The Beaches Gustav Klimt Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on August 21, 2026 / Updated on October 23, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

About The Beaches by Gustav Klimt: The Correct Identity Is Friends II

The image familiar under the name The Beaches does not depict a beach and is not supported as a separate Gustav Klimt landscape. It is the lost figure painting Die Freundinnen II, usually translated as Friends II or The Women Friends II. Klimt painted the 99 × 99-centimetre oil on canvas in 1916/17. The original was destroyed at Schloss Immendorf in May 1945.[1][2]

Two standing women occupy the square. The woman at right wears a turban and a sweeping orange-red garment; the woman pressed close to her at left is nude apart from a patterned shawl. Birds and floral forms cross a bright pink field behind them. Their identities are unknown. The picture represents a physically intimate, homoerotically charged relation between women, but it does not document named partners or disclose Klimt's private life.[1]

The composition survives through photographs and printed reproductions, including plate 1 of Max Eisler's 1931 Gustav Klimt. Eine Nachlese. Numerous drawings preserve stages in the figures' development. Those records allow the painting to be identified and studied, but none is the destroyed oil or evidence of its present surface.[1][3]

At a Glance

  • ArtistGustav Klimt
  • Governing titleDie Freundinnen II
  • English titlesFriends II, The Women Friends II and The Girlfriends II
  • Incorrect familiar labelThe Beaches
  • Date1916/17
  • MediumOil on canvas
  • Dimensions99 × 99 centimetres
  • SignatureNo signature transcription is secured in the governing records
  • SubjectTwo anonymous standing women, one clothed and one largely nude, in an intimate patterned setting
  • Commission contextProbably prompted by Othmar Fritsch's request for a painting resembling Portrait of Wally
  • Recorded ownershipAugust and Serena Lederer collection
  • Wartime historyShown under anonymised “private property” ownership in the 1943 Klimt retrospective after Nazi expropriation of the collection
  • Current statusDestroyed at Schloss Immendorf in May 1945; no original access[1][3][4]

Why The Beaches Is Not the Artwork's Title

Nothing in the pictured scene establishes a shore, sea or beach. There is no horizon, sand, waterline or landscape opening. Instead, the square is filled by two upright bodies, garments and a decorative field. Current specialist sources consistently identify this composition as Friends II.[1][2]

The correction does not create a newly discovered work. It returns a mislabelled image to an established lost canvas. German Die Freundinnen II and the English forms Friends II, The Women Friends II and The Girlfriends II are translation layers around that object. “The Beaches” has no comparable support in the authoritative specialist record.

The Roman numeral matters because Klimt made another composition catalogued as Friends I or The Sisters. The numeral distinguishes separate paintings; it does not describe an overpainted first state followed by a second state on the same support. This page concerns only the 1916/17 square destroyed at Immendorf.

The image itself makes the correction visually testable. The clothed woman at right, the nude at left, their close contact and the bright patterned background correspond to descriptions and studies explicitly attached to Friends II. No landscape identification can account for that evidence.

A Destroyed Oil Known through Reproduction

The governing physical record is concise: oil on canvas, 99 × 99 centimetres, dated 1916/17.[1][2] No available institutional entry supplies a dependable signature transcription or original-frame measurement. Gold, metal, textile and applied ornament are not part of the documented medium merely because the reproduced colours look rich.

The oil no longer survives. Max Eisler's 1931 portfolio reproduced it before the war, and later books and digital archives repeated the image. The MAK-associated Klimt Lost presentation identifies the portfolio sheet as plate 1 and places it beside the history of the persecuted Lederer collection.[3]

A reproduction can transmit pose, crop, relative colour and the broad organisation of the field. It cannot reveal the canvas's current condition, because there is no current canvas. Nor can it securely establish the height of paint, exact pigments, varnish, revisions or every tonal relationship. Different scans may make the pink, orange and patterned passages appear more or less intense.

The 1931 sheet is therefore evidence and substitute access at once. It keeps the lost composition visible while demonstrating the distance between a photographed or printed record and an original oil. The distinction is especially important here, because the painting's destruction invites reproductions to be treated too casually as if they were the work itself.

Two Figures Filling a Square

The two women stand so close that their forms read first as a paired vertical structure. Their bodies are cut off below the hips by the lower edge. Rather than showing a room around them, Klimt brings the figures forward until clothing, exposed skin and pattern occupy nearly the entire square.[1]

The left figure is nude except for a bright shawl crossing one shoulder. Her torso faces outward, and her head turns towards the viewer. The figure at right is more extensively covered. A turban encloses her hair; the orange-red garment expands across her body; her long neck curves above its broad patterned mass.[1]

Clothing and nudity do not divide the pair into isolated halves. The nude leans into or presses against her companion, and their outlines meet. The clothed figure's arm and garment help contain the other body, while the shawl links bare skin to the surrounding ornament. Proximity is structural, not an incidental gesture added to two separate portraits.

The square format reinforces that fusion. A wider support could have placed space between the women or supplied a setting. Here the figures occupy the available width, and the background closes around them. Their relation becomes the painting's main spatial fact.

No evidence identifies either woman. Visual differences may suggest contrasting ages, social types or degrees of worldly presentation, but they do not warrant names. A model represented in a drawing is not automatically the identity of a figure in the oil. “Friend” remains the painting's relational title, not a biographical label recovered from the sitters.

The women's presentation also works against a private, unobserved moment. Their faces remain available to the viewer even as their bodies touch. The composition therefore combines closeness with display: the pair is intimate, yet neither is hidden deep inside a room or absorbed entirely in the other. That tension helps explain why the painting cannot be reduced either to a conventional double portrait or to an abstract arrangement of patterned shapes.

The lower crop contributes to the effect. By cutting through both figures below the body's midpoint, the canvas removes feet, floor and much of the setting that would stabilise a full-length portrait. The women appear to rise within the square, held by each other and by the surrounding motifs. This upward, elongated quality also appears in associated drawings, where Klimt tested narrower waists, extended torsos and the paired vertical movement before clothing and colour fixed the final contrast.[5][6]

Covered and Exposed

The contrast between the women begins with dress, but it does not end there. One body is largely visible; the other is translated into a broad, colour-filled garment. One neck is relatively short and enclosed by the shawl; the other is elongated into a curving line above the orange-red field. Klimt's late style makes exposure and concealment operate as different ways of constructing a figure.[1]

The clothed woman does not become less bodily simply because ornament dominates her dress. Her head and neck establish direction, while the garment supplies volume and colour without describing anatomy in detail. The nude figure, conversely, is not detached from pattern. The shawl, background and neighbouring robe repeatedly interrupt the isolation of bare skin.

This interaction prevents a simple opposition such as innocence against corruption or nature against fashion. Those symbolic equations require evidence the picture does not supply. The represented contrast is secure; its conversion into a moral drama is not.

The word “kimono” also needs restraint. The Klimt Database describes a sweeping orange-red reform dress or kimono and connects the late picture with Klimt's interest in East Asian garments.[1] That permits careful discussion of an East Asianising visual language. It does not identify a surviving garment, a designer, an exact country of manufacture or a single source print.

Pink, Birds and Flowers

The background is not a neutral wall. East Asian bird and floral motifs are distributed across a vivid pink field. They do not establish deep recession; instead, they occupy intervals around the heads and upper bodies, making negative space active.[1]

The motifs behave differently from a crowded narrative scene. A bird or flower can be recognised, yet it also functions as a coloured unit balancing the women's outlines. The right figure's long neck is answered by elongated natural forms, while the scattered arrangement prevents the background from settling into plain monochrome.

The relation to Lady with a Fan is stronger than the relation to Portrait of Wally at this formal level. Current specialist analysis points to shared birds, floral motifs and bright patterned space, even though the buyer request began with Wally.[1] The comparison explains late design choices; it does not make the paintings versions of one object or give Friends II the fan portrait's sitter, provenance or market history.

Nor should the patterned field be described as physical wallpaper, collage or textile attached to the canvas. It is painted imagery within an oil painting. Without technical examination of the destroyed original, no pigment sequence or exact material construction can be recovered.

Intimacy without Invented Biography

Current Klimt Database scholarship calls the atmosphere between the women intimate and homoerotically charged.[1] That interpretation begins with visible evidence: close bodily contact, the pairing of naked and clothed forms, and a setting that offers no competing narrative event.

The description is more precise than treating the figures as merely decorative companions. It recognises that the painting makes female proximity and sensual contrast its subject. At the same time, “homoerotic” is an interpretation of representation, not a certificate of the models' identities, sexuality or off-canvas relationship.

Nothing secures the scene as a portrait of two named lovers. No surviving letter identifies the women, and the title supplies a relation rather than individual names. It would be equally reductive to insist that the picture is only allegory and contains no erotic charge. The responsible account holds both limits: intimacy is represented; biography remains unknown.

This is also where comparison with Water Serpents I must remain bounded. The earlier work places entwined female bodies in an aquatic parchment composition with its own mixed medium, revisions, studies and Belvedere history. Friends II presents an upright late pair in oil, against birds and flowers, and belongs to the destroyed Lederer collection. A recurring interest does not merge the objects.

Othmar Fritsch and the Request for Another Wally

The work's origin is unusual. According to the Klimt Database, art historian Othmar Fritsch saw Portrait of Wally in Klimt's studio and wanted to acquire it. Serena Lederer had already shown strong interest in that painting. When Klimt could not sell Wally to Fritsch, Fritsch is said to have requested something similar; Friends II was probably the result.[1]

The chain must retain its qualifications. Fritsch's request provides a plausible impetus, not proof that Friends II reproduces Wally's sitter or composition. The finished square differs decisively from the single portrait: it contains two anonymous women, sharper contrast between covering and nudity, and a patterned field whose nearest comparison lies elsewhere in Klimt's late work.[1]

Nor was Friends II a conventional commissioned portrait. The evidence points to a picture made at a buyer's explicit request without a named sitter whose likeness defined the contract. That distinction explains why a request could shape the project while the resulting subject remained anonymous.

The painting did not finally remain with Fritsch. It entered the collection of August and Serena Lederer. Current records do not justify a purchase price or a fully reconstructed transaction, so the page should not invent one. The important outcome is that a buyer request and final ownership belong to different people.[1][4]

Drawings: Exploration rather than Cartoons

Friends II generated a large and evolving body of drawings. Dorotheum's specialist account places relevant sheets within Alice Strobl's catalogue groups 2755–2843 and 3712–3721. Most explore the nude figure, and some predate the finished painting by reaching back towards 1915.[5]

Those catalogue spans are not a total of direct cartoons. They include studies associated at different strengths and stages. Klimt tested isolated standing nudes, turns of the head, arm positions and pairings. The group shows sustained development without proving that each sheet was transferred to the canvas.

One particularly informative drawing is Leopold Museum inventory 1301, Two Standing Female Nudes, the Left One with Raised Arms, dated 1916/17. Executed in pencil on Japanese paper and measuring 56.7 × 37.1 centimetres, it belongs to an advanced design phase. The left nude's frontal position, elongated proportions and narrow waist and hips relate closely to the painted companion.[6]

The sheet still differs from the oil. Both figures are nude, and the arrangement remains a study rather than a coloured plan for every garment and motif. Its value lies in showing how the paired vertical structure emerged before the final contrast of orange-red robe and exposed body.

Albertina inventory DL566, a 1916–17 Portrait of a Lady with Fur Collar associated with Friends II, uses pencil with blue and red coloured pencil on paper. It is signed at lower left and belongs to the study portfolio.[7] That signature applies to the sheet, not automatically to the lost canvas.

Another standing-nude sheet sold by Dorotheum in 2021 extends the documented group. The auction result is less important here than its scholarly classification and exact relation to the nude protagonist.[5] Together, the drawings preserve variation. They should not be arranged into a falsely exact day-by-day sequence.

The Lederer Collection and Nazi Expropriation

August and Serena Lederer built the largest private collection of Klimt's work. Friends II appeared there alongside family portraits, the Faculty Paintings, the Beethoven Frieze, landscapes and numerous drawings. A 1931 reproduction preserved the painting while it was still privately owned.[3][4]

After Austria's Anschluss in 1938, the Jewish Lederer family lost control of its property. The Gestapo looted the Vienna apartment, confiscated drawings and removed the collection. Serena fled to Hungary in 1939 and attempted to protect the works from exile, but she could no longer determine their display or storage.[3][4]

This context changes the language of later exhibition records. The 1943 Klimt retrospective at the former Secession presented works taken from persecuted owners. Its catalogue no longer named those owners. Friends II was listed merely as “private property,” erasing Serena Lederer's identity even though she was an involuntary lender.[3]

The display was therefore not an ordinary consensual loan. It offered public access while concealing the coercion that made the works available. Keeping that contradiction visible is part of the painting's object history, not an optional political aside.

Verified Loss at Schloss Immendorf

After the 1943 exhibition, many Lederer works were moved for storage to Schloss Immendorf in Lower Austria. The castle burned in May 1945. Friends II belongs to the group documented as destroyed there, unlike works whose arrival at the depot remains unverified.[3][4]

The painting's loss is secure even though the fire's exact cause is less so. Contemporary reports attributed the blaze to a withdrawing SS demolition unit, but later institutional accounts note that the perpetrators were never investigated and the motive remains unresolved.[3] It is safer to state that the canvas burned at Immendorf than to reconstruct an unwitnessed sequence of explosives, plunder and ignition.

No surviving fragment, restored canvas or postwar owner is documented. The 1931 plate and drawings do not make the original extant. They preserve evidence around an irreversible absence.

That loss also explains why title accuracy matters. Calling the image The Beaches detaches it from the commission evidence, the study group and the history of the Lederer collection. Restoring the name Friends II reconnects the figures to the records that explain how the painting was conceived, collected, persecuted and destroyed.

Frequently Asked Questions

References

  1. Gustav Klimt Database, “The Final Years,” especially “Swan's Necks and Kimonos”; exact Friends II identity/date/loss, Fritsch and Wally request, non-standard commission, paired figures, dress, intimacy, East Asian motifs and late-work comparisons. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  2. Galerie bei der Albertina, Klimt, Schiele, Moser specialist catalogue; oil-on-canvas medium, 99 × 99-centimetre dimensions, 1916/17 date, destroyed status and an exact related standing-nude study. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  3. Klimt Villa with MAK and Austrian National Library materials, “Klimt Lost”; 1931 plate 1, Nazi expropriation, Serena Lederer's exile and involuntary-lender status, anonymised 1943 catalogue entry, Immendorf storage and qualified fire evidence. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  4. Gustav Klimt Database, “The Lederer Family”; Friends II in the collection, 1931 reproduction, family patronage, Nazi-era fate and Immendorf destruction. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  5. Dorotheum, “Standing Female Nude to the Left,” 1 June 2021; exact 1916/17 study, broad Strobl catalogue groups, nude-figure emphasis and dynamic preparatory status. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  6. Leopold Museum, “Two Standing Female Nudes, the Left One with Raised Arms: Study for Friends II,” inventory 1301; date, pencil/Japanese-paper medium, dimensions, advanced design stage and relationship to the painted nude. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.
  7. Albertina, “Portrait of a Lady with Fur Collar (Study for Friends II),” inventory DL566; 1916–17 date, pencil and blue/red coloured-pencil medium, dimensions, signature and study portfolio. View source. Accessed 10 August 2026.

Discussion

The Beaches by Gustav Klimt: The Correct Identity Is Friends II rewards close attention to source context, object identity and careful reproduction boundaries.