Modern Art. “Cézanne Drawing,” exhibition overview (2021). View source .
- Société Paul Cézanne. “Pivoines,” The Paintings, Watercolors and Drawings of Paul Cezanne: An Online Catalogue Raisonné , FWN 3015-30a. View source .
- National Gallery of Art. “Cezanne Sketchbook,” object record, accession 1992.51.9.a–zz. View source .
- Le Baiser de la muse, d'après Frillié (FWN 572). View source.
- Louis-Auguste Cezanne, père de l'artiste, lisant L'Événement (FWN 402). View source.
- La Maison du pendu, Auvers-sur-Oise (FWN 81). View source.
- Une moderne Olympia (FWN 628). View source.
- Le Pont de Maincy (FWN 143). View source.
- La Montagne Sainte-Victoire vue de Montbriand (FWN 185). View source.
- Gardanne (vue horizontale) (FWN 224). View source.
- Le Vase bleu (FWN 823). View source.
- Les Joueurs de cartes (FWN 681). View source.
- La Montagne Sainte-Victoire (FWN 296). View source.
- La Corbeille de pommes (FWN 860). View source.
- Pommes et oranges (FWN 871). View source.
- Portrait d'Ambroise Vollard (FWN 531). View source.
- Philadelphia Museum of Art,The Large Bathers,W1937-1-1. View source.
- Château Noir (FWN 360). View source.
- Société Paul Cezanne,online catalogue structure and objectidentification. View source.
- Splash image, Thistle. National Gallery of Art, Washington.