Ten figures press together on a small, almost square sheet. One points towards the right, another raises his face, and others turn in different directions beneath elaborate headgear. Staffs and a banner rise above the gathering, but the event attracting their attention remains outside the surviving image. Group of Ten Spectators makes a crowd’s arrangement the subject of sustained looking.
The drawing belongs to the Morgan Library & Museum in New York, inventory I, 112. The museum currently assigns it to a follower of Hieronymus Bosch, around 1510–1540.[1] The Bosch Research and Conservation Project, or BRCP, instead argues that Bosch drew it himself.[3] Both the attribution and its connection with a later print remain disputed.
At a Glance
- TitleGroup of Ten Spectators
- AttributionFollower of Hieronymus Bosch in the Morgan record; Bosch in the BRCP catalogue
- DateAround 1510–1540 in the current museum record
- MediumPen and two brown inks on paper, with a brown framing line
- Dimensions12.4 × 12.6 cm
- CollectionMorgan Library & Museum, New York
- InventoryI, 112
- AcquisitionPurchased by Pierpont Morgan in 1909, according to the museum
- SubjectA group probably witnessing an episode from Christ’s Passion
Compare these works across Bosch’s career
These date ranges are estimates, not a documented year-by-year sequence. These works provide context for the article; none is highlighted as the object discussed here.
Saint Jerome at Prayer
Circa 1485–1495 [2]Crucifixion with a Donor
Circa 1490–1500 (BRCP) [2]Hermit Saints Triptych
Circa 1495–1505 [2]Saint Liberata Triptych
Circa 1495–1505 [2]The Hearing Forest and the Seeing Field
Circa 1500–1505 (Berlin exhibition) [4]The Haywain Triptych
1510–1516 (BRCP) [2]Contents
- Introduction
- Annotated Details
- A Crowd Built from Overlapping Bodies
- The Pointing Hand and the Empty Space
- Clothes, Hats and Vertical Accents
- Two Brown Inks and Different Degrees of Finish
- A Head Revised During Drawing
- Why Scholars Disagree About the Artist
- The Connection with a Later Engraving
- What the Printed Credits Establish
- Cropping, Mounting and Collectors’ Names
Annotated Details from Group of Ten Spectators
The Morgan sheet gathers ten spectators into one compact group. Its current follower attribution and the BRCP’s different view are explained in the article.
Details from GROUP OF TEN SPECTATORS
The photographs and focused details retain the available native resolution.
The figures at the left
A standing man holds a long staff at the left edge. The figure in front of him turns sideways, with a short cape falling over his shoulders.
Image and detail crops: Wikimedia Commons source 1 (public domain reproductions).
A Crowd Built from Overlapping Bodies
The figures occupy different levels, although they are packed into a shallow space. Large bodies establish the foreground; smaller portions of faces and headgear appear between and above them. A head can be clearly visible even when the body beneath it is almost entirely concealed. The viewer reconstructs the gathering through these partial appearances.
At the left, a standing figure grips a tall shaft with both hands. His profile faces towards the edge, while the foreground figure beside him turns back towards the middle of the sheet. The contrast makes the crowd less orderly than a procession in which everyone moves and looks the same way. Its members have been brought together without becoming identical parts of one action.
Near the centre, a broad face looks downward, while another head behind it tilts upward. Their opposing angles give a small cluster its own rhythm. Repeated curves describe hair, and short diagonal lines deepen the shadows between heads and shoulders. The changes in direction keep the upper half active even where little of each person’s body is shown.
The front figures provide larger areas of cloth. Their robes fall towards the lower boundary, interrupting the more concentrated pattern of faces above. Long folds can be followed almost from shoulder to hem, giving the eye a slower route through the drawing. The crowd’s density depends on this alternation between closely worked heads and broader, more open garments.
The Pointing Hand and the Empty Space
The right-hand figure offers the clearest directional signal. His arm extends beyond the bodies beside him and ends in a pointing hand. A high, curved projection from his hat leads towards the same side. Together, headgear, profile and gesture carry attention into the relatively empty strip of paper at the right edge.
The gesture has no visible destination. It could direct us towards an event in a larger composition, but the surviving sheet does not show what that event was. The BRCP regards an episode from the Passion as likely, while allowing an Ecce Homo, Carrying of the Cross or Crucifixion.[3] Choosing one of these as certain would supply information that the fragment withholds.
This uncertainty affects the figures’ expressions. A raised face might seem attentive, surprised or distressed, depending on the scene imagined beside it. The pointing figure might be directing someone else or commenting on what he sees. Their poses can be described closely without turning those possibilities into a named conversation or assigning every spectator a fixed moral role.
Clothes, Hats and Vertical Accents
The costumes distinguish people who would otherwise merge into the crowd. A short cape spreads over the shoulders of one foreground figure. Another garment carries a row of small circular ornaments along the sleeve. Wrapped cloth, pointed caps and exaggerated hat shapes create a varied upper outline against the unused paper.
These details need not identify particular ethnic or religious groups. They are part of how the drawing differentiates its participants and sets the scene apart from everyday portraiture. Some faces are strongly characterised, but characterisation is not an inscription naming the sitter. A pronounced nose, an unusual hat or an emphatic expression cannot establish a person’s identity by itself.
The shafts and banner supply another kind of order. Their long uprights cut through the shifting curves of heads and clothing. The cloth hanging near the centre provides a dark, narrow accent above the group, while another staff reaches towards the upper left. These forms connect the lower bodies with the space overhead without requiring an architectural setting.
Two Brown Inks and Different Degrees of Finish
Some passages remain pale and lightly described; others are darker, especially around the heads. The difference makes it possible to follow selected features more readily than the surrounding garments. A face can emerge through a few reinforced lines while the larger body is left relatively open. Variation in ink and attention becomes part of the drawing’s effect.
The BRCP describes two drawing phases, distinguishing an ink that becomes transparent in infrared from a carbon-containing one that remains visible.[3] The Morgan reports a more recent examination finding iron in both inks and no reason to suppose that a later hand added the darker one.[1] These accounts should not be turned into a simple rule that dark marks must belong to another artist.
The material evidence and the attribution question operate at different levels. Differences between inks can help distinguish passages, but they do not name the person who made them. Nor do two working phases provide an exact interval between sessions. The visible changes deserve attention without becoming an undocumented story of one draughtsman correcting another decades later.
A Head Revised During Drawing
One alteration matters particularly to the attribution debate. The BRCP points to the second figure from the left, whose head was initially outlined differently before the present cap was developed.[3] In the finished group the hat helps separate that head from its neighbours. The earlier contour preserves a moment when the figure’s appearance had not yet been fixed.
The catalogue uses this revision to question whether the sheet merely copies an existing painting. A draughtsman inventing a group would have reason to change the headgear while working. Yet revision alone cannot establish Bosch’s authorship: a follower could also adapt, rearrange or reconsider a figure. The change is evidence of a decision, not a signature.
It is also distinct from damage. An abandoned contour records something made and then altered within the drawing’s development. Cropping or abrasion belongs to a different stage of the object’s history. Looking for both prevents every pale or interrupted line from being explained in the same way.
Why Scholars Disagree About the Artist
The BRCP’s account traces a change from broad acceptance as Bosch to follower attributions after the late 1960s. Fritz Koreny dated the drawing around 1530–1540 and criticised aspects of its execution; Erwin Pokorny proposed an earlier period, around 1510–1520, closer to Bosch’s workshop.[3] These estimates explain why the Morgan’s present range spans both Bosch’s final years and the years following his death.
The arguments concern particular qualities of the drawing. Koreny’s follower reading questions the hatching, modelling and attention to costume. The BRCP sees stronger affinities with Bosch’s accepted work, especially in the handling of individual figures, and gives more weight to the altered head.[3] The same sheet can therefore become evidence for different accounts of how confidently and inventively it was drawn.
The catalogue compares a figure here with Saint John in the El Escorial Christ Carrying the Cross and with figures in the Albertina Tree-Man drawing. It also relates some headgear and types to the Frankfurt Ecce Homo.[3] These are stylistic comparisons, rather than documents showing the artist preparing this particular paper for a known commission.
The public title Group of Ten Spectators describes what is visible without resolving that dispute. Calling it a follower’s work follows the owning museum; acknowledging the BRCP’s contrary assessment records a substantial alternative. The Morgan also notes similarities with drawings assigned to the proposed Master of the Prado Haywain.[1] That comparison does not securely identify this sheet’s maker.
The Connection with a Later Engraving
A second question concerns a print of Christ Carrying the Cross published by Hieronymus Cock. The composition is associated with Cornelis Cort and Lambert Lombard. An impression in the Saint Louis Art Museum is catalogued as attributed to Cort, after Lombard, and dated to the 1560s.[5] The Morgan and BRCP discuss the related print around 1560.[1][3]
The BRCP identifies eight heads in the Morgan drawing that recur in the engraving, expanding Koreny’s earlier comparison of four. They appear in a different configuration, within a much larger procession and setting.[3] The connection is therefore more specific than a general similarity between crowded Passion scenes, while still involving changes to the figures’ arrangement.
The difficulty is the intermediary drawing. Lombard’s composition study, dated 1556 and now in the Fondation Custodia, Paris, does not contain those particular heads, as both the Morgan and BRCP explain.[1][3] Its relationship to the finished print cannot account for every element simply by assuming that the engraver copied it without modification.
Several possibilities remain. The Morgan sheet may have been consulted during production of the engraving, or both works may draw on another source. The catalogue also considers a lost Bosch painting behind the wider composition.[3] None of these possibilities establishes a complete chain of possession or proves that Lombard owned the small drawing in 1556.
What the Printed Credits Establish
The engraving’s credits name Bosch as inventor and Lombard with the term restituit, which the BRCP discusses as bringing the composition back or restoring it.[3] Those words record a claim made by the print’s producers about its sources. They do not turn the Morgan drawing’s lower-right name into Bosch’s own signature or settle its disputed date.
The print is also an interpretation in another medium. Engraving reorganises lines into a reproducible image, and the larger composition places individual heads among buildings, weapons, animals and a moving crowd. A relationship to Bosch’s inventions need not mean a literal reproduction of one intact painting in every detail.
The small drawing remains valuable independently of this later use. Its compressed group asks us to examine where each head sits and how each body overlaps another. The print changes that scale of attention, giving similar forms positions within a more expansive narrative. Their connection makes the act of adaptation visible without recovering every lost stage between them.
Cropping, Mounting and Collectors’ Names
The sheet’s present outline has clipped corners and a framing line. The BRCP records cropping at the top and a vertical fold through the middle.[3] Its compact boundary may therefore enclose only part of a larger drawing. The empty space around the crowd cannot automatically be treated as the complete original setting.
The Morgan records that the sheet is fully laid down on a secondary support. It also notes a faint, currently illegible inscription on the original reverse, detected with transmitted light.[1] That observation gives no licence to invent its wording. The visible old annotations associated with the back belong to the drawing’s collecting history rather than another surviving figure composition.
At the lower right of the front, the name bosch appears beneath Rymsdyk’s Museum. The museum identifies the latter with the collector Jan van Rymsdyk and records Tighe and Charles Fairfax Murray among previous owners.[1] The names are evidence of how the object was collected and classified. They do not supply a dated declaration by the artist himself.
The Morgan gives its purchase by Pierpont Morgan as 1909.[1] Today the drawing preserves a group whose attraction to an unseen event is still compelling: interlocked bodies, divergent glances, an altered cap and a hand pointing beyond the surviving scene. The pointing hand continues to direct attention beyond the edge, while the cap’s earlier contour brings it back to decisions preserved on the paper.
Artworks and related attributions
Browse paintings, drawings and related attributions. Records group triptychs, fragments and two-sided sheets where appropriate. Dates follow the cited museum records or catalogue headings and are generally estimates. Rows marked “2016 catalogue” report that publication’s attribution and collection information; these are dated opinions, rather than a claim that every work is an accepted autograph Bosch.
| Name | Date | Medium, attribution and collection |
|---|---|---|
| A Crossbowman | Second half of the sixteenth century | Oil on oak panel · Copy after Hieronymus Bosch · Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid · P002695 Source 1. Source 2. |
| A Woman Spinning and an Old Woman | Museum estimates: about 1480–1490 for the women and 1500–1505 for the reverse; the precise chronology is disputed | Pen and brown and grey ink on the front; pen and brown ink on the reverse · Hieronymus Bosch · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · N 190 recto and verso (PK) Source 1. Source 2. |
| Adoration of the Child in Cologne | Second half of the sixteenth century | Oil on oak panel · Imitator of Hieronymus Bosch, in the city collection record · Wallraf-Richartz-Museum & Fondation Corboud, Cologne · WRM 0474 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Adoration of the Magi in Philadelphia | Early sixteenth century in the museum record; around 1495–1520 in the BRCP catalogue | Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch in the museum record; workshop of Bosch in the 2016 BRCP catalogue · Philadelphia Museum of Art, John G. Johnson Collection, 1917 · 1321; museum object 103592 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Adoration of the Magi — New York | c.1470–1480 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Metropolitan Museum 13.26 2016 catalogue. |
| Adoration of the Magi — Prado triptych | c.1494 | Oil on oak; grisaille exterior · Bosch · Prado P002048 Object source. |
| Adoration of the Magi — three associated fragments | c.1515–1535 | 2016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch · Two Shepherds / Retinue in Philadelphia; associated Adoration in private collection in 2016 2016 catalogue. |
| Ascent of the Blessed — Venice | c.1505–1515 | Oil on panel · Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia; Visions of the Hereafter Object source. |
| Battle of the Birds and Mammals | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 14715 2016 catalogue. |
| Beggars and Musicians | Around 1530–1540 | Ink and wash on paper · Unknown follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Albertina, Vienna · 7798 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Christ Carrying the Cross Drawing | Around 1470 in the museum catalogue | Black chalk or charcoal, pen and brush in brown ink, white corrections · Anonymous, workshop of Rogier van der Weyden · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · N 81 recto and verso (PK) Source 1. Source 2. |
| Christ Carrying the Cross in Vienna | Around 1490–1510 in the current KHM record and BRCP catalogue | Oil on oak, painted on both sides · Hieronymus Bosch; possible workshop involvement in the Passion side discussed by the BRCP · Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna · Gemäldegalerie, GG 6429 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Christ Carrying the Cross — El Escorial | c.1495–1505 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Patrimonio Nacional 10014739 2016 catalogue. |
| Christ Carrying the Cross — Ghent | c.1510–1516 (museum) | Oil on panel · Bosch in museum listing; authorship disputed · MSK Ghent 1902-H Object source. |
| Christ Mocked — London | c.1510 | Oil on wood · Bosch · National Gallery NG4744 Object source. |
| Concert in the Egg, After Hieronymus Bosch | Around 1561; third quarter of the sixteenth century | Oil on canvas · Anonymous, after Hieronymus Bosch · Palais des Beaux-Arts, Lille · P 816 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Conjurer / Comical Concert — Louvre drawing | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch (recto), follower (concert verso) · Pen and brown ink · Louvre INV 19197 2016 catalogue. |
| Conjurer / Cross-bearing and beggars — Liège sheet | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch (verso), follower (recto) · Pen and brown ink · Album d’Arenberg 534 2016 catalogue. |
| Crowning with Thorns — El Escorial | c.1530–1540 | 2016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch; oil on oak · Patrimonio Nacional 10014743 2016 catalogue. |
| Crucifixion with a Donor | Circa 1495–1505; Circa 1490–1500 | Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, Brussels · 6639 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Death and the Miser Drawing | Not securely established; probably made after the painting | Pen and brush, dark ink and white highlights on prepared paper · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch in the BRCP catalogue; alternatives recorded by the Louvre · Musée du Louvre, Department of Prints and Drawings, Paris · RF 6947, Recto Source 1. Source 2. |
| Death and the Miser — Washington | c.1485/1490 (NGA) | Oil on panel · Bosch · National Gallery of Art 1952.5.33 Object source. |
| Ecce Homo Triptych — Boston | c.1495–1500; wings c.1500/1503 | 2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; oil on oak · Museum of Fine Arts Boston; several production phases 2016 catalogue. |
| Ecce Homo — Frankfurt | c.1490 | Mixed technique on oak · Bosch · Städel 1577 Object source. |
| Fall of the Damned — Venice | c.1505–1515 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on panel · Visions of the Hereafter · Venice 2016 catalogue. |
| Garden of Earthly Delights | 1490–1500 (Prado) | Oil on oak; grisaille exterior · Bosch · Prado; triptych Object source. |
| Gluttony and Lust / Allegory of Intemperance — Yale fragment | c.1500–1510 (group dating) | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Yale 1959.15.22; fragment associated with Ship of Fools 2016 catalogue. |
| Group of Ten Spectators, a Follower of Bosch | Around 1510–1540 in the current museum record | Pen and two brown inks on paper, with a brown framing line · Follower of Hieronymus Bosch in the Morgan record; Bosch in the BRCP catalogue · Morgan Library & Museum, New York · I, 112 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Head of an Old Woman | About 1500 | Oil on panel · Attributed to Jacob Cornelisz. van Oostsanen · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · 2439 (OK) Source 1. Source 2. |
| Hell and the Flood — Rotterdam panels | Around 1515 in the museum records; around 1510–1520 in the BRCP catalogue | Oil on oak panels · Jheronimus Bosch in the museum records; workshop of Bosch in the BRCP catalogue · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam Source 1. Source 2. |
| Hermit Saints Triptych | Circa 1495–1505 | Oil on oak panels · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia, Venice · 2044 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Infernal Landscape | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink, red accent · Private collection in 2016 2016 catalogue. |
| Infernal Scene with Anvil / Monster Studies | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; attribution debated in entry · Pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 548 2016 catalogue. |
| Infernal Scene with Tree-Man / Standing Man | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; pen and brown ink · Dresden C 1875; historical reverse title includes a proposed prophet 2016 catalogue. |
| Job Triptych — Bruges | c.1510–1520 | 2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; oil on oak · Groeningemuseum / Hoeke loan in 2016 2016 catalogue. |
| Last Judgement — Bruges triptych | c.1495–1505 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Groeningemuseum 2016 catalogue. |
| Last Judgement — Munich fragment | c.1530–1540 | 2016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch; oil on oak · Alte Pinakothek 5752 2016 catalogue. |
| Last Judgement — Vienna triptych | c.1500–1505 (BRCP 2016) | Oil on oak · Bosch and workshop (BRCP 2016) · Academy of Fine Arts Vienna 2016 catalogue. |
| Man in a Basket and Comic Figures | Around 1500–1515 in the museum record | Pen and brown ink on paper; the reverse is catalogued as iron-gall ink · Hieronymus Bosch in the current Albertina record; attribution has been debated · Albertina, Vienna · 7797 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2. |
| Man Seen from Behind | About 1550–1569; About 1565–1570 | Traces of black chalk, pen and brush in light brown ink · Anonymous, circle of Pieter Bruegel the Elder · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam Source 1. Source 2. |
| Mary and John at the Foot of the Cross | About 1440 | Brush in grey and black · Unknown, possibly Netherlandish · Kupferstich-Kabinett, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden · C 815 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Model Sheet with ‘Witches’ | Disputed; proposals depend on the attribution | Pen and brown ink; the BRCP also records underlying black chalk · Hieronymus Bosch; follower attributions also recorded · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 19721 recto Source 1. Source 2. |
| Peasant and Three Bust-Length Figures | 1401–1500 | Brown pen over a black preliminary drawing · Attributed to the Master of the Drapery Studies; Bosch circle also recorded · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 777 Source 1. Source 2. |
| River to Hell — Venice | c.1505–1515 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on panel · Visions of the Hereafter · Venice 2016 catalogue. |
| Saint Anthony and a Concert in an Egg | Around 1510–1525 in the museum’s 2016–17 exhibition texts | Pen in light and dark brown inks · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch; underlying monsters: Bosch (BRCP), possibly Bosch (exhibition text) · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 711 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2. |
| Saint Christopher Carrying the Christ Child | c.1500; 1490–1505 in restoration material | Oil on panel · Bosch · Boijmans St 26 Object source. |
| Saint James and Hermogenes | About 1551–1575 in the KIK-IRPA catalogue | Oil on wood, painted on both sides · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée des Beaux-Arts, Valenciennes · P.46.1.44; older number 176 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Saint Jerome at Prayer | Circa 1485–1495 | Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Museum of Fine Arts, Ghent · 1908-H Source 1. Source 2. |
| Saint John on Patmos / Passion Scenes | c.1495–1505; estimates vary | Oil on oak · Bosch · Gemäldegalerie Berlin 1647A Object source. |
| Saint John the Baptist in Meditation | Late 15th century; c.1485–1510 (Prado exhibition) | Oil on panel · Bosch · Lázaro Galdiano 8155 Object source. |
| Saint Liberata Triptych | Circa 1495–1505 | Oil on oak panels · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia, Venice · 2045 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things | 1505–1510 (Prado) | Oil on poplar · Bosch (Prado); workshop/follower disputed · Prado Object source. |
| Ship of Fools — Louvre painting | 1475–1500 (record); c.1505–1515 (exhibition) | Oil on oak · Bosch · Louvre RF 2218; fragment Object source. |
| Ship of Fools — Louvre workshop drawing | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch · Pen, brush, grey-brown ink and white highlights on prepared paper · Louvre RF 3714 2016 catalogue. |
| Studies of Monsters | About 1530–1550, according to the current Ashmolean record | Pen and brown ink on laid paper, both faces · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford · WA1863.155 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Studies of Saint Anthony and Monsters | No execution date specified in the current Louvre records | Pen and brown ink on paper · Bosch listed; reverse questioned by Louvre; BRCP accepts both faces · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 20871 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2. |
| Temptation of Saint Anthony — Kansas City fragment | c.1500–1510 | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Nelson-Atkins 35–22 2016 catalogue. |
| Temptation of Saint Anthony — Lisbon triptych | c.1500 | Oil on oak · Bosch · Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga 1498 Pint Museum. |
| Temptation of Saint Anthony — Prado panel | c.1530–1540 | 2016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch (2016 opinion); oil on oak · Prado P002049 2016 catalogue. |
| Terrestrial Paradise | Approximately 1505–1515 | Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell'Accademia, Venice Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Burning Ship Drawing | 1500–1520 | Pen and iron gall ink on paper · Attributed to Hieronymus Bosch · Academy of Fine Arts Vienna, Graphic Collection · HZ-2554; numbered 2554 in the BRCP catalogue Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Comical Barber Scene | About 1550–1580, according to the British Museum | Pen and brown ink, grey and brown wash, over black chalk · Anonymous follower, after Hieronymus Bosch · British Museum, Department of Prints and Drawings, London · 1854,0628.46 Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Conjuror, After Hieronymus Bosch | Probably after 1525; around 1530–1540 in the BRCP technical report | Oil on oak panel · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée Ducastel-Vera, Saint-Germain-en-Laye · 872.1.87 Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Cure of Folly / Extraction of the Stone of Madness | 1501–1505 (Prado) | Oil on oak · Bosch (Prado); workshop/follower disputed · Prado P002056 Object source. |
| The Entombment Drawing | About 1505–1515, current museum record | Brush and black and grey ink, with grey wash, over black chalk · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch; drawn by the Master of the Prado Haywain Triptych; Hieronymus Bosch, argued by the BRCP in 2016 · British Museum, Department of Prints and Drawings, London · 1952,0405.9 Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Gathering of the Birds | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 13136 2016 catalogue. |
| The Haywain — Prado triptych | 1510–1516 (BRCP 2016) | Oil on oak · Bosch (BRCP 2016) · Prado; separate Escorial version exists 2016 catalogue. |
| The Hearing Forest and the Seeing Field | Circa 1500–1505 | Pen and brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch; reverse: Bosch and workshop · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 549, front and reverse Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Owl’s Nest — Rotterdam | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Boijmans N 175 2016 catalogue. |
| The Passion Triptych in Valencia | Workshop of Bosch, about 1510–1520; Follower of Bosch; centre about 1530–1540, wings about 1540–1550 | Oil and gold on oak panels · Workshop of Bosch, about 1510–1520; Follower of Bosch; centre about 1530–1540, wings about 1540–1550 · Museu de Belles Arts de València Source 1. Source 2. |
| The Pedlar / Wayfarer — Rotterdam | c.1500 (museum) | Oil on panel · Bosch · Boijmans 1079 (OK); rejoined exterior Object source. |
| The Tree-Man — Vienna drawing | c.1505 | Pen and brown ink · Bosch · Albertina, Vienna Object source. |
| The Wedding at Cana, After Hieronymus Bosch | Approximately 1560 in the current museum record | Oil on panel, 93 cm high × 72 cm wide · Anonymous, after Hieronymus Bosch · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam, St 25 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Two Fantastical Creatures — Berlin KdZ 550 | Around 1505–1515 in the museum’s 2016 exhibition text | Pen in brown ink on reddish prepared laid paper · Hieronymus Bosch · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 550, recto and verso Source 1. Source 2. |
| Two Figures Wearing Mitres | About 1480 | Oil on panel · Anonymous (Boijmans); Bosch circle (RKD) · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · 1177 (OK) Source 1. Source 2. |
| Two Men and the Temptation of Eve | About 1505–1515 in the Prado’s 2016 exhibition guide | Pen and grey-brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch in the 2016 catalogues discussed here · Private collection, as recorded in 2016 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Two Men Fighting | Not specified in the current Louvre record | Pen and brown ink · In the manner of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 20660 recto; formerly NIII 8896 and MA 8400 Source 1. Source 2. |
| Two Men — Berlin KdZ 5210 | Not specified in catalogue heading | 2016 catalogue: Bosch questioned · Pen, brush, ink, chalk and white highlights · Berlin KdZ 5210; historical title Two Oriental Men 2016 catalogue. |
| Two Monsters — Berlin KdZ 547 | Approximately 1500–1510 in Berlin's 2016 exhibition catalogue; an estimated range | Pen and brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 547, drawn on both sides Source 1. Source 2. |
Frequently Asked Questions
The drawing is catalogued as Group of Ten Spectators. Overlapping bodies, varied headgear and different directions of looking hold the crowd together.[1]
It belongs to the Morgan Library & Museum, New York, inventory I, 112. The museum records Pierpont Morgan’s purchase in 1909.[1]
Discussion
Follow the crowd’s gestures towards an event outside the sheet and compare the competing attribution records.
Reader Insights
Follow the pointing hand beyond the surviving image. What information is withheld?
How do the banner and staffs organise the overlapping heads?
Which difference of gaze most strongly gives a spectator an individual presence?
Join the Conversation
Share a detail, comparison or question about Group of Ten Spectators, a Follower of Bosch below.
References
- The Morgan Library & Museum, Group of Ten Spectators, I, 112, complete current collection record, scholarly notes, inscriptions and provenance information. View source.
- BRCP Catalogue Raisonné (2016), object dates in catalogues 1, 2, 8, 15 and 20; catalogue 20 object metadata only for the Haywain comparison. View source
- Matthijs Ilsink and colleagues, Hieronymus Bosch, Painter and Draughtsman: Catalogue Raisonné (2016), catalogue 49, pp. 546–549, complete entry, notes and comparison plates. View source.
- Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, 2016 exhibition wall texts, p. 3: approximate date of KdZ 549. View source
- Saint Louis Art Museum, Christ Carrying the Cross, 630:2018, current record for an impression attributed to Cornelis Cort, after Lambert Lombard, published by Hieronymus Cock. View source.
- Splash image, Follower of Hieronymus Bosch, Group of Ten Spectators, around 1510–1540, pen and two brown inks on paper, Morgan Library & Museum, New York, I, 112. View source. View source.


