Hieronymus Bosch, attribution disputed, Model Sheet with ‘Witches’ (Sorcières et monstres), pen and brown ink over black chalk on paper, 20.4 × 26.5 cm according to the current museum record, Musée du Louvre, Paris, INV 19721 recto. Buy Art Prints Now
from Amazon

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


by
Tom Gurney BSc (Hons) is an art history expert with over 20 years experience
Published on June 19, 2020 / Updated on November 4, 2026
Email: tomgurney1@gmail.com / Phone: +44 7429 011000

A woman rides a wheel as though it were a horse. Above her, another sits across a baker’s paddle while an owl perches behind her. At the right, a bent body carries a tray and a flowering jug, and a rooster appears to pull the barrel beneath it. The drawing takes recognisable people, animals and household equipment, then assembles them into actions that could never work outside the picture.

This is the Louvre’s Sorcières et monstres, inventory INV 19721 recto, also known as the Model Sheet with ‘Witches’. The museum currently lists Hieronymus Bosch while recording competing attributions to followers.[1] The Bosch Research and Conservation Project’s 2016 catalogue argues for Bosch himself and qualifies the identification of the women as witches.[3] Both questions matter, but the sheet’s individual inventions deserve attention before either label becomes an answer to everything it contains.

At a Glance

  • Museum titleSorcières et monstres
  • Alternative titleModel Sheet with ‘Witches’
  • Current museum listingHieronymus Bosch; follower attributions also recorded
  • DateDisputed; proposals depend on the attribution
  • MediumPen and brown ink; the BRCP also records underlying black chalk
  • Dimensions20.4 × 26.5 cm in the Louvre record
  • CollectionMusée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris
  • InventoryINV 19721 recto
  • Important inscriptionA later attribution to Bruegel, rather than an artist’s signature

Compare these works across Bosch’s career

These date ranges are estimates, not a documented year-by-year sequence. These works provide context for the article; none is highlighted as the object discussed here.

Approximate dates
14801490150015101520

Saint Jerome at Prayer

Circa 1485–1495 [2]

Crucifixion with a Donor

Circa 1490–1500 (BRCP) [2]

Hermit Saints Triptych

Circa 1495–1505 [2]

Saint Liberata Triptych

Circa 1495–1505 [2]

The Hearing Forest and the Seeing Field

Circa 1500–1505 (Berlin exhibition) [4]

The Haywain Triptych

1510–1516 (BRCP) [2]

Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Annotated Details
  3. A Wheel Turned into a Mount
  4. Balancing the Impossible
  5. Smaller Figures and Unfinished Stories
  6. Why Call It a Model Sheet?
  7. Witches, Folly and Household Objects
  8. The Disagreement about Bosch’s Hand
  9. An Inscription and a Reassembled Sheet

Annotated Details from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches

The Louvre sheet assembles separate figures, baskets, animals and utensils. The traditional title and disputed attribution are discussed in the article.

Annotated details from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches by Bosch or a follower; attribution discussed in the article

Details from THE LOUVRE MODEL SHEET WITH WITCHES

These views follow four distinct areas without assigning every figure a single symbolic meaning.

1

Figures and utensils above

The upper left places human figures beside long-handled implements. A basket carried above a head creates a different balance from the upright figure beside it.

Figures and utensils above detail from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches by Bosch or a follower; attribution discussed in the article
2

The large round table

Two figures gather at a large circular table. Its broad woven-looking edge and the objects near their hands make this a compact scene within the sheet.

The large round table detail from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches by Bosch or a follower; attribution discussed in the article
3

The figure within a curved vessel

A hooded figure sits inside a broad curved form beneath a small table. A rooster stands beside the vessel, separating this group from the figures at the left.

The figure within a curved vessel detail from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches by Bosch or a follower; attribution discussed in the article
4

The lower-right figures

A small figure with a basket-like covering moves near a standing woman. The long pole over her shoulder continues the sheet’s repeated use of thin diagonal objects.

The lower-right figures detail from The Louvre Model Sheet with Witches by Bosch or a follower; attribution discussed in the article

Image and detail crops: Wikimedia Commons source 1 (public domain reproductions).

A Wheel Turned into a Mount

The large wheel dominates the lower left. Its circular rim gives the seated figure a firm outline beneath the soft folds of her clothing. One bare foot stretches down across the wheel’s interior, while the seated body leans forward above it. The geometry is immediately legible even though the proposed form of transport is absurd.

Her arms introduce another set of contradictions. One hand raises a long basket overhead; the other directs a spinning implement horizontally like a weapon. The BRCP identifies this as a distaff used as a lance, with a pig’s foot suspended from it.[3] A domestic tool acquires the stance of martial equipment, yet its dangling attachment undermines the threat. The figure appears busy and purposeful without making her purpose rational.

A second figure bends in from the left towards the wheel. The upright basket above this person’s head repeats the material and shape of the larger basket, but on a much smaller scale. The two figures occupy a compact local group. Their relationship is one of the few places where the page suggests an immediate shared action, even though it supplies no setting that would explain what they are trying to achieve.

The strong circle also stabilises an otherwise scattered design. From a distance, the eye catches this wheel before it resolves all the thin shafts, fingers and woven surfaces around it. Looking closer reverses that hierarchy: small objects become the source of the humour, and the wheel begins to seem like one ingenious component in an expanding collection of misused things.

Balancing the Impossible

The barrel group on the right develops a different form of instability. The figure’s head hangs low, turned towards the viewer, while the legs extend behind. Above the bent back, a broad tray supports a small jug filled with delicate sprigs. The jug’s calm upright position contradicts the body’s precarious arrangement. Such a load ought to fall, but the drawing makes its balance look momentarily possible.

The rooster beneath and to the left seems an inadequate source of traction for a barrel and its rider. Its lifted foot and spreading tail nevertheless give it a determined animation. Fine connections between bird and barrel invite the viewer to read the grouping as a vehicle. The effect depends on enough practical detail to suggest a mechanism, combined with proportions that make the mechanism ridiculous.

Above this group, a woman raises a long rake across the top of the page. Her sleeves open into broad hanging shapes, and her torso twists beneath her covered head. The rake’s thin shaft provides a nearly horizontal line against the vertical fall of her clothes. The pose is vigorous even though the page offers no hay, crop or other task for the tool.

At the upper left, the paddle rider lifts an object in one hand and holds a flat rectangular form in front of her body. The owl sits behind her on the projecting handle. The paddle’s narrow extension could suggest forward movement, but the bird’s stillness makes it a perch as well as an imaginary mount. The same object supports two incompatible uses within one small invention.

Smaller Figures and Unfinished Stories

Not every figure requires a large machine. Near the top, one carries a pot on her head and a bundle of projecting stems or twigs behind her shoulder. Her face is shown in profile, with the nose and open mouth clearly articulated. Below the pot, the head covering falls into a compact pattern of folds. The small, pointed marks of the bundle contrast with the rounded vessel above.

Another figure bends under a raised curved implement. The inward turn of the body makes a compressed shape between the more upright people beside it. At the lower right, a standing woman balances a long-handled implement across her shoulder and carries another angled object. These figures continue the page’s interest in how a tool can extend a body’s silhouette, even where the action remains difficult to name.

A figure near the bottom has an inverted basket over the head, leaving the face invisible. The exposed legs turn in opposite directions, creating a particularly unstable stance. An arrow appears to pierce both basket and body. The BRCP leaves even the figure’s sex uncertain.[3] The concealed head should therefore resist a confident identification simply because the familiar title encourages the viewer to see women throughout.

A separate creature crawls along the lower edge, its long curved tail rising above its back. It receives less space than the human inventions, but its low position changes the scale and rhythm of the page. The viewer moves from upright bodies to something close to the ground, then back towards the raised shafts and baskets. This movement supplies visual connections without requiring a single story to unite every motif.

Why Call It a Model Sheet?

The figures are dispersed across the paper with areas of empty space between them. Their actions do not develop through successive episodes, and there is no principal event to which they all respond. Even the diagonal hatching below several bodies stops short of creating a continuous landscape. Each invention can be read as a relatively independent unit.

The BRCP interprets that arrangement as evidence for a model sheet: a collection of figures available for later use. Its catalogue counts eight human figures and stresses their separate placement.[3] The interpretation explains why a drawing might contain such a variety of actions without composing them into a coherent gathering. An artist consulting the sheet could select a particular pose or combination of objects.

Calling it a model sheet does not establish the exact painting for which it was made. Nor does it prove that the page was handed around a large organised workshop. The useful observation is more modest: the layout makes individual motifs accessible. The drawing preserves a repertoire, while leaving the eventual circumstances of reuse open.

Witches, Folly and Household Objects

The traditional title directs attention towards witchcraft, but the evidence is uneven. Riding an implement, balancing a vessel or carrying a distaff can contribute to an image of unnatural behaviour without identifying a specific magical act. No caption names these people or explains a spell. Their peculiar actions are visible; their precise identities remain interpretations.

The BRCP consequently places witches in quotation marks. It notes affinities with witch imagery and reports that some figures were used as witches in a later painting by a Bosch follower in Brussels.[3] That connection helps explain the conventional title, but it does not turn the Louvre sheet into a record of an actual gathering or an illustration of a documented prosecution.

The contrast with Rotterdam’s Two Old Women is useful. That fragment, also traditionally called Two Witches, contains a woman with a distaff and another leaning on a stick. Its current museum title describes the people and their activity more neutrally.[5] The Louvre figures engage in much more impossible actions. Even so, the comparison shows why age, clothing or spinning equipment alone cannot securely establish witchcraft.

The Disagreement about Bosch’s Hand

Attribution also requires more than a shared taste for strange subjects. The BRCP argues for Bosch through small details of execution, including blossoms, a cockerel and the double line marking a foot’s instep. It compares the sheet with The Wood Has Ears, The Field Has Eyes, Tree-Man and the Rotterdam women. These are proposed connections between ways of drawing, rather than a claim that every unusual figure must be Bosch’s.[3]

The Louvre records a different range of conclusions. Fritz Koreny assigns the work to a follower around 1530–1550; Erwin Pokorny proposes an immediate follower around 1515–1520. Matthijs Ilsink retains the possibility of Bosch’s authorship.[1] The dates follow the different proposed relationships to Bosch. They should not be combined into one supposedly agreed execution period.

The disagreement also changes what the comparisons might mean. Repeated forms can support an argument for one artist’s hand, but a follower could know and adapt earlier inventions. The question is whether the particular line, construction and handling indicate the same maker. The BRCP answers affirmatively; the recorded follower positions show that this judgement remains contested. The museum’s Bosch listing can be reported accurately while preserving that uncertainty.

An Inscription and a Reassembled Sheet

Near the lower left, a later inscription names Bruegel and claims the drawing as his own work. It is an attribution added after the drawing was made, not a signature by Bruegel. The Louvre records acquisition for the Cabinet du Roi at the Mariette sale in 1775, when the sheet was catalogued under Pieter Bruegel the Elder.[1] The inscription helps explain that collecting history without settling the identity of the draughtsman.

The support has its own history. The BRCP condition report records that the sheet was cut vertically through the middle, then rejoined and reinforced. It also identifies a later border, stains and small tears.[3] The framed appearance in a modern photograph therefore combines the drawing with subsequent treatment and presentation. The visible edge is not automatically an original compositional decision.

Those interventions have not erased the inventiveness of the small figures. A wheel, basket, jug, rake or paddle remains recognisable as a familiar object while acquiring an impossible task. Looking across the page means repeatedly testing those combinations: how a body balances, where a shaft leads, what might pull a barrel. That sequence of small discoveries gives the drawing its particular force, whether its maker was Bosch or an artist working from his example.

Artworks and related attributions

Browse paintings, drawings and related attributions. Records group triptychs, fragments and two-sided sheets where appropriate. Dates follow the cited museum records or catalogue headings and are generally estimates. Rows marked “2016 catalogue” report that publication’s attribution and collection information; these are dated opinions, rather than a claim that every work is an accepted autograph Bosch.

79 records

NameDateMedium, attribution and collection
A CrossbowmanSecond half of the sixteenth centuryOil on oak panel · Copy after Hieronymus Bosch · Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid · P002695 Source 1. Source 2.
A Woman Spinning and an Old WomanMuseum estimates: about 1480–1490 for the women and 1500–1505 for the reverse; the precise chronology is disputedPen and brown and grey ink on the front; pen and brown ink on the reverse · Hieronymus Bosch · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · N 190 recto and verso (PK) Source 1. Source 2.
Adoration of the Child in CologneSecond half of the sixteenth centuryOil on oak panel · Imitator of Hieronymus Bosch, in the city collection record · Wallraf-Richartz-Museum & Fondation Corboud, Cologne · WRM 0474 Source 1. Source 2.
Adoration of the Magi in PhiladelphiaEarly sixteenth century in the museum record; around 1495–1520 in the BRCP catalogueOil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch in the museum record; workshop of Bosch in the 2016 BRCP catalogue · Philadelphia Museum of Art, John G. Johnson Collection, 1917 · 1321; museum object 103592 Source 1. Source 2.
Adoration of the Magi — New Yorkc.1470–14802016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Metropolitan Museum 13.26 2016 catalogue.
Adoration of the Magi — Prado triptychc.1494Oil on oak; grisaille exterior · Bosch · Prado P002048 Object source.
Adoration of the Magi — three associated fragmentsc.1515–15352016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch · Two Shepherds / Retinue in Philadelphia; associated Adoration in private collection in 2016 2016 catalogue.
Ascent of the Blessed — Venicec.1505–1515Oil on panel · Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia; Visions of the Hereafter Object source.
Battle of the Birds and MammalsNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 14715 2016 catalogue.
Beggars and MusiciansAround 1530–1540Ink and wash on paper · Unknown follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Albertina, Vienna · 7798 Source 1. Source 2.
Christ Carrying the Cross DrawingAround 1470 in the museum catalogueBlack chalk or charcoal, pen and brush in brown ink, white corrections · Anonymous, workshop of Rogier van der Weyden · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · N 81 recto and verso (PK) Source 1. Source 2.
Christ Carrying the Cross in ViennaAround 1490–1510 in the current KHM record and BRCP catalogueOil on oak, painted on both sides · Hieronymus Bosch; possible workshop involvement in the Passion side discussed by the BRCP · Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna · Gemäldegalerie, GG 6429 Source 1. Source 2.
Christ Carrying the Cross — El Escorialc.1495–15052016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Patrimonio Nacional 10014739 2016 catalogue.
Christ Carrying the Cross — Ghentc.1510–1516 (museum)Oil on panel · Bosch in museum listing; authorship disputed · MSK Ghent 1902-H Object source.
Christ Mocked — Londonc.1510Oil on wood · Bosch · National Gallery NG4744 Object source.
Concert in the Egg, After Hieronymus BoschAround 1561; third quarter of the sixteenth centuryOil on canvas · Anonymous, after Hieronymus Bosch · Palais des Beaux-Arts, Lille · P 816 Source 1. Source 2.
Conjurer / Comical Concert — Louvre drawingNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch (recto), follower (concert verso) · Pen and brown ink · Louvre INV 19197 2016 catalogue.
Conjurer / Cross-bearing and beggars — Liège sheetNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch (verso), follower (recto) · Pen and brown ink · Album d’Arenberg 534 2016 catalogue.
Crowning with Thorns — El Escorialc.1530–15402016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch; oil on oak · Patrimonio Nacional 10014743 2016 catalogue.
Crucifixion with a DonorCirca 1495–1505; Circa 1490–1500Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Royal Museums of Fine Arts of Belgium, Brussels · 6639 Source 1. Source 2.
Death and the Miser DrawingNot securely established; probably made after the paintingPen and brush, dark ink and white highlights on prepared paper · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch in the BRCP catalogue; alternatives recorded by the Louvre · Musée du Louvre, Department of Prints and Drawings, Paris · RF 6947, Recto Source 1. Source 2.
Death and the Miser — Washingtonc.1485/1490 (NGA)Oil on panel · Bosch · National Gallery of Art 1952.5.33 Object source.
Ecce Homo Triptych — Bostonc.1495–1500; wings c.1500/15032016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; oil on oak · Museum of Fine Arts Boston; several production phases 2016 catalogue.
Ecce Homo — Frankfurtc.1490Mixed technique on oak · Bosch · Städel 1577 Object source.
Fall of the Damned — Venicec.1505–15152016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on panel · Visions of the Hereafter · Venice 2016 catalogue.
Garden of Earthly Delights1490–1500 (Prado)Oil on oak; grisaille exterior · Bosch · Prado; triptych Object source.
Gluttony and Lust / Allegory of Intemperance — Yale fragmentc.1500–1510 (group dating)2016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Yale 1959.15.22; fragment associated with Ship of Fools 2016 catalogue.
Group of Ten Spectators, a Follower of BoschAround 1510–1540 in the current museum recordPen and two brown inks on paper, with a brown framing line · Follower of Hieronymus Bosch in the Morgan record; Bosch in the BRCP catalogue · Morgan Library & Museum, New York · I, 112 Source 1. Source 2.
Head of an Old WomanAbout 1500Oil on panel · Attributed to Jacob Cornelisz. van Oostsanen · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · 2439 (OK) Source 1. Source 2.
Hell and the Flood — Rotterdam panelsAround 1515 in the museum records; around 1510–1520 in the BRCP catalogueOil on oak panels · Jheronimus Bosch in the museum records; workshop of Bosch in the BRCP catalogue · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam Source 1. Source 2.
Hermit Saints TriptychCirca 1495–1505Oil on oak panels · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia, Venice · 2044 Source 1. Source 2.
Infernal LandscapeNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink, red accent · Private collection in 2016 2016 catalogue.
Infernal Scene with Anvil / Monster StudiesNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch; attribution debated in entry · Pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 548 2016 catalogue.
Infernal Scene with Tree-Man / Standing ManNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; pen and brown ink · Dresden C 1875; historical reverse title includes a proposed prophet 2016 catalogue.
Job Triptych — Brugesc.1510–15202016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch; oil on oak · Groeningemuseum / Hoeke loan in 2016 2016 catalogue.
Last Judgement — Bruges triptychc.1495–15052016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Groeningemuseum 2016 catalogue.
Last Judgement — Munich fragmentc.1530–15402016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch; oil on oak · Alte Pinakothek 5752 2016 catalogue.
Last Judgement — Vienna triptychc.1500–1505 (BRCP 2016)Oil on oak · Bosch and workshop (BRCP 2016) · Academy of Fine Arts Vienna 2016 catalogue.
Man in a Basket and Comic FiguresAround 1500–1515 in the museum recordPen and brown ink on paper; the reverse is catalogued as iron-gall ink · Hieronymus Bosch in the current Albertina record; attribution has been debated · Albertina, Vienna · 7797 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2.
Man Seen from BehindAbout 1550–1569; About 1565–1570Traces of black chalk, pen and brush in light brown ink · Anonymous, circle of Pieter Bruegel the Elder · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam Source 1. Source 2.
Mary and John at the Foot of the CrossAbout 1440Brush in grey and black · Unknown, possibly Netherlandish · Kupferstich-Kabinett, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen Dresden · C 815 Source 1. Source 2.
Model Sheet with ‘Witches’Disputed; proposals depend on the attributionPen and brown ink; the BRCP also records underlying black chalk · Hieronymus Bosch; follower attributions also recorded · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 19721 recto Source 1. Source 2.
Peasant and Three Bust-Length Figures1401–1500Brown pen over a black preliminary drawing · Attributed to the Master of the Drapery Studies; Bosch circle also recorded · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 777 Source 1. Source 2.
River to Hell — Venicec.1505–15152016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on panel · Visions of the Hereafter · Venice 2016 catalogue.
Saint Anthony and a Concert in an EggAround 1510–1525 in the museum’s 2016–17 exhibition textsPen in light and dark brown inks · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch; underlying monsters: Bosch (BRCP), possibly Bosch (exhibition text) · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 711 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2.
Saint Christopher Carrying the Christ Childc.1500; 1490–1505 in restoration materialOil on panel · Bosch · Boijmans St 26 Object source.
Saint James and HermogenesAbout 1551–1575 in the KIK-IRPA catalogueOil on wood, painted on both sides · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée des Beaux-Arts, Valenciennes · P.46.1.44; older number 176 Source 1. Source 2.
Saint Jerome at PrayerCirca 1485–1495Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Museum of Fine Arts, Ghent · 1908-H Source 1. Source 2.
Saint John on Patmos / Passion Scenesc.1495–1505; estimates varyOil on oak · Bosch · Gemäldegalerie Berlin 1647A Object source.
Saint John the Baptist in MeditationLate 15th century; c.1485–1510 (Prado exhibition)Oil on panel · Bosch · Lázaro Galdiano 8155 Object source.
Saint Liberata TriptychCirca 1495–1505Oil on oak panels · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell’Accademia, Venice · 2045 Source 1. Source 2.
Seven Deadly Sins and the Four Last Things1505–1510 (Prado)Oil on poplar · Bosch (Prado); workshop/follower disputed · Prado Object source.
Ship of Fools — Louvre painting1475–1500 (record); c.1505–1515 (exhibition)Oil on oak · Bosch · Louvre RF 2218; fragment Object source.
Ship of Fools — Louvre workshop drawingNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Workshop of Bosch · Pen, brush, grey-brown ink and white highlights on prepared paper · Louvre RF 3714 2016 catalogue.
Studies of MonstersAbout 1530–1550, according to the current Ashmolean recordPen and brown ink on laid paper, both faces · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford · WA1863.155 Source 1. Source 2.
Studies of Saint Anthony and MonstersNo execution date specified in the current Louvre recordsPen and brown ink on paper · Bosch listed; reverse questioned by Louvre; BRCP accepts both faces · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 20871 recto and verso Source 1. Source 2.
Temptation of Saint Anthony — Kansas City fragmentc.1500–15102016 catalogue: Bosch; oil on oak · Nelson-Atkins 35–22 2016 catalogue.
Temptation of Saint Anthony — Lisbon triptychc.1500Oil on oak · Bosch · Museu Nacional de Arte Antiga 1498 Pint Museum.
Temptation of Saint Anthony — Prado panelc.1530–15402016 catalogue: Follower of Bosch (2016 opinion); oil on oak · Prado P002049 2016 catalogue.
Terrestrial ParadiseApproximately 1505–1515Oil on oak panel · Hieronymus Bosch · Gallerie dell'Accademia, Venice Source 1. Source 2.
The Burning Ship Drawing1500–1520Pen and iron gall ink on paper · Attributed to Hieronymus Bosch · Academy of Fine Arts Vienna, Graphic Collection · HZ-2554; numbered 2554 in the BRCP catalogue Source 1. Source 2.
The Comical Barber SceneAbout 1550–1580, according to the British MuseumPen and brown ink, grey and brown wash, over black chalk · Anonymous follower, after Hieronymus Bosch · British Museum, Department of Prints and Drawings, London · 1854,0628.46 Source 1. Source 2.
The Conjuror, After Hieronymus BoschProbably after 1525; around 1530–1540 in the BRCP technical reportOil on oak panel · Anonymous follower of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée Ducastel-Vera, Saint-Germain-en-Laye · 872.1.87 Source 1. Source 2.
The Cure of Folly / Extraction of the Stone of Madness1501–1505 (Prado)Oil on oak · Bosch (Prado); workshop/follower disputed · Prado P002056 Object source.
The Entombment DrawingAbout 1505–1515, current museum recordBrush and black and grey ink, with grey wash, over black chalk · Workshop of Hieronymus Bosch; drawn by the Master of the Prado Haywain Triptych; Hieronymus Bosch, argued by the BRCP in 2016 · British Museum, Department of Prints and Drawings, London · 1952,0405.9 Source 1. Source 2.
The Gathering of the BirdsNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Berlin KdZ 13136 2016 catalogue.
The Haywain — Prado triptych1510–1516 (BRCP 2016)Oil on oak · Bosch (BRCP 2016) · Prado; separate Escorial version exists 2016 catalogue.
The Hearing Forest and the Seeing FieldCirca 1500–1505Pen and brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch; reverse: Bosch and workshop · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 549, front and reverse Source 1. Source 2.
The Owl’s Nest — RotterdamNot specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch; pen and brown ink · Boijmans N 175 2016 catalogue.
The Passion Triptych in ValenciaWorkshop of Bosch, about 1510–1520; Follower of Bosch; centre about 1530–1540, wings about 1540–1550Oil and gold on oak panels · Workshop of Bosch, about 1510–1520; Follower of Bosch; centre about 1530–1540, wings about 1540–1550 · Museu de Belles Arts de València Source 1. Source 2.
The Pedlar / Wayfarer — Rotterdamc.1500 (museum)Oil on panel · Bosch · Boijmans 1079 (OK); rejoined exterior Object source.
The Tree-Man — Vienna drawingc.1505Pen and brown ink · Bosch · Albertina, Vienna Object source.
The Wedding at Cana, After Hieronymus BoschApproximately 1560 in the current museum recordOil on panel, 93 cm high × 72 cm wide · Anonymous, after Hieronymus Bosch · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam, St 25 Source 1. Source 2.
Two Fantastical Creatures — Berlin KdZ 550Around 1505–1515 in the museum’s 2016 exhibition textPen in brown ink on reddish prepared laid paper · Hieronymus Bosch · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 550, recto and verso Source 1. Source 2.
Two Figures Wearing MitresAbout 1480Oil on panel · Anonymous (Boijmans); Bosch circle (RKD) · Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen, Rotterdam · 1177 (OK) Source 1. Source 2.
Two Men and the Temptation of EveAbout 1505–1515 in the Prado’s 2016 exhibition guidePen and grey-brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch in the 2016 catalogues discussed here · Private collection, as recorded in 2016 Source 1. Source 2.
Two Men FightingNot specified in the current Louvre recordPen and brown ink · In the manner of Hieronymus Bosch · Musée du Louvre, Département des Arts graphiques, Paris · INV 20660 recto; formerly NIII 8896 and MA 8400 Source 1. Source 2.
Two Men — Berlin KdZ 5210Not specified in catalogue heading2016 catalogue: Bosch questioned · Pen, brush, ink, chalk and white highlights · Berlin KdZ 5210; historical title Two Oriental Men 2016 catalogue.
Two Monsters — Berlin KdZ 547Approximately 1500–1510 in Berlin's 2016 exhibition catalogue; an estimated rangePen and brown ink on paper · Hieronymus Bosch · Kupferstichkabinett, Staatliche Museen zu Berlin · KdZ 547, drawn on both sides Source 1. Source 2.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are the women securely identified as witches?

The Louvre’s historical title is Witches and Monsters, but the BRCP qualifies that identification. Impossible actions and household equipment do not alone establish a precise witchcraft narrative.[1][3]

Is the attribution agreed?

The Louvre currently lists Bosch and records follower proposals. The BRCP argues for Bosch, while other scholars place it with a follower; the maker remains disputed.[1][3]

Is the Bruegel inscription a signature?

No. The inscription is a later attribution to Bruegel, not an accepted artist’s signature identifying the draughtsman.[1][3]

Is it the Rotterdam Two Witches sheet?

No. Louvre INV 19721 and Rotterdam N 190 are different objects. The Rotterdam women have a distaff and stick, whereas the Louvre sheet contains other figures and impossible combinations.[1][5]

Discussion

Look at the individual inventions before treating either the witch label or the artist’s name as settled.

Reader Insights

Editorial prompt · Close Looking

How does turning a wheel into a mount change a familiar object?

Editorial prompt · Comparison

Compare the woman on the baker’s paddle with the balancing figure at the right.

Editorial prompt · Context

Do the separate inventions form a story for you, or remain a collection of possibilities?

Join the Conversation

Share a detail, comparison or question about Model Sheet with ‘Witches’: The Louvre Drawing below.

References

  1. Musée du Louvre: Sorcières et monstres, INV 19721 recto, current collection record View source.
  2. BRCP Catalogue Raisonné (2016), object dates in catalogues 1, 2, 8, 15 and 20; catalogue 20 object metadata only for the Haywain comparison. View source
  3. Bosch Research and Conservation Project: Catalogue Raisonné, 2016, entry 39, pages 510–511 View source.
  4. Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, 2016 exhibition wall texts, p. 3: approximate date of KdZ 549. View source
  5. Museum Boijmans Van Beuningen: A Woman Spinning and an Old Woman, N 190 recto View source.
  6. Splash image, Hieronymus Bosch, attribution disputed, Model Sheet with ‘Witches’ (Sorcières et monstres), pen and brown ink over black chalk on paper, 20.4 × 26.5 cm according to the current museum record, Musée du Louvre, Paris, INV 19721 recto. View source. View source.