Introduction
Three bare backs catch the light in Francisco de Goya’s A Procession of Flagellants. One man raises his arm, another inclines his head and a third bends forward. Behind them the crowd thickens into a band of faces and pointed hoods. On the left of the original panel, a figure of the Virgin rises against the dark mass of a church. Goya puts the public act of penance in the same field of view as the images that give it meaning and the people who have come to watch. [1] [2]
At a Glance
- ArtistFrancisco de Goya y Lucientes
- TitleA Procession of Flagellants (Los disciplinantes in the Academy catalogue)
- Date1808–1812 in the Academy catalogue and c. 1814–1816 in the Fundación Goya en Aragón catalogue. [1] [2]
- Medium and dimensionsOil on wood panel, 46 × 73 cm (height × width). [1]
- CollectionReal Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, Madrid, inventory 0674. [1]
Works across Goya’s career
The Parasol
1777The Nude Maja
1795–1800A Procession of Flagellants
1808–12Saturn Devouring His Son
c. 1820–23The Dog
c. 1820–23A procession seen from the roadside
The opening image is reversed, and the description follows the orientation of the Academy’s original and the annotated image. [1]
There is a small strip of open ground beneath the penitents’ feet. It lets us see where they put their weight. One turns his back squarely towards us and plants his feet apart, his elbow raised. The man next to him steps across the lit ground. Lower down, a figure bows until his shoulders are at the height of his neighbour’s waist. Light catches their skin and pale skirts in uneven patches. The marks on the backs and fabric are most legible where these patches are brightest. Goya gives the bodies enough room to move separately even as the crowd presses in behind them. [1] [2]
The rest of the procession is harder to see. The Fundación Goya en Aragón identifies the Virgin as Our Lady of Solitude and distinguishes two further images of Christ, one carrying the cross and one crucified. Several men carry the sculptures on platforms known as pasos. Two dark, veiled figures in the foreground kneel near the Virgin’s platform. Further back, the outlines of the hooded trumpeters break up the band of heads. The procession stretches towards the far right, where the lanterns and banners are high enough to remain visible even as the people beneath them merge into the distance. [1] [2]
The church wall fills much of the upper left. Its dark surface makes a background for the halo and pale dress of the Virgin, while the open sky on the other side picks up the verticals of the banners. The visual effect is easiest to see if you let your eye pass from the high, still figure of Mary down to the exposed backs below her. The panel holds both a devotional image designed to be seen above a crowd and the exertion of bodies moving on the ground. A face looking out from among the pointed hoods, singled out by the Fundación, briefly interrupts the movement into the distance. [1] [2]
The Academy also records a change Goya made while painting. He covered the pointed hoods on two figures at the centre, and traces have since become apparent beneath the surface. This is a pentimento, evidence of an earlier decision in the paint. White hoods worn by some penitents, traces of earlier hoods on others and the dark pointed headwear of the trumpeters can all be in view at once. The exposed heads and shoulders let the spectator follow the different turns of individual bodies across the foreground. [1] [2]
Annotated Details from A Procession of Flagellants
Follow the statues, penitents and banners in the orientation of the Academy painting.
What the penitents are doing
A disciplinante performed bodily penance by scourging himself. In the setting Goya depicts, that act belonged to a communal procession. The statues connect it to the Passion of Christ and to the grief of the Virgin. The kneeling women pay their respects to the passing images, the trumpeters accompany their movement and the bearers transport the platforms above the heads of the crowd. Taken together these details suggest the devotional setting of Spanish Holy Week. The contemporary sources establish the practice and its setting more securely than they establish a specific town, route or calendar day for Goya’s scene. [1] [2] [3] [4]
Charles III issued a royal decree on 20 February 1777 after a petition from the Bishop of Plasencia. The bishop complained that public penitents entertained or frightened spectators where they ought to have encouraged devotion. The decree ordered local authorities to prohibit disciplinantes, empalados and similar displays at Holy Week processions, May Cross celebrations and public prayers of supplication, among other occasions. It also directed customary processions to finish before sunset. In the decree’s own terms, penitents could seek more private forms of penance under the guidance of their confessors. Its concern was how the public exercise of devotion affected the people who gathered around it. [3]
The Academy records that public penitential practices persisted in some places. Goya’s painting shows why legislation and observation supply different kinds of evidence. An official decree tells us what the Crown instructed local authorities to prevent. The panel gives its space to people taking part in a procession in very different ways. The kneeling figures close to the Virgin are turned away from us, leaving their expressions hidden, while the bodies of the flagellants are exposed to our view. The Fundación interprets that exposure as a criticism of popular irrationality. Art historian Alfonso Rodríguez G. de Ceballos argued instead for the importance of popular piety to Goya’s representation. The attention given to both the devotions and their spectators allows either reading to begin with features we can see. [1] [2] [3] [4]
Goya on film
Five films explore Goya’s portraits, prints, Black Paintings and painting techniques.
The Duke of Wellington by Goya
The portrait, its military decorations and its later theft.
Watch on YouTubeThe other García de la Prada panels
Manuel García de la Prada left this painting to the Academy in his will of 1836. It arrived in 1839 with four other Goyas, The Madhouse, Scene of the Inquisition, The Bullfight and The Burial of the Sardine. Four are close in size and horizontal in format. The Burial of the Sardine is taller than it is wide and measures 82 × 60 cm. The shared bequest is documented. An entry for four small paintings of festivals and customs recorded in the 1828 inventory made after Goya’s death may refer to the four horizontal panels. Their association is consequently stronger than the evidence for the circumstances in which García de la Prada bought them. [1] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9]
In Scene of the Inquisition, the tall headwear marks people brought before a tribunal. Goya groups the accused inside a vaulted chamber before a seated audience. The procession takes the same conspicuous shape of pointed headwear and puts it outdoors, where some of the people wearing it practise penance in public. The distinction alters our sense of what each group is doing. In the tribunal, dress singles out people subjected to judgement. In the procession, dress makes participants visible among the bearers, musicians and spectators lining the route. [1] [2] [7]
In The Bullfight, people cluster at the edge of an improvised ring. The nearest figures help us gauge the distance to the activity inside the enclosure. In the procession, the penitents move through that near space themselves. From this position a spectator could plausibly look down at their feet and then look up at an image carried past. The Burial of the Sardine supplies another comparison. There the banner seems to gather the carnival dancers around it. In the flagellants panel the distant banners show how far the procession has already travelled away from the people nearest us. [1] [8] [9]


The subject after the panel
Goya came back to flagellation in an album drawing captioned Semana Santa en tiempo pasado en España, or Holy Week in a Time Past in Spain. Made in his Bordeaux years, the drawing brings two lit penitents forward against a row of darker figures. Its title locates the action in the Spain of memory. The drawing gives us a different scale on which to see the same play of pale, muscular bodies and dark dress. The little marks that make up the crowd in the oil panel yield to a smaller number of figures on the page. [10]
The painter José Gutiérrez Solana later borrowed several details in his own Los disciplinantes, also held by the Academy. Its catalogue points to the figure seen from behind in a white skirt and the dark hoods of the trumpeters. Solana sets his figures close to the front of the picture and gives a large crucifix flanked by candles an emphatic position. Goya lets the crowd recede around the church, with a procession whose distant end is still visible. The recurring figures make it possible to see how differently the two painters arrange the space for the same public act. [1] [11]
Artworks directory
| Name | Date | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| And There’s No Help for It, Plate 15 | Printed 1863 | |
| Asmodea | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Boys Inflating a Bladder | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Boys Picking Fruit | 1778 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Bullfight in a Divided Ring | 1825 | Lithograph |
| Card Players | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Card Players (sketch) | 1777–78 | Painted sketch |
| Dance on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Duel with Cudgels | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Heads in a Landscape | c. 1820–23 | Easel painting |
| Judith and Holofernes | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Leocadia | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Maja and Cloaked Men | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Maja and Cloaked Men (sketch) | 1777 | Painted sketch |
| Majo Clapping in Time to the Music | 1777 | Drawing |
| Men Reading | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Out Hunting for Teeth, Plate 12 | 1799 | Etching, burnished aquatint and burin |
| Picnic in the Countryside (sketch) | 1776–78 | Painted sketch |
| Picnic on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1776 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Pilgrimage to San Isidro | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Preparatory study for The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters | c. 1796–97 | Drawing |
| Procession of the Holy Office | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Quarrel at the Cockerel Inn (sketch) | 1777 | Painted sketch |
| Quarrel in the New Tavern | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| Saturn Devouring His Son | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Seated Majo Smoking | c. 1776 | Drawing |
| The Dog | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Drinker | 1777 | Tapestry cartoon |
| The Fates | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Great He-Goat | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| The Kite | 1777–78 | Tapestry cartoon |
| The Parasol | 1777 | Oil on canvas, tapestry cartoon |
| The Second of May 1808 | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| The Sleep of Reason Produces Monsters, Plate 43 | 1799 | Etching and aquatint |
| The Third of May 1808 | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| Thou Who Canst Not, Plate 42 | 1799 | Etching and burnished aquatint |
| Three Figures | 1776 | Drawing (lost) |
| Two Old Men | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Two Old Men Eating Soup | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Two Women and a Man | c. 1820–23 | Wall painting transferred to canvas |
| Universal Language: The Author Dreaming | 1797 | Drawing |
| The Family of Charles IV | 1800 | Oil on canvas |
| Witches’ Sabbath (Osuna painting) | 1797–98 | Oil on canvas |
| The Nude Maja | 1795–1800 | Oil on canvas |
| The Clothed Maja | 1800–07 | Oil on canvas |
| Self-Portrait (Drawing) | c. 1796 | Brush and carbon black ink on laid paper |
| The Swing, Madrid Album B.21 | 1795–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Majas Fighting, a Majo Observing, Madrid Album B.15 | 1796–97 | Brush, grey and black washes on laid paper |
| Majos and Majas Conversing, Madrid Album B.16 | c. 1794–97 | Ink wash on paper |
| Weeping Woman and Three Men, Madrid Album B.17 | 1795–97 | Brush, carbon black washes and black chalk |
| Maja Seated on a Chair and Two Companions Behind, Madrid Album B.18 | 1795–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Girl and Bull, Madrid Album B.23 | 1796–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Lovers Sitting on a Rock, Madrid Album B.24 | 1796–97 | Brush and carbon black washes |
| Mariano Ceballos Riding a Bull | 1825 | Crayon lithograph and scraper |
| Landscape (lifetime impression) | c. 1807–10 | Etching and aquatint |
| Self-Portrait (1815), Prado canvas | 1815 | Oil on canvas |
| Self-Portrait (1815), Academy panel | 1815 | Oil on panel |
| Self-Portrait with Dr Arrieta | 1820 | Oil on canvas |
| Christ Crucified | 1780 | Oil on canvas |
| The Last Communion of Saint Joseph of Calasanz | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| Christ on the Mount of Olives | 1819 | Oil on panel |
| The Flower Girls, or Spring | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Grape Harvest, or Autumn | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Snowstorm, or Winter | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| The Threshing Ground, or Summer | 1786–87 | Oil on canvas |
| Picnic on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1776 | Oil on canvas |
| The Kite | 1777–78 | Oil on canvas |
| Dance on the Banks of the Manzanares | 1777 | Oil on canvas |
| A Fight at the Venta Nueva | 1777 | Oil on canvas |
| Blind Man’s Bluff | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| Dogs on a Lead | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| Hunting with a Decoy | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| Hunter Loading His Rifle | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| The Angler | 1775 | Oil on canvas |
| The Hermitage of San Isidro on His Feast Day | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| The Meadow of San Isidro | 1788 | Oil on canvas |
| The Straw Manikin | 1791–92 | Oil on canvas |
| Witches’ Flight | c. 1797–98 | Oil on canvas |
| A Scene from ‘The Forcibly Bewitched’ | 1798 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duchess of Alba in Black | 1797 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duchess of Alba in White | 1795 | Oil on canvas |
| Charles III in Hunting Dress | c. 1786 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duke and Duchess of Osuna and Their Children | 1787–88 | Oil on canvas |
| Manuel Osorio Manrique de Zúñiga | 1787–88 | Oil on canvas |
| The Marquesa de Pontejos | c. 1786 | Oil on canvas |
| Equestrian Portrait of the 1st Duke of Wellington | 1812 | Oil on canvas |
| The Duke of Wellington | 1812–14 | Oil on wood |
| Portrait of Ferdinand VII of Spain | 1814 | Oil on canvas |
| Gaspar Melchor de Jovellanos | 1798 | Oil on canvas |
| María Tomasa Palafox y Portocarrero | 1804 | Oil on canvas |
| Señora Sabasa García | c. 1806–11 | Oil on canvas |
| Don Juan Bautista de Muguiro | 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Doña Isabel de Porcel | Before 1805 | Oil on canvas |
| The Colossus | After 1808 | Oil on canvas |
| The Burial of the Sardine | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| The Madhouse | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| A Procession of Flagellants | 1808–12 | Oil on panel |
| Portrait of Jacques Galos | 1826 | Oil on canvas |
| Portrait of Mariano Goya, the Artist’s Grandson | 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Milkmaid of Bordeaux | c. 1827 | Oil on canvas |
| Portrait of Don Juan Antonio Cuervo | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| María Luisa of Parma (Naples version) | c. 1800 | Oil on canvas |
| The Countess of Baena | 1819 | Oil on canvas |
| The Family of the Infante Don Luis | 1783–84 | Oil on canvas |
| The Holy Family | c. 1787 | Oil on canvas |
| Saint Barbara | c. 1773 | Oil on canvas |
| Saints Justa and Rufina | 1817 | Oil on canvas |
| El Tío Paquete | c. 1819–20 | Oil on canvas |
| The Forge | c. 1815–20 | Oil on canvas |
| Majas on a Balcony (Metropolitan Museum version) | c. 1800–10 | Oil on canvas |
| Maja and Celestina on a Balcony | c. 1808–12 | Oil on canvas |
| The Water Bearer | 1808–12 | Oil on canvas |
| Time and the Old Women | c. 1810 | Oil on canvas |
Frequently Asked Questions
The painting belongs to the Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando in Madrid. Its inventory number is 0674. [1]
Discussion
Look again at the images and ideas explored in A Procession of Flagellants. These editorial prompts invite your observations.
Look from the kneeling figures below the Virgin to the penitents in the light and then to the distant banners. At which point do you feel closest to the people in the procession? How does the face looking out from among the hoods change your position as a spectator?
Reader Insights
Follow the line of figures towards the church.
What do the costumes and gestures tell you about each participant’s role?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about A Procession of Flagellants below.
References
- Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, Los disciplinantes, collection record 0674. View source.
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, Procesión de disciplinantes, catalogue entry 465. View source.
- Charles III, royal decree of 20 February 1777, reproduced in Santos M. Coronas González, ed., El libro de las leyes del siglo XVIII, vol. IV, pp. 2048–49. View source.
- Alfonso Rodríguez G. de Ceballos, ‘La Procesión de Disciplinantes de la Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando. Goya y la religiosidad popular’, Anales de Historia del Arte, extraordinary volume (2008), pp. 389–405. View source.
- Itziar Arana Cobos, ‘Los legados de Manuel García de la Prada y Fernando Guitarte: la colección de Goya de la Real Academia de San Fernando’, in Pedro J. Martínez Plaza, ed., Las donaciones y legados de los museos españoles de titularidad pública, Museo Nacional del Prado (2023), especially pp. 64–66. View source.
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, Casa de locos, catalogue entry 463, including the history of the four cabinet panels. View source.
- Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, Escena de Inquisición, collection record 0673. View source.
- Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, La corrida de toros, collection record 0675. View source.
- Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, El entierro de la sardina, collection record 0676. View source.
- Fundación Goya en Aragón, Semana Santa en tiempo pasado en España, catalogue entry 1760, drawing G.57. View source.
- Real Academia de Bellas Artes de San Fernando, José Gutiérrez Solana, Los disciplinantes, collection record 1452. View source.
- Fondation Beyeler, Goya exhibition guide (2021), room 5, no. 14. View source.










