The Cat's Paw. Minneapolis Institute of Art. Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience

Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

The Cat's Paw: Introduction

A monkey has trapped a pale cat against its body and is pushing one of the cat's forepaws towards a hot stove. The cat twists backwards, mouth open and ears pressed down. Its extended leg draws the eye towards the firebox at lower left, while the monkey's red clothing fixes the aggressor at the centre. The title, The Cat's Paw, names both that endangered limb and a familiar idea: someone made to take a risk for another person's benefit.

Edwin Landseer painted this oil on panel circa 1824. The Minneapolis Institute of Art holds it as accession 82.47; the sight measures 76.2 by 68.9 centimetres. The museum credits the gift of Dr Roger L. Anderson in memory of Agnes Lynch Anderson and designates the work and its full digital image Public Domain.[1] Those facts identify the object. They do not soften what it asks a viewer to watch.

The subject comes from Jean de La Fontaine's Le Singe et le Chat, a fable about a monkey who persuades a cat to pull roasting chestnuts from a fire and then eats the reward. Landseer compresses the tale into a physical contest that La Fontaine does not describe in this form. Persuasion has become restraint; a sequence of decisions has become a single crisis; the metaphor of exploitation has become pressure applied to an animal body.[2]

That change is the painting's central problem. Nineteenth-century writers repeatedly praised its humour, colour and expressive skill, even when they dwelt on the cat's pain. The work was reproduced in engravings, a lithograph, a photographic process and political caricature. Its long appeal did not depend on deciding whether the scene was funny or cruel. It depended on keeping comedy, virtuosity and unequal suffering uncomfortably close.

At a Glance

  • ArtistEdwin Landseer [1]
  • Datec. 1824 [1]
  • Collection or siteMinneapolis Institute of Art [1]
  • Object82.47 [1]

This work across Edwin Landseer’s career

Contents

  1. What the Minneapolis painting establishes
  2. The cat's body makes the danger visible
  3. The monkey's grip, costume and chain
  4. Stove, iron and a crowded working room
  5. Bertrand, Raton and La Fontaine's sequence
  6. From persuasion to physical force
  7. Earlier cats, monkeys and the idiom
  8. A round study of the monkey
  9. The separate 1875 idea drawing
  10. British Institution exhibition in 1824

What the Minneapolis painting establishes

The date needs its qualification. Mia catalogues the painting as circa 1824 rather than assigning it an exact day or a fully certain year of completion. A documented public appearance in 1824 makes the year secure for its early history, but the museum's approximate wording should survive whenever the object is introduced. The support is a panel, not canvas. Mia does not identify the wood in its current record, so mahogany, oak and other more specific terms would exceed the evidence.[1]

Scale also matters. At a little over three-quarters of a metre high, the painted field is large enough to accommodate several animals, furniture and a glowing stove, yet still concentrated enough to feel like an enclosed domestic episode. The outer frame is larger—96.2 by 89.22 centimetres—but that measurement belongs to the framed object, not to Landseer's painted sight. Keeping the two sets of dimensions separate prevents a frame from silently enlarging the picture.[1]

The near-square composition is slightly taller than it is wide. Darkness presses in from the room, while the cat's body and pale cloth supply a connected band of light. Warm red and orange gather around the monkey and stove. This colour organisation can be described from the museum image, but a digital file cannot identify pigments, grounds, glazes or changes beneath the visible surface. Nor does it reveal the panel's condition or restoration history.

Mia's accession number is especially useful because this subject survives in several media. The number 82.47 belongs to the finished oil. It does not belong to a small round monkey study, a pen-and-ink compositional drawing, the nineteenth-century engravings or any later adaptation. A title shared across copies is not enough to establish identity; maker, material, dimensions, holder and object number have to agree.

No human figure appears in the room. Human power is nevertheless everywhere: in the stove and flat iron, in the baskets and cloth, in the monkey's clothes and chain, and in the fable that teaches viewers to treat animal action as a model of human conduct. Landseer does not show the person who trained, dressed or confined the monkey. He shows the consequences of that absent world at the point where one captive animal turns another into an instrument.

Annotated Details from The Cat's Paw

The numbered points identify visible features discussed in this article. Return from each detail to the whole composition. The Cat's Paw. Minneapolis Institute of Art. Image source. Public domain.

Annotated details from The Cat's Paw by Edwin Landseer

Details from THE CAT'S PAW

Follow the connected limbs from the monkey to the cat, then compare the small watchers and the fire.

1

The monkey’s grip

The monkey holds the cat’s foreleg and directs its paw toward the heat. The joined limbs make coercion visible through the arrangement of bodies.

The monkey’s grip detail from The Cat's Paw by Edwin Landseer

Return to the numbered overview

2

The cat’s open mouth

The cat’s head turns upward with its mouth open. Its pale fur and teeth stand out beside the monkey’s darker face and the red cloth.

The cat’s open mouth detail from The Cat's Paw by Edwin Landseer

Return to the numbered overview

3

The watching basket

Small animal heads appear among the light fabric in the basket. They form a secondary group high at the left, separated from the central struggle.

The watching basket detail from The Cat's Paw by Edwin Landseer

Return to the numbered overview

4

The fire below

The glowing fire occupies a low opening beside the chair. Its position clarifies the danger toward which the cat’s paw is being drawn.

The fire below detail from The Cat's Paw by Edwin Landseer

Return to the numbered overview

The cat's body makes the danger visible

The cat forms the longest and brightest diagonal. Its hindquarters begin near the lower-right edge, the torso rises across the monkey, and one foreleg extends left towards the stove. This line does more than join the principal figures. It converts distance into risk: every part of the animal's body appears pulled towards the hot zone while the head recoils in the opposite direction.[1]

The contradiction runs through the pose. The cat's leg is forced outward, but its neck and face turn back. The pale belly and flank are exposed, yet the spine twists rather than yielding smoothly. Open mouth, flattened ears, tense toes or claws and the backward angle of the head support an interpretation of distress. They do not allow a still image to provide an audible cry, an exact injury or a medical diagnosis.

Landseer directs attention to the paw without isolating it. The monkey's hands, the cat's limb and the stove belong to one chain of action. The viewer can trace force from the monkey's braced body through its grip and along the cat's foreleg to the heated surface. The title therefore works literally before it works idiomatically. This is a paw placed in danger, not merely a verbal symbol attached after the event.

The cat's pale colour makes vulnerability conspicuous against the brown-black interior. Light catches the head, throat, belly and forelimb, while the monkey's darker body partly disappears into clothing and furniture. This is not a simple moral code in which light equals innocence. La Fontaine introduces both animals as troublesome household thieves. In the painted instant, however, their exposure is unequal: one body is brightly displayed under pressure and the other controls that pressure from relative shadow.[2]

The cat is neither a passive emblem nor an uncomplicated character portrait. Its resistance gives the picture much of its movement, but resistance does not restore agency. The animal cannot choose the distance between paw and stove while another body holds it. Landseer turns expressive anatomy into an account of constraint: the more vigorously the cat twists, the more clearly the grip becomes visible.

The monkey's grip, costume and chain

The monkey occupies the centre-right, seated or braced on a low bench or stool. One arm encircles the cat's upper body while the hands direct torso and foreleg. The arrangement is close enough that the animals' outlines overlap; the cat cannot withdraw without passing through the monkey's grasp. Unlike La Fontaine's verbal flatterer, this monkey performs power with its whole body.[1][2]

Its face is comparatively controlled. The profile does not mirror the cat's open mouth or recoil. That contrast divides the scene between an animal bearing risk and an animal organising it. Calmness here is not kindness. It can make the coercion feel more deliberate because the aggressor does not appear caught in the same emergency.

Red outer clothing and pale fabric give the monkey a conspicuously humanised appearance. Costume may suggest training or performance, and it encourages viewers to connect animal cunning with human calculation. Yet clothing does not disclose the monkey's owner, troupe, species, sex or individual history. The picture offers no name and no documentary portrait of a known performing animal.

A chain is visible near the lower body and seat. It supports captivity or restraint, not a complete biography. The monkey exerts control while remaining controlled by an absent person. This makes the picture's hierarchy more complex than a free predator attacking a free victim: the chained animal reproduces domination within the limited space allowed to it.

That fact does not excuse the monkey or transfer responsibility neatly to an unseen master. It changes the kind of question the scene poses. The monkey can be both agent and captive, just as La Fontaine's Raton can be both household thief and exploited tool. Landseer creates an unstable ladder of power in which an absent human environment contains the monkey, the monkey contains the cat, and the cat's paw approaches the fire.[2]

Stove, iron and a crowded working room

The stove at lower left is more substantial than the open hearth required by the fable. Its firebox glows, and a flat iron stands on the upper surface. These visible features establish heat and an ironing or laundry association. They do not establish temperature, the duration of contact or the severity of any burn. The danger is legible without turning imagined pain into a measured fact.[1]

Cloth, baskets, a bench or stool and other scattered objects make the room feel used rather than staged as an empty allegorical set. The foreground includes a large pale broken or overturned form whose exact identity is uncertain. Small dark pieces lie nearby. It is safer to read these as signs of disorder than to invent a precise accident that happened before the depicted instant.

Several other cats or cat-like animals occupy the upper and left parts of the room. A striped cat appears beside or below a basket; smaller heads and bodies emerge around the container. A dark animal is visible at upper right, but the museum image does not make its species completely secure. These surrounding creatures enlarge the audience within the picture. They do not automatically become a documented family.

Later writers called the smaller animals kittens, treated the pale cat as their mother and imagined an attempt at rescue. Such readings belong to the history of the work's reception, where they show how viewers constructed a domestic drama from compressed visual cues.[12][13][14] The image itself cannot prove parentage, age, audible screaming or a shared intention among every animal. Attribution preserves the historical story without disguising it as direct observation.

The absence of a human has invited another durable fiction: that a servant or ironing woman has just left and will soon return. La Fontaine's fable does include a servant who interrupts the chestnut scheme, but Landseer does not paint that entrance.[2] A nineteenth-century narrative can use the stove, iron and disordered room to imagine recent departure; it cannot turn the imagined worker into a visible participant.

The setting therefore does more than modernise the hearth. It puts exploitation inside a workplace furnished for human labour. The iron is made to be heated and handled safely through its grip. The cat's body is made to substitute for such a tool. An ordinary room becomes threatening because the monkey redirects a human technology through an unwilling animal.

Bertrand, Raton and La Fontaine's sequence

La Fontaine published Le Singe et le Chat as Book IX, fable XVII. The poem names the monkey Bertrand and the cat Raton. They share a household and a master, and both are introduced as troublesome thieves: one is quick to mischief, the other hunts mice and also takes cheese. The opening refuses the clean moral arrangement of an innocent pet confronted by an outside villain.[2]

The pair notice chestnuts roasting among the ashes. Bertrand sees an opportunity but does not place his own hand in danger. Instead, he praises Raton's skill and invites the cat to draw out the food. Flattery is part of the mechanism. The monkey turns a risky task into a test of the cat's supposed talent.

Raton moves the ash delicately and begins to work. The action unfolds by increments: the paw returns to the heat, and one, then two, then three chestnuts are secured. Bertrand eats while the cat performs the dangerous part. The division of labour is also a division of reward. One animal supplies exposure; the other consumes the result.[2]

A servant arrives and interrupts the operation. Raton is left dissatisfied, while Bertrand has already benefited. The ending then moves from kitchen episode to political analogy. La Fontaine compares the exploited cat with princes who expose themselves to danger or effort for a stronger ruler's advantage. The animals are not simply comic substitutes for generic people; they organise a pointed account of delegated risk.[2]

The fable depends on time. Bertrand must persuade, Raton must make repeated approaches, the monkey must eat, and interruption must arrive. That sequence allows the reader to see complicity and deception accumulate. Raton acts, even though the terms of action have been manipulated. The cat's dissatisfaction comes after the imbalance becomes clear.

Landseer keeps the names out of the title and removes the unfolding conversation. A viewer can understand danger before knowing Bertrand or Raton. Literary knowledge then changes the interpretation: the hot paw becomes an emblem of political and social use, while the visual grip reveals how radically the painter has revised the manner of exploitation.

From persuasion to physical force

Calling the picture an illustration of La Fontaine is accurate at the level of source, title and basic arrangement. It is incomplete at the level of action. The poem's monkey flatters and instructs; Landseer's monkey wraps itself around the cat and extends the foreleg by force. The difference is not a minor flourish. It shifts responsibility, agency and the viewer's relation to pain.[1][2]

In verse, readers can judge Raton's vanity or poor judgement as part of the trap. In the painting, the cat's twisting body leaves little room for voluntary cooperation at the depicted instant. The story of a dupe becomes the image of a captive under bodily compulsion. Landseer makes the metaphor more immediate by making it less dependent on dialogue.

Compression is crucial. A poem can distribute attention across several chestnuts and an eventual interruption. A painting has to select or construct one moment. Landseer chooses neither the first temptation nor the servant's arrival. He arrests the scheme at maximum asymmetry: Bertrand possesses the stronger position, Raton bears the physical hazard, and the reward remains close enough to explain the assault.

The cat's resistance also changes the spectator's role. A reader may move rapidly through the fable towards its moral. The painted body keeps the cost in view. The eye repeatedly returns to mouth, ears, claws and extended limb, then follows the line to the glowing stove. Meaning cannot be separated cleanly from the display of distress.

This is why humour and violence cannot be allocated to different halves of the picture. The human costume, crowded room and clever visual translation can support comedy, while the grip and recoil support cruelty. Both operate through the same forms. The red coat that makes the monkey theatrical also makes it conspicuous as an aggressor; the exaggerated diagonal that makes the scene lively also measures the cat's exposure.

Nor should physical compulsion be described as Landseer's unprecedented invention. Earlier European artists had already visualised the fable through animals wrestling or a monkey holding a paw near the fire. Landseer's originality lies in his own concentration of bodies, domestic detail and expression, not in being the first person ever to imagine force.

Earlier cats, monkeys and the idiom

Abraham Hondius's The Monkey and the Cat offers a securely catalogued painted comparison. The Cleveland Museum of Art dates the oil on canvas probably to the 1670s and gives unframed dimensions of 62.2 by 73.7 centimetres. Its current description presents the fable as a warning about flattery and records a dark monkey tackling a grey-striped cat beside fire and chestnuts.[15]

Hondius's picture matters because it joins persuasion in the moral account to bodily conflict in the image. It predates Landseer by roughly a century and a half. It does not prove that Landseer saw this particular canvas, owned a reproduction or borrowed its design. Similar subject and force establish a tradition, not a direct studio route.

Jacob Gole's print makes the earlier graphic formulation still more explicit. Made between 1680 and 1723, the etching and engraving measures 140 by 183 millimetres and belongs to a series of ten animal subjects. The Rijksmuseum describes the monkey holding the cat's paw beside a hearth with chestnuts in the fire. The object names Francis Barlow as a design source and records a possible Jan Griffier intermediary.[16]

The Dutch title itself describes the monkey forcing the cat to take the chestnuts from the fire. Again, exact contact between this sheet and Landseer is unknown. What the print proves is narrower and stronger: long before 1824, an artist could translate the fable's manipulation into a hand physically directing a paw. Landseer participated in an available visual vocabulary even as he intensified it in a different room and format.[16]

The title also belonged to language beyond pictures. In its relevant figurative sense, a cat's-paw is a person used by another as a tool or dupe; Merriam-Webster connects that meaning to the monkey-and-chestnuts story.[17] The body part becomes a social role. A person can be made to absorb danger, blame or effort while someone else takes the gain.

Dictionary chronology needs caution. Merriam-Webster's entry also includes a nautical or weather-related sense for a light movement of air on water and gives a circa-1769 first-use field. That date should not be transferred automatically to the tool-or-dupe meaning. The etymological relationship is secure enough to explain Landseer's title; a precise first appearance of the figurative sense is not established by that field alone.[17]

A round study of the monkey

Mia holds a second Landseer object directly connected with the painting: Study for the Monkey in The Cat's Paw, dated 1824. It is oil and graphite on an oak panel, with a round sight measuring 12.07 centimetres across. Its outer frame measures 26.67 centimetres square. The accession number is 2010.12, and the credit records the gift of Joan and David Logan of Greenwich, Connecticut.[18]

The study isolates the monkey's head and shoulder in left-facing profile. Pale-brown fur, a reddish collar and darker facial forms emerge from areas where graphite or the warm support remains conspicuous. Paint is less extensive towards the lower and right parts of the round field. These are visible relationships, not a complete reconstruction of the order in which Landseer worked.[18]

Isolation changes the animal. Without the cat, stove and clothing, the profile cannot perform coercion by itself. It becomes an exercise in turning muzzle, eye, ear and fur through a compact circular space. Comparison with the finished oil shows why the final monkey can look so controlled: the head's directional clarity survives even when the surrounding body is engaged in force.

Oil and graphite together provide evidence of study, but they do not disclose every transfer step. It is possible to compare the profile with the completed figure without claiming that Landseer copied it mechanically, squared it up, traced it or painted the oak immediately before the large panel. No such procedure is visible in the current digital records.

The reverse bears a Christopher Wood dealer label. That label belongs to the later history of the object, not to an original Landseer inscription.[18] The distinction is useful because a work's back can accumulate evidence at many dates. A modern dealer's mark may help trace circulation while saying nothing about what the artist called the study in 1824.

Mia designates this object Public Domain and supplies a full image.[18] Its rights and accession remain independent of 82.47. Sharing maker, year and subject does not make the round study a fragment of the finished panel, and its exact oak support should not be projected onto the larger painting whose wood is unspecified.

The separate 1875 idea drawing

An October 1875 Art Journal article published another preparatory object. It described a pen-and-ink drawing lent by Frederick A. Milbank, MP, as Landseer's first conception of the subject. The article said that this drawing had brought 85 guineas in the sale of works left by the artist.[13] It is not Mia's round oil-and-graphite monkey study.

The published design includes monkey and cat, a simpler heating vessel or chafing-dish and a dog's head. Much of the finished room is absent or compressed. In the oil, a substantial stove, basket, cloth and surrounding cats enlarge the incident into a crowded domestic disturbance. The comparison documents revision at the level of composition rather than merely improved finish.[13]

Landseer appears to have moved from a compact fable group towards a setting whose contents share the narrative work. The flat iron clarifies human labour. Containers and scattered forms establish disorder. Additional animals create witnesses and invite family stories. The stove gives the cat's extended limb a larger and more threatening destination than the earlier small heating device.

The dog's head in the drawing is especially revealing because it does not simply survive as the same clearly identified animal in the oil. A dark creature occupies the upper-right area of the painting, but its species is not fully secure from the museum image. The historical comparison can register change without forcing that shadowed form into a definite dog.

The drawing's sale price and 1875 owner belong to its own provenance. They do not establish the price of the finished oil or place 82.47 in Milbank's collection. Preparatory works can travel independently after leaving an artist's studio. The shared composition is evidence of relation, not a licence to merge ownership histories.

Together, the two studies preserve different kinds of preparation. Mia 2010.12 concentrates on an animal head through oil and drawing on a tiny round oak support. The Milbank sheet, as reproduced and described in 1875, concentrates on the arrangement of figures and heating object in pen and ink. One explores the monkey; the other explores the episode.

British Institution exhibition in 1824

The finished picture entered public view at the British Institution, not the Royal Academy. James Dafforne's later compilation of Landseer's exhibited works lists it as catalogue number 185 in 1824 and identifies the subject as coming from La Fontaine's fables.[19] The same list records other Landseer exhibits that year, but number 185 fixes this particular oil within the Institution display.

A contemporary response appeared in The Examiner on Sunday 29 February 1824. The date matters because later summaries have repeated 29 January, a day not supported by the checked issue. The review begins on printed page 139 and continues on page 140. It praises execution, colour and chiaroscuro before concentrating on the monkey's applied strength, the cat's suffering and the movement of the smaller animals.[12]

The critic called Landseer a “pictorial Shakespeare of animal expression”.[12] The phrase promotes his capacity to organise a drama through bodies rather than human speech. It also reveals what the reviewer valued: not zoological neutrality, but an ability to make animals carry recognisable passions and relationships.

More difficult is the review's treatment of pain as part of the viewer's pleasure. The writer admires the accuracy with which coercion and distress are rendered. Suffering is not ignored; it becomes evidence of artistic command. The response therefore gives unusually direct access to an early audience that could acknowledge cruelty and praise the entertainment produced from it in the same passage.[12]

The review does not establish universal opinion. One newspaper cannot measure the whole exhibition audience, and intense praise cannot be converted into ticket sales or popularity statistics. It can establish that this contradiction was present from the start: the painting's success, for at least one contemporary critic, lay partly in how vividly it made an animal crisis enjoyable to inspect.

The British Institution context also resists a retrospective story in which Landseer's animal dramas arrived fully packaged as timeless favourites. In 1824 this was a recently exhibited panel by an artist still early in his career. Its catalogue title connected it to a known fable; the review tested its claims to colour, execution and expression in the active culture of London exhibitions.[19][12]

Humour built from distress

The label “humorous” persisted. The Art Journal in 1875 placed The Cat's Paw among Landseer's comic subjects and treated both the drawing and painting as droll.[13] Frederic George Stephens's 1880 account expanded the image into a lively laundry-room story, while Walter Gilbey later argued that the work established Landseer's humorous reputation and supplied material for political caricature.[14][20]

Historical laughter is evidence, not an instruction. It shows how nineteenth-century viewers and writers could make animal expression, domestic mishap and human analogy cooperate as amusement. A current viewer may respond differently, especially to the cat's restraint and proximity to heat. Neither response cancels the other as part of the painting's history.

Stephens's narrative demonstrates how rapidly observation could become fiction. He imagines the ironing room, the absent worker, the behaviour of the smaller cats and even thoughts passing among the animals.[14] These details are valuable as an example of Victorian story-making. They are unsafe when detached from their author and presented as facts visible in the panel.

The scene's comic structure is nevertheless real. A dressed monkey behaves like a scheming person; a familiar room becomes the site of an elaborate chestnut theft; animals cluster as if they were a human audience to a household disaster. The fable promises a clever reversal of ordinary roles. Landseer's virtuosity makes fur, fabric, metal, fire and expression interact with theatrical economy.

Violence is equally real. The joke requires one creature to bear what another avoids. The monkey's ingenuity cannot be separated from the cat's exposed limb, and the cat's expressive body cannot be admired without looking at its loss of control. The painting makes unequal risk visually brilliant. That is precisely why admiration can feel ethically unstable.

Gilbey's comment about political caricature helps explain the durability of the arrangement.[20] A cat's-paw need not remain a literal cat. Any situation in which one actor directs another towards cost can inhabit the scheme. Monkey, grip, extended limb and desirable object provide a compact grammar of exploitation that later artists could rename for new conflicts.

The Earl of Essex and an incomplete provenance

Later nineteenth-century accounts say that Landseer sold the painting for £100 and that it passed a few days afterwards to the Earl of Essex for £120.[13][14] These figures were published more than fifty years after the event. They should be reported as historical accounts, not described as surviving invoices or contemporary sale records.

George Capell-Coningsby, 5th Earl of Essex, lived from 1757 to 1839. Christie's identifies him as an important early patron and notes that his collection included The Cat's Paw.[21] That supports the Essex association but not a commission. Buying a completed or recently exhibited painting is different from directing its creation in advance.

Stephens located the picture in the dining room at Cassiobury in his 1880 account.[14] The Art Journal had described it in 1875 as remaining in the Earl of Essex's possession.[13] Because the 5th Earl died in 1839, that later wording belongs to the continuing title, family or collection rather than to the same living owner. Provenance language has to distinguish a person from an inherited designation.

Gilbey records a sale on 22 July 1893 at 890 guineas. His table dates the picture 1824, gives dimensions of 29 by 27 inches, associates it with the 5th Earl's collection and notes the engraving by C. G. Lewis.[20] The historical measurements are close to, but not identical with, Mia's sight dimensions; each belongs to its own record and method.

The checked evidence does not identify the 1893 buyer or supply an unbroken route from that sale to Dr Anderson. No responsible account should fill the interval with a generic phrase such as “by descent” or assume how the donor acquired it. A gap is part of the provenance until documents close it.

The modern endpoint is exact. Mia credits Dr Roger L. Anderson's gift in memory of Agnes Lynch Anderson and assigns accession 82.47.[1] The painting's journey can therefore be narrated as a sequence of supported stations—1824 exhibition, reported early sale, Essex and Cassiobury association, 1893 sale, Minneapolis gift—while the missing connections remain plainly marked.

Engraving, lithograph and photographic translation

Robert Graves produced an engraving after Landseer that survives at the Smithsonian American Art Museum. The museum catalogues its impression without a date, gives a plate size of 18 by 13.8 centimetres and identifies it as object 1967.14.62. It is marked free to use.[22] The small scale indicates how substantially the composition could be reduced for circulation on paper.

The 1875 Art Journal supplies a separate historical detail: a small plate by Graves appeared in Forget-Me-Not in 1830.[13] That statement should not be used to assign 1830 automatically to the Smithsonian sheet. An undated impression and a documented publication can be related through maker and subject while remaining distinct objects or states.

Charles George Lewis translated the image on a much larger scale. The Metropolitan Museum of Art holds an 1846 proof before letters made with etching, engraving and stipple on chine collé. Its sheet measures 75.5 by 68 centimetres; Graves and Warmsley were the publishers; the object number is 49.40.166.[23] The current Met record provides no image, so specific claims about reversal, tonal handling or inscriptions would be guesswork.

The Met also catalogues Nathaniel Currier's The Cats-Paw, a hand-coloured lithograph dated 1846–56. The image measures 29.4 by 22 centimetres on a sheet 39.8 by 27.5 centimetres, and the object number is 63.550.353.[24] Made and published by Currier after Landseer, it documents an American transformation of the British painting. It does not disclose edition size, sales or the social range of its purchasers.

In 1878 the Woodbury Permanent Photographic Printing Company carried the composition through another layer of mediation. A public-domain page at the Rijksmuseum is catalogued as a Woodburytype after a print by Lewis after Landseer's painting. It measures 221 by 198 millimetres and is numbered RP-F-F25484-B.[25] Painting, engraved interpretation and photomechanical reproduction all remain legible in the catalogue chain.

These objects did not merely make smaller copies. Each medium reorganised access and material presence. An engraving could translate tone into incised marks; a hand-coloured lithograph could give the subject a different commercial and geographic setting; a Woodburytype could reproduce an existing print photographically. Without examining every state, it is still possible to see that viewers encountered The Cat's Paw through several objects between themselves and the oil.

The sequence is representative rather than exhaustive. It establishes repeated reproduction in Britain, an American lithographic version and a later photographic page. It does not establish total output, the number of impressions, worldwide sales or the proportion of viewers who knew the painting only through print. Those questions require evidence the surviving catalogue entries do not supply.

A political cat's-paw in New Zealand

An 1877 cartoon in the Alexander Turnbull Library shows how the composition could be redirected towards a specific political dispute. The National Library of New Zealand catalogues the sepia wash drawing as A-091-012 and attributes it to William Francis Robert Gordon. It turns named politicians into animals around an oven, bread roll, iron and inscribed container.[26]

The institution explicitly says that the caricature derives from Landseer's well-known painting and that the composition circulated widely in print form.[26] That record provides a documentary link rather than one inferred only from resemblance. At the same time, the adaptation changes characters, desired object and political stakes. It uses Landseer's structure to make a local argument.

This is more than a copy with altered faces. The original's hierarchy—one figure restraining or directing another towards a resource—offers a ready-made way to picture financial use and political conflict. Oven and iron preserve the domestic framework, while labels and recognised public figures replace La Fontaine's generalised princes with a current controversy.

The New Zealand object demonstrates geographic and conceptual reach, not a universal family tree. Political artists could use the phrase “cat's-paw” without copying Landseer, and one documented derivation cannot make every later monkey-and-cat image dependent on 82.47. Its value lies in precision: here, in this dated and catalogued work, the library records the compositional debt.

Placed beside Graves, Lewis, Currier and the Woodburytype, the cartoon shows two kinds of afterlife. Reproductive prints carried Landseer's arrangement across media and place; adaptation made the arrangement argue about something new. The first preserved recognisability. The second depended on recognisability in order to depart from the original.

Why the picture remains difficult

The Cat's Paw is easy to summarise and hard to settle. A monkey uses a cat to obtain chestnuts. Yet that sentence leaves out the difference between La Fontaine's persuasion and Landseer's grip, between a metaphor and a body, between a captive aggressor and the more exposed captive it controls.

Close looking keeps those differences active. The cat's pale diagonal measures forced movement. The monkey's clothing makes animal behaviour resemble human calculation, while its chain reveals another level of control. Stove, iron and cloth place the act inside a room designed for human work. Other animals watch without supplying a certain family story.

The early reception makes the ethical tension historical rather than newly imposed. An 1824 critic praised expressive mastery through the very pain that now troubles many viewers; later writers continued to call the picture humorous.[12][13][14][20] Their delight should not be erased, because it explains the work's success. It need not govern the response of the present.

The reproductive history confirms how effectively Landseer built an adaptable image. The design could shrink into a book engraving, expand into a proof before letters, cross the Atlantic as a coloured lithograph, pass through a Woodburytype and become a colonial political cartoon.[22][23][24][25][26] Across those changes, the relation of benefit to risk remained intelligible.

That relation gives the title its lasting force. The cat's paw is at once an exact painted limb and the role of anyone compelled, persuaded or manipulated to absorb another's danger. Landseer makes the idiom vivid by refusing to leave its cost abstract. The viewer has to follow the line of power all the way to the stove.

Artworks directory

This directory gathers works discussed in the articles, including drawings, original etchings and prints after Landseer. It is not a complete catalogue of every drawing, version, plate or impression. Distinct media are kept separate; uncertain dates are left blank. Linked titles open individual articles.

107 artworks

NameDateMedium
A Bellowing StagDrawing
A Deerhound1826Painting
A Distinguished Member of the Humane Society1838Painting
A Highland Breakfast1834Painting
A Highland Landscapec. 1830Painting
A Highland Shepherd's HomePainting
A Horse, Goat and Bull1811Print
A Hunting HorseDrawing
A Jack in OfficePainting
A Lion Disturbed at His RepastPainting
A Random ShotPainting
A Scene at AbbotsfordPainting
AdversityPainting
Alexander and Diogenesexhibited 1848Painting
Alpine Mastiffs Reanimating a Distressed Traveler1820Painting
Contending Group after NatureDrawing
Copy after Rubens's Wolf and Fox Huntc. 1824–26Painting
DashPainting
Deer and Deer Hounds in a Mountain Torrent ('The Hunted Stag')c. 1832 / exhibited 1833Painting
Deer FamilyPrint
Dignity and Impudence1839Painting
Dog Resting Upon a CouchDrawing
Eos1841Painting
Favourites, the Property of H.R.H. Prince George of Cambridge1834–35Painting
Her Majesty Sketching at Loch LagganPrint
High Life1829 / exhibited 1831Painting
Highland LassieDrawing
Isaac van Amburgh and his Animals1839Painting
Lady Godiva's PrayerPainting
Laying Down the Law1840Painting
Lion Defending Its Preyc. 1840Painting
LionessDrawing
Little StrollersPrint
Low Life1829 / exhibited 1831Painting
Man Proposes, God Disposes1864Painting
Nell Gwynne / Diana VernonPainting
NeptunePrint
No Hunting Till the Weather BreaksPainting
OtterhoundsDrawing
PeacePainting
PensionersPainting
Portrait of a MulePainting
Portrait of Mr Van Amburgh, as He Appeared with His Animals at the London Theatres1846–47Painting
Portraits of a Pointer Bitch and PuppyPainting
Pray Let Me OutPrint
ProsperityPainting
Ptarmigan in a Landscapeby 1833Painting
Queen Victoria and Prince Albert at the Bal Costumé of 12 May 18421842–46Painting
Queen Victoria at Loch LagganPainting
Queen Victoria at Osborne1865–67Painting
Queen Victoria landing at Loch MuickPainting
Rat-catching1823Print
Reclining LionDrawing
Reclining Lion, From BackDrawing
Rent-day in the Wilderness1855–68Painting
Return from Deer Stalking1839Print
Royal Sports on Hill and LochPainting
Sam Lovill, Porter at the Royal AcademyDrawing
Scene from A Midsummer Night's Dream1848–51Painting
Scene in the Highlands, with portraits of the Duchess of Bedford, the Duke of Gordon and Lord Alexander RussellPainting
Scottish Highlands, Lochs and FiguresDrawing
Shoeingexhibited 1844Painting
Sleeping Bloodhoundexhibited 1835Painting
Spaniel and RabbitPainting
Stag at Bay1866Sculpture
Stag at Bay1846Painting
Studies of a staghound and the head of a stag for painting ‘The Hunting of Chevy Chase’Drawing
Study for Alpine Mastiffs Reanimating a Distressed TravelerDrawing
Study for the Monkey in The Cat's PawDrawing
Study of a DogDrawing
Study of a herding dog facing rightDrawing
Study of the horse of Selene, from the East pediment of the ParthenonDrawing
SuspensePainting
Taking a BuckPrint
The Arab Tentc. 1865–66Painting
The BarnDrawing
The Best Run of the SeasonPrint
The Cat's Pawc. 1824Painting
The Cavalier’s PetsPrint
The ChallengePainting
The ChaseDrawing
The Connoisseurs: Portrait of the Artist with Two Dogs1865Painting
The Death of a Stag in Glen TiltPainting
The Drive—Shooting Deer in the PassPainting
The Drover's DeparturePainting
The Highland Shepherd’s Dog1824; portfolio issue 1848Print
The Honourable Mrs NortonPainting
The Hunting of Chevy Chase1825–26Painting
The Illicit Highland Whisky StillPainting
The Keeper John Crerar with his PonyPainting
The Larder InvadedPrint
The Lion-Dog of MaltaPrint
The Lions at the Base of Nelson's Column1867Sculpture
The Monarch of the Glenabout 1851Painting
The Mountain TorrentPrint
The Old Shepherd's Chief Mourner1837Painting
The Sanctuary1842Painting
The Stricken DeerPainting
The Twa DogsPainting
Time of PeacePrint
Two stags runningDrawing
Victoria, Princess Royal, with EosPainting
View of GlenfeshiePainting
WarPainting
White Horse in a StablePainting
Windsor Castle in Modern Times1841–43Painting
Woburn Abbey Game Card1825; portfolio issue 1848Print

Discussion

Use the article’s images and evidence to develop your own reading of The Cat's Paw.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

Which detail is most revealing when you consider “What the Minneapolis painting establishes”?

Editorial prompt · Interpretation

How does the evidence in “The cat's body makes the danger visible” affect your reading of The Cat's Paw?

Editorial prompt · Further Questions

What further question would you bring to “Why the picture remains difficult”?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about The Cat's Paw below.

References

  1. Minneapolis Institute of Art, Sir Edwin Henry Landseer, The Cat's Paw, c. 1824, oil on panel, 82.47 / object 3077, current collection record, API data and full digital image: and View source 1. View source 2.
  2. Jean de La Fontaine, Le Singe et le Chat, Book IX, fable XVII, in the fourth part of Fables choisies, 1679, pp. 70–72: View source.
  3. National Gallery of Art, Alpine Mastiffs Reanimating a Distressed Traveler. View source.
  4. Minneapolis Institute of Art, The Cat's Paw. View source.
  5. Birmingham Museums Trust, The Hunting of Chevy Chase. View source.
  6. Victoria and Albert Museum, The Old Shepherd's Chief Mourner. View source.
  7. Tate, Dignity and Impudence. View source.
  8. Royal Collection, Eos. View source.
  9. National Galleries of Scotland, The Monarch of the Glen. View source.
  10. Royal Holloway, University of London, Man Proposes, God Disposes. View source.
  11. Trafalgar Square / Greater London Authority, The Lions at the Base of Nelson's Column. View source.
  12. The Examiner, no. 839, 29 February 1824, review of the British Institution, printed pp. 139–40: View source.
  13. “Studies and Sketches by Sir Edwin Landseer, R.A.”, The Art Journal, October 1875, printed pp. 289–90: View source.
  14. Frederic George Stephens, Sir Edwin Landseer, 1880, printed pp. 52–54: View source.
  15. Cleveland Museum of Art, Abraham Hondius, The Monkey and the Cat, probably 1670s, oil on canvas, 1979.82: View source.
  16. Rijksmuseum, Jacob Gole, Aap dwingt een kat de kastanjes uit het vuur te halen, 1680–1723, etching and engraving, RP-P-1906-1876: View source.
  17. Merriam-Webster, “cat's-paw”, current definition and etymology: View source.
  18. Minneapolis Institute of Art, Sir Edwin Henry Landseer, Study for the Monkey in The Cat's Paw, 1824, oil and graphite on oak panel, 2010.12 / object 109006, current collection record and API data: and View source 1. View source 2.
  19. James Dafforne, Pictures by Sir Edwin Landseer, Royal Academician, 1873, British Institution list, printed p. 83: View source.
  20. Walter Gilbey, Animal Painters of England, vol. II, 1900, printed pp. 54 and 84: View source.
  21. Christie's, Sir Edwin Henry Landseer, The Hawk Trainer, lot 4618877, catalogue essay on George Capell-Coningsby, 5th Earl of Essex, and his collection: View source.
  22. Smithsonian American Art Museum, Robert Graves after Edwin Henry Landseer, The Cat's Paw, undated engraving on paper, 1967.14.62: View source.
  23. Metropolitan Museum of Art, Charles George Lewis after Edwin Landseer, The Cat's Paw, 1846, etching, engraving and stipple on chine collé, proof before letters, 49.40.166: View source.
  24. Metropolitan Museum of Art, Nathaniel Currier after Edwin Landseer, The Cats-Paw, 1846–56, hand-coloured lithograph, 63.550.353: View source.
  25. Rijksmuseum, Woodbury Permanent Photographic Printing Company after Charles George Lewis after Edwin Landseer, The Cat's Paw, 1878, Woodburytype, RP-F-F25484-B: View source.
  26. National Library of New Zealand, attributed to William Francis Robert Gordon, Fighting politicians, 1877, A-091-012, Alexander Turnbull Library: View source.
  27. Splash image, The Cat's Paw. Minneapolis Institute of Art. Image source. Public domain.
  28. Navigation image, One of the bronze lions at Nelson’s Column: modelled by Edwin Landseer and cast by Carlo Marochetti. Photograph by Amanda Slater. CC BY-SA 2.0. Image source. CC BY-SA 2.0. Resized.